Salt Lake County v. Utah State Tax Commission

Annotate this Case

The Supreme Court affirmed the determination of the Utah State Tax Commission that the Property Tax Division correctly followed the requirements of the Aircraft Valuation Law, Utah Code 59-2-201 subsection 4, in determining the 2017 value of Delta Air Lines' aircraft, holding that Salt Lake County failed to demonstrate that the Law, as applied to Delta's 2017 assessment, violated the fair market value provision of the Utah Constitution.

For tax year 2017, the Division valued Delta's aircraft according to section 59-2-201's preferred methodology. The County appealed, arguing that the valuation did not reflect the fair market value of Delta's aircraft, in violation of the Utah Constitution. The Commission upheld the assessment, concluding that the County did not establish that the Legislature's preferred method of valuation did not reasonably reflect fair market value. The Supreme Court affirmed, holding that the Aircraft Valuation Law was not unconstitutional as applied by the Commission to assess the value of Delta's aircraft for tax year 2017.

Download PDF

0123ÿ5627257ÿ23ÿ389 ÿ 5ÿ 23257ÿ9 5 ÿ 27 ÿ 689 2 257ÿ27ÿ 1 ÿ 2 2 ÿ 65 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !ÿ " #$%&%ÿ'( $ ÿ()ÿ *%ÿ" + %ÿ()ÿ +*ÿ ÿ ,-. ÿ.-/!ÿ012 34ÿ 2 257 5ÿ 6ÿ 2 - ÿ, - !ÿ -7ÿ0188 ,, 1 ÿ9:;ÿ<!. -ÿ- =ÿ. !,4ÿ 0>4ÿ 3657? 7 36ÿ ÿ @>ÿABACBDEFÿ G9H;ÿ89IÿF4ÿABAEÿ JKLG;ÿ @MGNOGHÿD4ÿABAEÿ ÿ 1:ÿPGQKQK@:ÿR@Hÿ=GMKGSÿ@Rÿ-TG:UIÿ<GUKVK@:ÿ ÿ 2Q9Wÿ,Q9QGÿ 9Xÿ0@NNKVVK@:ÿ YZ;TGÿY9:GÿPW9:ÿ @>ÿC[\D[Dÿ ÿ -QQ@H:GIV]ÿ ,KNÿ^KLL4ÿ KN@QWIÿ->ÿ_@;KLI4ÿ_H9;LGIÿ0>ÿY@W:V@:4ÿ KN@QWIÿY>ÿ_IS9QGH4ÿ,9LQÿ.9`Gÿ0KQI4ÿR@HÿaGQKQK@:GHVÿ ,G9:ÿ<>ÿ=GIGV4ÿ-QQbIÿ^G:>4ÿ,9H9Wÿ!>ÿ^@L;OGHT4ÿ.9H@:ÿY>ÿ.K:;4ÿ 8KUWGLLGÿ->ÿ.@NO9H;K4ÿ-VVQ>ÿ-QQIbVÿ^G:>4ÿ,9LQÿ.9`Gÿ0KQI4ÿ R@HÿHGVa@:;G:Qÿ2Q9Wÿ,Q9QGÿ 9Xÿ0@NNKVVK@:ÿ ^9HIÿ=>ÿ W@HZa4ÿY9NGVÿ<>ÿ^KLV@:4ÿ0@LGÿP>ÿ0H@SQWGH4ÿ,9LQÿ.9`Gÿ0KQI4ÿ R@HÿHGVa@:;G:Qÿ<GLQ9ÿ-KHÿ.K:GV4ÿ :U>ÿ ÿ Y2, 0!ÿ -^! ÿ9ZQW@HG;ÿQWGÿ@aK:K@:ÿ@RÿQWGÿ0@ZHQ4ÿK:ÿSWKUWÿ 0 !JÿY2, 0!ÿ<2==- 4ÿ-,,10 - !ÿ0 !JÿY2, 0!ÿP!-=0!4ÿ Y2, 0!ÿP! !=,! 4ÿ9:;ÿY2, 0!ÿP1 .8- ÿc@K:G;>ÿ ÿ Y2, 0!ÿ -^! 4ÿ@aK:K@:ÿ@RÿQWGÿ0@ZHQ]ÿ de $(f ' d(eÿ gCÿ @ÿG:VZHGÿiQW9QÿG9UWÿaGHV@:ÿ9:;ÿU@Ha@H9QK@:ÿa9IVÿ9ÿQ9XÿK:ÿ aH@a@HQK@:ÿQ@ÿQWGÿR9KHÿN9H`GQÿM9LZGÿ@RÿWKV4ÿWGH4ÿ@HÿKQVÿQ9:TKOLGÿ aH@aGHQI4jÿQWGÿ2Q9Wÿ0@:VQKQZQK@:ÿHGkZKHGVÿQW9Qÿ9LLÿQ9:TKOLGÿaH@aGHQIÿOGÿ 0123ÿ2156ÿ789 3 ÿ ÿ31 ÿ78 00 8 ÿ 8 ÿ ÿ ÿ7 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !ÿ ÿ " #ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ! $ ÿ % # &ÿ ÿ' ÿ ( ÿ ÿ % ÿ')ÿ# *+,ÿ931-ÿ78 03+ÿ +ÿ &ÿ .ÿ /01/ 1+ÿ ÿ 203&ÿ ÿ9 ÿ2 4 # ÿ ! ÿ9 ÿ7 ÿ ( ÿ567 7 20ÿ')ÿ 4ÿ ' ( ÿ8ÿ/ ÿ1 ( ÿ9 # ÿ2 *1&ÿ* ( ÿ % ÿ ÿ ÿ! ÿ ÿ ( 4ÿ ÿ ÿ! $ ÿ% # ÿ ÿ ÿ ( # ÿ ) ÿ ÿ 4 '# ÿ ): ( +ÿ3 ÿ" ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ( ÿ ÿ* ÿ ÿ # ( ÿ ÿ ÿ1 ( ÿ 9 # ÿ2 *ÿ ÿ; # ÿ1 ÿ2 <ÿ ( ÿ # ÿ ÿ ÿ ! ÿ ' # *ÿ ÿ! $ ÿ% # ÿ ÿ% # ÿ ÿ ÿ9 ÿ7 +ÿ = ÿ? ÿ @ÿ) ÿ 203&ÿ ÿA )ÿ3 @ÿ; % ÿ% # ÿ; # < ÿ ( ÿ (( 4ÿ ÿ ÿ < ÿ ÿ! # 4)&ÿ* ( ÿ " ÿ ÿ; % ÿ ÿ ÿ 4 ÿ ÿ( ÿ! $ ÿ% # ÿ ÿ ( ÿ % #ÿ ( ÿ ÿ ÿ #)ÿ ÿ # ÿ ( ÿ' ÿ ÿ ÿ !' ÿ ÿ ( ÿ; # ÿ * +ÿ0 # ÿ2 $ ÿ7 )ÿ( ## 4 ÿ ÿ % # ÿ' ÿ ÿ9 ÿ0 ÿ3 @ÿ7 !! &ÿ 4ÿ ÿ ÿ % # ÿ% # ÿ ÿ9 ÿ7 ÿ' ( ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ # ( ÿ ÿ ÿ! $ ÿ% # ÿ ÿ; # < ÿ ( +ÿ3 ÿ7 )ÿ( ÿ ÿ ÿ % # ÿ! ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ% # ÿ ÿ ÿ ( ÿ 4ÿ 4 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ #ÿ' ÿ &ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ % ( ÿ ÿ ÿ ! ÿ ( ÿ ÿ 4 ÿ% # ÿ ÿ; # < ÿ )+ÿ =Bÿ3 ÿ7 !! ÿ( (# ÿ ÿ ÿ; % ÿ( ( #)ÿ ## * ÿ ÿ " ! ÿ ÿ ÿ1 ( ÿ9 # ÿ2 *ÿ ÿ ! 4ÿ ÿ 203ÿ% # ÿ ÿ; # < ÿ ( +ÿ3 ÿ7 !! ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ7 )ÿ ÿ ÿ( )ÿ ÿ' ÿ ÿ '# ÿ')ÿ (# ÿ ÿ( % ( 4ÿ % ( ÿ ÿ ÿ# 4 # < ÿ ÿ! ÿ ÿ% # ÿ ÿ ÿ '#)ÿ # ( ÿ ÿ! $ ÿ% # +ÿC ( ÿ ÿ 7 )ÿ ÿ ÿ! $ ÿ ÿ " ÿ )ÿ * 4&ÿ ÿ 7 !! ÿ (# ÿ ÿ #)ÿ ÿ # % ÿ% # ÿ! ÿ % ( ÿ')ÿ ÿ7 )+ÿ =8ÿ3 ÿ7 )ÿ ÿ ÿ( ÿ ÿ % *ÿ ÿ7 !! < ÿ ! +ÿ3 ÿ7 )ÿ( ÿ ÿ ÿ1 ( ÿ9 # ÿ2 *&ÿ ÿ # ÿ ÿ ÿ 203ÿ ! ÿ ÿ; # < ÿ ( &ÿ% # ÿ ÿ9 ÿ 7 < ÿ " ! ÿ ÿ )ÿ' ÿ ÿ !#)ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ! $ ÿ% # +ÿ0 ( ( ##)&ÿ ÿ7 )ÿ 4 ÿ ÿ ÿ1 ( ÿ9 # ÿ2 *< ÿ ÿ! # 4)ÿ # ÿ ÿ % # 4ÿ; # < ÿ ( ÿ' # *ÿ ÿ! $ ÿ% # +ÿ =5ÿ3 ÿ1 ( ÿ9 # ÿ2 *ÿ ## * ÿ ÿ7 !! ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ # % ÿ% # ÿ! ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ! ÿ ÿ ÿ '#)ÿ # ( ÿ ÿ! $ ÿ% # +ÿC ÿ ÿ (( ##)ÿ % $ ÿ ÿ )ÿ )ÿ% #% &ÿ( ÿ( ÿ! ÿ' ÿ! +ÿC ( ÿ ÿ 7 )ÿ ÿ ÿ! $ ÿ ÿ * 4ÿ ( )ÿ ÿ 44 ÿ ÿ # % ÿ % # ÿ! &ÿ ÿ( ÿ ! ÿ ÿ ÿ1 ( ÿ9 # ÿ ÿ ÿ 0123ÿ2156ÿ789 3 ÿ ÿ31 ÿ78 00 8 ÿ 7 ÿ ÿ ÿ93ÿ ÿ ÿ 2 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ! " ÿ #$ÿ % & ÿ' ÿ ( ÿ) *ÿ% *+ ÿ ' , ÿ *' &ÿ)ÿ ( ÿ9 (ÿ7 & , &-ÿ ./01234567ÿ 9:ÿ3( ÿ * * <ÿ =ÿ> ? & ÿ)ÿ@ * &ÿ>, & A &@ , &?ÿ * & A * ÿ@ & * <ÿ ÿ><ÿ ( ÿ9 (ÿ0 ÿ3 =ÿ7 %% & ÿ * ( *ÿ ( &ÿ><ÿ & ' , ÿ@,& -ÿBCCÿ931Dÿ78!6ÿEÿFGH H #I#JI JI J-ÿ3( ÿ7 %% &" ÿK* * <ÿ3 =ÿ! ' &ÿ *)*% ÿ ( ÿ * ? & ÿ % & ÿ ,>L @ ÿ ÿ* ' ÿ><ÿ ( ÿ7 %% &-ÿ931Dÿ 1! -ÿ78!6ÿMN:#H#1H#:I JI@J ÿMNN H KH: -ÿ 9$ÿO )* ÿ #$ ÿ ( ÿ! ' &ÿ ÿ * & ÿ * * ÿ,& *ÿ ÿ ,& *<ÿ * @(-ÿ1ÿ,& *<ÿ * @(ÿP' , Q Rÿ ( ÿ <& *? @ÿ& ,* ÿ )ÿ ÿ>, & " ÿ@ @ ' ÿ * * <-SÿBTUVÿWTXCÿYZV[ÿB ÿ\ \ ÿY] ÿ ÿ^VT_ÿ BVTVCÿ`TaÿY]bbcd ÿ#GGGÿ93ÿG ÿ9ÿ # ÿGN$ÿK- ÿFG -ÿ ÿP % Q Rÿ ÿ @ ,* ÿ ( ÿ) *ÿ% *+ ÿ' , ÿ)ÿQ RÿQ@R% &<" ÿ * * <ÿ * &?ÿ ? ( *ÿ ÿ ÿ &? ÿ,& -Sÿef ÿ 9Nÿ6% < &?ÿ ( ÿ,& *<ÿ * @( ÿ ( ÿ! ' &ÿ, ÿ ÿ @%> & &ÿ)ÿ (* ÿ * ÿ% ( ÿ ÿ *% & ÿ ( ÿ' , ÿ)ÿ &ÿ * & " ÿ * * <ÿ * &?ÿ ÿ ÿ &? ÿ,& -ÿ3( ÿ% ( ÿ@& ÿ )ÿ ( ÿ@ ÿ' , &ÿ% ( ÿ ( @(ÿP *% & ÿ * * <ÿ' , ÿ > ÿ&ÿ* ? & ÿ@ ÿ ÿ * @ &gSÿ ( ÿ &@% ÿ% ( ÿ ( @(ÿ P *% & ÿ * * <ÿ' , ÿ><ÿ@% , &?ÿ ( ÿ * & ÿ' , ÿ )ÿ & @ ÿ &@% ÿ? & * ÿ><ÿ ( ÿ * * <gSÿ & ÿ ( ÿ% *+ ÿ % ( ÿ ( @(ÿP = % & ÿ ( ÿ * @ ÿ ÿ ( @(ÿ@% * > ÿ * * ÿ ( ' ÿ> &ÿ> ,?( ÿ & ÿ -Sÿef ÿ9ÿ# -ÿ3( ÿ * * ÿ)*ÿ ( ÿ! ' &ÿ , ÿ ( &ÿ* @&@ ÿ ( ÿ' * , ÿ' , &ÿ% ( ? ÿ><ÿ ?& &?ÿ @(ÿ% ( ?<ÿ ÿ )) * & ÿ ?( ÿ> ÿ&ÿ ( ÿh, <ÿ )ÿ ( ÿ ' &@ ÿ & ÿ ( *ÿ) @ * ÿ)ÿ * ÿL, ?% & -ÿ3( ÿ% ( ÿ , ÿ & ÿ ( ÿ ?( ÿ ( ÿ ( ÿ! ' &ÿ @ ÿ&ÿ @(ÿ% ( ÿ@, ÿ ' *<ÿ><ÿ * & -ÿ 9Gÿ &ÿ #$ ÿ ( ÿ ? ,* ÿ & @ ÿ ( ÿ1 *@* ) ÿi , &ÿ2 ÿ > ( &?ÿ ÿ &? ÿ% ( ?<ÿ)*ÿ' , &?ÿ *@* ) ÿ ( &ÿ *% &# &?ÿ ( ÿ * * <ÿ =ÿ> ? &ÿ)ÿ * & -ÿ931Dÿ78!6ÿEÿFGH H #I J-ÿ0,> @ &ÿ ÿ* h, * ÿ ( ÿ7 %% &ÿ ÿ ÿ ( ÿ) *ÿ % *+ ÿ' , ÿ)ÿ *@* ) ÿ><ÿ, &?ÿ ( ÿP1 * & *ÿK* @ ÿj, SÿI1KjJ ÿ &ÿ * & ÿ & , *<ÿ * @ &?ÿ ,> @ &-ÿef ÿEÿFGH H #I JI>JI J-ÿ1& ÿ ( &ÿ ' , &?ÿ &ÿ * & " ÿ) ÿ ,> @ &ÿ ÿ *' ÿ)*ÿ &ÿ &@* % & ÿ & * ÿP) ÿ L, % & Sÿ)ÿP, ÿ ÿ ÿ% = %,%ÿ kÿ* ,@ &-Sÿ ef ÿEÿFGH H #I JI@JI J-ÿO, ÿ ( ÿ , ÿ *% ÿ ( ÿ7 %% &ÿ ÿ, ÿ lllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllÿ #ÿ3( ÿ ? ,* ÿ( ÿ % & ÿ9 (ÿ7 ÿ @ &ÿFGH H #ÿ &@ ÿ #$-ÿO, ÿ> @ , ÿ ( * ÿ( ' ÿ> &ÿ& ÿ% * ÿ@( &? ÿ ÿ ,> @ &ÿ ÿ ÿ@ ÿ ( ÿ@,** & ÿ' * &ÿ)ÿ ( ÿ@ -ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ 0123ÿ2156ÿ789 3 ÿ ÿ31 ÿ78 00 8 ÿ 8 ÿ ÿ ÿ7 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !ÿ" ÿ ÿ# $ÿ% ÿ !ÿ% % &ÿ ! % ÿ ÿ ÿ % ÿ $ÿ % !ÿ ÿ ÿ'1()*ÿ! ÿ ÿ $ + ,ÿ % ÿ ÿ - ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ % .ÿ !ÿ ÿ#% ÿ ! ,ÿ ÿ ÿ % ÿ % &ÿ& ! ÿ ÿ" % ÿ ÿ % $$ ÿ ,ÿ! ÿ % ÿ /.ÿ01 ÿ2ÿ345656789 :9!:9 :;ÿ9 :/ÿ <87ÿ ÿ678>;ÿ? @$ÿ &ÿ ,ÿ ÿ9 ÿ" $ÿ % !ÿ ,ÿ ÿ0 ÿ2 - ÿ7 ,/ÿ3 ÿ? $ ÿ !ÿ $ÿ678>ÿ $$ $$ ÿ ÿ? @$ÿ % ÿ %% ! &ÿ ÿ ÿ1 % ÿA ÿ 2 "@$ÿ ! $;ÿ % &ÿ#877Bÿ" & ÿ ÿ ÿ'1()*ÿ ! &,ÿ ÿ $ !ÿ% ÿ - ÿ $ÿ $ÿ ÿ67Bÿ ÿ !C $ /.ÿ <88ÿ3 ÿ1()ÿ ! &,ÿ $ !ÿ ÿ ÿD8 /Eÿ+ ÿ ÿ - ÿ ÿ ÿ? @$ÿ &ÿ ,/ÿ3 ÿ? $ ÿ $ ÿ !ÿ $ÿ ÿ? @$ÿ ,ÿ $ &ÿ " ÿ ÿ ! & $/ÿ3 ÿ % $ ÿ % ÿ $ !ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿD68/Fÿ+ ;ÿ !ÿ ÿ % ÿ % ÿ $ !ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿD 7/4ÿ+ /ÿG ÿ+ % $ ÿ ÿ 1 % ÿA ÿ2 "ÿ H $ÿ ÿ7 $$ ÿ ÿ $ ÿ ÿ1()ÿ" ÿ ÿ ÿ! $% ;ÿ ÿ? $ ÿ % !ÿ ÿ" & ÿ ÿ $ ÿ ÿ ! & $/ÿ <86ÿ3 ÿ7 ,ÿ +C % !ÿ+ ÿ ÿ7 $$ ÿ ÿ ÿ? $ @$ÿ 678>ÿ $$ $$ ÿ ÿ? @$ÿ ,;ÿ $$ &ÿ ÿ ÿ? $ ÿ! !ÿ ÿ $$ $$ÿ ÿ ,ÿ ÿ ÿ - ÿ ÿ !;ÿ ;ÿ !ÿ ÿ9 ÿ7 $ /ÿ ÿ$ ÿ ÿ ÿ & ;ÿ ÿ7 ,ÿ $ + !ÿ $ÿ " ÿ $ ÿ ÿDF>/Fÿ+ /ÿ3 ÿ7 ,@$ÿ $ ÿ $ !ÿ ÿ% + ÿ ÿ ÿ% $ ÿ % ;ÿ % ÿ % ;ÿ !ÿ$ %-5ÿ !ÿ! + 5+ $ !ÿ - ÿ % ;ÿ+ ÿ ÿ! !ÿ ÿ % ! ÿ ÿ1()ÿ /ÿ3 ÿ7 ,@$ÿ $ ÿ !ÿ ÿ ÿ! !ÿ ÿ $ ÿ ÿ 1()ÿ ÿ $ÿ H !ÿ+,ÿ ÿ1 % ÿA ÿ2 "ÿ+ % $ ;ÿ ÿ $ÿ ;ÿ ÿ! !ÿ ÿ % ÿ ÿ - ÿ /ÿ <8Fÿ? ÿ$ + !ÿ $ÿ " ÿ I @$ÿ ;ÿ + &ÿ ÿ 7 ,@$ÿ $ /ÿ? @$ÿ ÿ ! !ÿ ÿ + ÿ ÿ $ÿ ÿ ÿ 7 ,@$ÿ $ ;ÿ+ ÿ $ÿ ,ÿ% H ÿ" $ÿ ÿ ÿ7 ,@$ÿ I ÿ! !ÿ ÿ% $ ! ÿ ÿ % ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ1()ÿ ÿ ,ÿ ÿ % ÿ % &ÿ& ! ÿ $ÿ H !ÿ+,ÿ ÿ1 % ÿA ÿ 2 "/ÿ <8 ÿ3 ÿ7 $$ ÿ! !ÿ ÿ ÿ? $ @$ÿ $$ $$ ÿ $ &ÿ ÿ1()ÿ" $ÿ ÿ% % ÿ ÿ ! ÿ ÿ1 % ÿA ÿ 2 "/ÿ3 ÿ7 $$ ÿ ÿ% % ! !ÿ ÿ ÿ7 ,ÿ !ÿ ÿ ÿ $ÿ+ ! ;ÿ $ÿ H !ÿ+,ÿ ÿ1 % ÿA ÿ2 ";ÿ ÿ$ ÿ $ &ÿ ÿ ÿ !ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ? @$ÿ ,/ÿG % $ ÿ #' * ÿ $ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ3 Iÿ7 $$ ÿ ÿ! ÿH $ $ÿ ÿ & ,ÿ ÿ% $ ,ÿ ÿ & $ ÿ % $;.ÿJKLKMKNÿ ÿOPQRÿSPQPKÿ ÿ ÿ 0123ÿ2156ÿ789 3 ÿ ÿ31 ÿ78 00 8 ÿ 7 ÿ ÿ ÿ93ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !!"#$ÿ %ÿ93ÿ& $ÿ'ÿ% $ÿ ÿ() *ÿ%+ ÿ,-. / *ÿ012$ÿ 3 ÿ 7455 4/ÿ* *ÿ/4 ÿ **6 ÿ 3 ÿ740/ 78 ÿ-4/ 0 4/ .ÿ-3 .. /9 )ÿ '% ÿ33 ÿ7455 4/ÿ013 .*ÿ 3 ÿ; < 4/8 ÿ %&ÿ 5 / ÿ4=ÿ ; . 8 ÿ1641 6 7)ÿ33 ÿ740/ 7ÿ1 4/ ÿ=46ÿ6 < >ÿ4=ÿ 3 ÿ 7455 4/8 ÿ* 65 / 4/)ÿ? ÿ3 < ÿ@06 * - 4/ÿ 4ÿ6 < >ÿ 3 ÿ 7455 4/8 ÿ* - 4/ÿ0/* 6ÿ9 3ÿ74* ÿ - 4/ÿ&+1A A% , 2, 2, 2)ÿ BCCDEÿGHIÿCJGHIGKIÿLMÿKENBEOÿ '%Pÿ33 ÿ740/ 7ÿ-3 .. /9 ÿ 3 ÿ-4/ 0 4/ . 7ÿ4=ÿ 3 ÿ1 6-6 = ÿ Q .0 4/ÿ2 >ÿ ÿ 11. *ÿ 4ÿ 3 ÿ %&ÿ 5 / ÿ4=ÿ; . 8 ÿ 6-6 = )ÿ RS - 0 ÿ ÿ ÿ/4 ÿ=46ÿ 3 ÿT3U VÿT7U455 4/ÿ 4ÿ* 65 / ÿW0 4/ ÿ 4=ÿ. 9 . 7ÿ46ÿ-4/ 0 4/ . 7ÿ4=ÿ. 9 . < ÿ / - 5 / $ÿ> ÿ3 < ÿ/4ÿ 9 /-7ÿ* - 4/ÿ 4ÿ6 < >Xÿ6 9 6* /9ÿ 3 ÿ-4/ 0 4/ . 7ÿ4=ÿ 3 ÿ 1 6-6 = ÿQ .0 4/ÿ2 >)ÿYZ[\ #ÿ][^_ `ÿa ÿ ÿbc dÿec cfÿ ÿ !!"#$ÿ ÿ93ÿP$ÿ'ÿg$ÿ gÿ() *ÿ +ÿ,-. / *ÿ012)ÿ? ÿR 3 6 =46 ÿ **6 ÿ 3 ÿ -4/ 0 4/ . 7ÿ4=ÿ 3 ÿ 0 ÿ=46ÿ 3 ÿ= 6 ÿ 5 ÿ ÿ ÿW0 4/ÿ4=ÿ. >)Xÿ hi ÿ GHGjkCBCÿ '%&ÿ33 ÿ740/ 7ÿ 690 ÿ 3 ÿ 3 ÿ1 6-6 = ÿQ .0 4/ÿ2 >ÿ ÿ 0/-4/ 0 4/ .ÿ ÿ 11. *ÿl7ÿ 3 ÿ7455 4/ÿ 4ÿ ÿ 3 ÿ< .0 ÿ4=ÿ ; . 8 ÿ 6-6 = ÿ=46ÿ Vÿ7 6ÿ %&)ÿ9/* 6ÿ 3 ÿ9 3ÿ74/ 0 4/$ÿR -3ÿ 1 6 4/ÿ /*ÿ-46146 4/ÿ1 7 ÿ ÿ Vÿ /ÿ164146 4/ÿ 4ÿ 3 ÿ= 6ÿ5 6m ÿ < .0 ÿ4=ÿ3 $ÿ3 6$ÿ46ÿ ÿ /9 l. ÿ1641 6 7)Xÿ931nÿ78 03)ÿ 6 )ÿ $ÿ oÿ ,%2)ÿ1/*ÿ 0-3ÿ Vÿ50 ÿl ÿR *ÿ ÿ ÿ0/ =465ÿ /*ÿ W0 .ÿ6 ÿ /ÿ 164146 4/ÿ 4ÿ ÿ= 6ÿ5 6m ÿ< .0 )Xÿhi ÿoÿ ,%2, 2)ÿ '%+ÿRpq 6ÿ5 6m ÿ< .0 8ÿ5 / ÿ 3 ÿ 540/ ÿ ÿ>3 -3ÿ1641 6 7ÿ >40.*ÿ-3 /9 ÿ3 /* ÿl > /ÿ ÿ> .. /9ÿl07 6ÿ /*ÿ ÿ> .. /9ÿ .. 6$ÿ / 3 6ÿl /9ÿ0/* 6ÿ /7ÿ-4510. 4/ÿ 4ÿl07ÿ46ÿ ..ÿ /*ÿl4 3ÿ3 < /9ÿ 6 4/ l. ÿm/4>. *9 ÿ4=ÿ 3 ÿ6 . < / ÿ= - )Xÿ931nÿ78;6ÿoÿ gA A % ,% 2, 2)ÿ /ÿ4 3 6ÿ>46* $ÿR 3 ÿ< .0 4/ÿ=46ÿ 5 / ÿ /*ÿ V 4/ÿ 3 ..ÿl $ÿ ÿ/ 6ÿ ÿ ÿ6 4/ l.7ÿ16 - - l. $ÿ W0 .ÿ 4ÿ 3 ÿ- 3ÿ16 - ÿ =46ÿ>3 -3ÿ 3 ÿ1641 6 7ÿ< .0 *ÿ>40.*ÿ ..ÿ /ÿ 3 ÿ41 /ÿ5 6m )Xÿri ÿsÿ tttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttÿ ÿ u 14/* / ÿ9 3ÿ0 ÿ3 Vÿ7455 4/ÿ= . *ÿ ÿ. 6ÿ /ÿ. 0ÿ4=ÿ ÿ l6 =ÿ /9ÿ 3 ÿ ÿ m ÿ/4ÿ14 4/ÿ4/ÿ 3 ÿ 0 ÿl =46 ÿ0 $ÿ- /9ÿ vf\fwf[ÿ ÿbc dÿec cfÿ ÿ !!"#$ÿ %ÿ93ÿ& $ÿ'ÿ% $ÿ ÿ() *ÿ%+ )ÿ? ÿ /4 $ÿ34> < 6$ÿ 3 ÿ . 34093ÿ 3 ÿ7455 4/ÿ. -m ÿ@06 * - 4/ÿ 4ÿ60. ÿ 4/ÿ 3 ÿ-4/ 0 4/ . 7ÿ4=ÿ ÿ 0 $ÿ ÿ ÿ/4 ÿ1643 l *ÿ=645ÿ m /9ÿ ÿ 14 4/ÿ4/ÿ 3 ÿ5 6ÿ ÿ ÿ1 6 7)ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ 0123ÿ2156ÿ789 3 ÿ ÿ31 ÿ78 00 8 ÿ 8 ÿ ÿ ÿ7 ÿ ÿ !"#$"%&ÿ%'ÿ(!$ÿ)*+ÿ,&$- ÿ ÿ.$/ÿ($$+ÿ01ÿ,%223 &ÿ+1ÿ4+! ÿ 5+&6/2 4*7ÿ8&6 9ÿ: ;ÿ<=>?ÿ::>9ÿ::@ÿA9 B ÿCDDEFÿAGH B ?ÿ F=Eÿ ICDÿK ÿL ÿ MÿNMB O ÿPBH Qÿ RÿB ÿS R ÿB ÿB T MB =UÿV"%ÿ W!X%2ÿ,%4Y ÿ ÿ(&ÿZ &ÿ,&$- 9ÿ :Cÿ<=>?ÿC:;9ÿCD>ÿA9 B ÿCD:;F=ÿ0 ÿ L[?\ R ÿ[ \ÿ] ? G BHÿB ?ÿR B ^ÿ? R9ÿN[ B \ÿMB O ÿPBH Qÿ MB RÿBÿ H ?ÿR B ?B ?=Uÿ5+&6/2 4*7ÿ8&6 9ÿ: ;ÿ<=>?ÿB ÿ::@_ÿ`++ÿ!`%ÿ"a ÿ B ÿCD>=ÿ I>bÿ3 ÿH c RHB ÿ BRÿG R BHÿB ^ÿ ÿ? M ÿ ÿ M ?ÿS^ÿd G ÿ B ÿMB O ÿPBH ÿ RÿBRR RR ?=ÿV"%ÿW!X%2ÿ,%4Y 9ÿ :Cÿ <=>?ÿB ÿCDCeD>_ÿ`++ÿ!`%ÿ5+&6/2 4*7ÿ8&6 9ÿ: ;ÿ<=>?ÿB ÿ::@=ÿ9 B QRÿ G R ÿ? G B Rÿ B ÿ B ÿMB O ÿPBH ÿ RÿL ÿS ÿBRG B ?ÿBRÿ P ? ?ÿS^ÿHBd=Uÿ931fÿ78 03=ÿB =ÿ 9ÿgÿ>ACFABF=ÿ1GG ? cH^9ÿ ? ÿ ÿG R 9ÿL[ \ ÿM ?ÿ ÿ^B ?R GOÿS^ÿd G ÿ=ÿ=ÿ=ÿ[ B ÿMB O ÿ PBH \ÿ Rÿ ÿS ÿ? M ?ÿR BHHÿS ÿ RG S ?ÿS^ÿ ÿH c RHB =UÿV"%ÿ W!X%2ÿ,%4Y 9ÿ :Cÿ<=>?ÿB ÿCDCeDEÿA6"$"&Xÿ.&"$+aÿ($$+`ÿ(2+!$"&X7ÿV+'"& ÿhÿ i"&"&Xÿ,% ÿ ÿj -&+`9ÿCk ÿ<=>?ÿ >>9ÿ >kÿA9 B ÿCD;kFF=ÿ I>Cÿ3 ÿB ÿL M Rÿ M HB ÿ R ?ÿ ÿ? M ÿMB O ÿ PBH UÿB ?ÿ? ÿPBH B ÿM ?RÿGB ÿS ÿ R ?ÿ ÿBRR RRÿ? ÿ O ?Rÿ ÿ ^=ÿ8a ÿB ÿCD>=ÿ ÿ ÿd ?R9ÿ ÿG R ÿ? Rÿ ÿ lllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllÿ Eÿ m ÿ RÿG ÿ? G ? ?ÿ5%4aÿ%'ÿ !"#$"%&ÿ%'ÿ(!$ÿ)*+ÿ,% &$- ÿ ÿ.$/ÿ($$+ÿ01ÿ,%22"``"%&ÿ+1ÿ4+! ÿ5+&6/2 4*7ÿ8&6 9ÿ: ;ÿ<=>?ÿ::>A9 B ÿ CDDEF9ÿ ÿG R BHÿHB c Bc ÿB ÿ RR ÿ R ? ?ÿ ÿB GH ÿ 9ÿ R G ÿE=ÿ ÿCDDE9ÿB GH ÿ 9ÿR G ÿ>ACFÿ P ? ?nÿ 1HHÿ B c SH ÿ ^ÿ ÿ ÿR B 9ÿ ÿ T M ÿ ? ÿ ÿ HBdRÿ ÿ ÿ9 ?ÿ0 B R9ÿ ÿ ? ÿ Rÿ7 R 9ÿ R BHHÿS ÿ BT ?ÿB ÿBÿ MÿB ?ÿ o BHÿ B ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ RÿPBH 9ÿ ÿS ÿBRG B ?ÿBRÿ P ? ?ÿS^ÿHBd[=\ÿ 1 ?ÿB GH ÿ 9ÿR G ÿEÿ P ? ?ÿ ÿ B nÿ 3 ÿ2 c RHB ÿR BHHÿ P ? ÿS^ÿHBdÿBÿ MÿB ?ÿ o BHÿ B ÿ ÿBRR RRM ÿ ÿBHHÿ B c SH ÿ ^ÿ ÿ ÿ R B 9ÿBGG ? cÿ ÿ RÿPBH ÿ ÿM ^ÿ=ÿ=ÿ=ÿ=ÿ3 ÿ 2 c RHB ÿR BHHÿ RG S ÿS^ÿHBdÿR G ÿ P R RÿBRÿ R BHHÿR G ÿBÿ] R ÿPBH B ÿ ÿ BTB ÿ ÿR G ÿ ^9ÿR ÿ B ÿ P ^ÿ R ÿB ?ÿG B ÿR BHHÿ B^ÿ Bÿ BTÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿPBH ÿ ÿ R9ÿ 9ÿ ÿ Rÿ B c SH ÿ ^ÿ=ÿ=ÿ=ÿ=ÿ 0 G ÿ 9ÿ ÿ9 B ÿ7 R ÿ BRÿS ÿBM ? ?ÿR ÿ B ÿ ÿ MB BHÿHB c Bc ÿB ÿ RR ÿ RÿG B ?ÿ ÿB GH ÿ 9ÿR G ÿ>=ÿ(++ÿ 931fÿ78 03=ÿB =ÿ 9ÿgÿ>_ÿ`++ÿ!`%ÿ( 22"$ÿp $+4ÿq"`$4"r ÿ,% ÿ ÿ.$/ÿ ($$+ÿ01ÿ,%223&9ÿ>bCCÿ93ÿ;E9ÿIÿ>>ÿ = 9ÿ>@Dÿ<=E?ÿCb@@=ÿ3 RÿM P 9ÿB ?ÿ ÿG B c Rÿ ÿ ÿHB c Bc 9ÿ? ÿ ÿBH ÿ ÿB BH^R R=ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ 0123ÿ2156ÿ789 3 ÿ ÿ31 ÿ78 00 8 ÿ 7 ÿ ÿ ÿ93ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ! ÿ" # $%ÿ& ÿ! &#ÿ&'ÿ# ! ( ()ÿ* + ÿ ++ÿ , ÿ #ÿ- ÿ . $ ÿ &ÿ ++ÿ% (# ÿ&'ÿ. &. "/0ÿ123456ÿ748459ÿ7:5;432<=ÿ >5?32 ÿ@ÿA3232<ÿBC DÿE FÿG/ #ÿ ÿF /ÿ3 ÿ ÿ, $ ÿ H*I + &(ÿ ÿ (ÿ Dÿ(& ÿ ÿ $ ($ /ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ' ($ &(ÿ&'ÿJ #)! ( Dÿ(& ÿ&'ÿ( +ÿ+ -/0ÿK;48ÿ L8M ÿK99CM9 =ÿN46 ÿ ÿ148Oÿ74845ÿP8QÿBC::R2DÿS EÿG/ #ÿE DÿE TÿU9 ÿ ESS VÿU$+ ( #ÿ .V/ÿ W ÿ3 & ) ÿ ÿ ## &(ÿ&'ÿ ÿ1 $ ' ÿY + &(ÿ2 -Dÿ ÿ + ) + ÿ ÿ. $ , #ÿ ÿ. ' #ÿ! &#ÿ'& ÿ* + ()ÿ&( ÿ ". ÿ&'ÿ . &. "Z $ ' ÿ&-( #ÿ,"ÿ + ( ÿ $ÿ ÿ[ + /ÿ3 ÿ ÿ & # ( +"ÿ ÿ ÿ7&!! &(ÿ &ÿ ÿ ÿ1G\ÿ &ÿ# ! ( ÿ ÿ ' ÿ! % ÿ* + ÿ&'ÿ (# * # +ÿ $ ' /ÿ931]ÿ78[6ÿ^ÿ_S` ` EU VU,VU V/ÿ3 ÿ1G\ÿ ÿ ÿ( &( ++"ÿ $&)( a #ÿ. ,+ $ &(ÿ ÿ )( ÿ* + ÿ ! ÿ'& ÿ (# * # +ÿ$&!! $ +ÿ $ ' 0ÿ ÿ ÿ (ÿ * ) ÿ$&(# &(ÿ ". $ +ÿ'& ÿ ÿ $ ' b ÿ ". ÿ (#ÿ* ( ) /0ÿc6 ÿ ^ÿ_S` ` EU VU V/ÿ 'ÿ ÿ1G\ÿ#& ÿ(& ÿ. &* # ÿ'& ÿ ÿ'+ ÿ #J ! ( Dÿ ÿ ÿ + &ÿ ÿ ÿ7&!! &(ÿ &ÿ # $ ÿ ÿ* + ÿ&'ÿ $ÿ $ ' ÿ (ÿ ÿ'+ ÿ,"ÿ/_dÿ'& ÿ $ÿ $ ' ÿ&* ÿ ÿ $ ' ÿ .ÿ &ÿ ÿ ! e ! !ÿ dÿ # $ &(/0ÿc6 ÿ^ÿ_S` ` EU VU$VU V/ÿ8($ ÿ ÿ 7&!! &(ÿ # ( ' ÿ ÿ1G\b ÿ$ ( ÿ! % ÿ* + ÿ'& ÿ $ÿ (# * # +ÿ $ ' ÿ (#ÿ ..+ ÿ ÿ'+ ÿ #J ! ( Dÿ ÿ ## ÿ & ÿ * + ÿ &) ÿ &ÿ * ÿ ÿ ÿ & +ÿ* + ÿ&'ÿ ++ÿ $ ' ÿ&-( #ÿ,"ÿ ÿ . $ + ÿ + ( /ÿf $ ÿ ÿ! &#ÿ ## ÿ &) ÿ ÿ * ) ÿ . $ ÿ ÿ ÿ, " ÿ-& +#ÿ. "ÿ'& ÿ $ÿ (# * # +ÿ $ ' ÿU!&# ' #ÿ,"ÿ ÿ'+ ÿ #J ! ( Dÿ 'ÿ ..+ $ ,+ VDÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !! &(ÿ .. & $/ÿ W ÿ1+ & ) ÿ ÿ ÿ&'ÿ ÿ1G\ÿ ÿ ÿ. ' #ÿ! &#ÿ'& ÿ * + ()ÿ $ ' Dÿ ÿ ÿ. &* # ÿ ÿ ' "ÿ* +* ÿ 'ÿ ÿ7&!! &(ÿ ÿ '' $ ( ÿ * # ($ ÿ ÿ ÿ1G\ÿ#& ÿ(& ÿ &( ,+"ÿ '+ $ ÿ' ÿ ! % ÿ* + /ÿ755ÿ36 ÿ^ÿ_S` ` EU VU#V/ÿ3 ÿ7&!! &(ÿ! "ÿ ÿ (ÿ + ( * ÿ! &#ÿ&'ÿ* + ()ÿ $ ' ÿ 'ÿ -&ÿ$&(# &( ÿ ÿ! gÿUEVÿ ÿ 7&!! &(ÿ ÿ$+ ÿ (#ÿ$&(* ($ ()ÿ * # ($ ÿ ÿ ÿ $ ' ÿ * + ÿ '+ $ #ÿ (ÿ ÿH1G\Iÿ#&ÿ(& ÿ &( ,+"ÿ '+ $ ÿ' ÿ! % ÿ * + ÿ&'ÿ ÿ $ ' D0ÿ (#ÿU Vÿ ÿ7&!! &(ÿ $ ((& ÿ # ( '"ÿ (ÿ + ( * ÿ. $ ()ÿ) # ÿ' &!ÿ- $ÿ ÿH7I&!! &(ÿ! "ÿ # ! ( ÿ $ ' ÿ* + /0ÿc6 ÿ^ÿ_S` ` EU VU#VU VhU V/ÿ W ÿ3 ÿ7& ( "ÿ$&( (# ÿ ÿ ÿ & "ÿ $ ! Dÿ ÿ ..+ #Dÿ * &+ #ÿ ÿ9 ÿ7&( &(ÿ, $ ÿ ÿ# #ÿ(& ÿ ++&-ÿ ÿ 7&!! &(ÿ &ÿ ÿ[ + b ÿ&. ()ÿ. &. "ÿ ÿ' ÿ! % ÿ* + /ÿ 3 ÿ7& ( "ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ. * ( #ÿ ÿ7&!! &(ÿ' &!ÿ $ ()ÿ' ÿ! % ÿ* + ÿ (ÿ ÿ- " /ÿi Dÿ ÿ7& ( "ÿ " ÿ ÿ ÿ! (# ÿ ÿ! &#&+&)"ÿ ÿ (# * + ÿ $ ' ÿ #ÿ ÿ . ÿ&'ÿ (ÿ&. ()ÿ + ( ÿ (#ÿ % ÿ - "ÿ ÿ7&!! &(b ÿ # $ &(ÿ &ÿ ..+"ÿ ÿ ( "ÿ* + &(ÿ .. & $Dÿ- $ÿ ÿ7& ( "ÿ , + * ÿ-& +#ÿ!& ÿ $$ +"ÿ '+ $ ÿ' ÿ! % ÿ* + ÿ&'ÿ $ÿ ÿ ÿ 0123ÿ2156ÿ789 3 ÿ ÿ31 ÿ78 00 8 ÿ 8 ÿ ÿ ÿ7 ÿ ÿ ÿ0 !"ÿ ÿ7 #ÿ$ #$ÿ ÿ ÿ$ ÿ% & $ÿ ÿ $ ÿ' $ ÿ ÿ ( $ÿ ÿ7 )) $$ ÿ ÿ &#ÿ ÿ & ÿ ! $ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ) ÿ ÿ !ÿ ÿ$ ÿ ÿ ! ÿ $ÿ ÿ * % ÿ ÿ$ ) & ÿ # ÿ3 !"ÿ ÿ7 #ÿ$ #$ÿ ÿ$ ÿ% & $ÿ ÿ $ ÿ' $ ÿ ÿ ( $ÿ ÿ7 )) $$ ÿ ÿ $ ÿ ÿ & ÿ !ÿ % *ÿ % ! ÿ$ ! !ÿ+ ÿ% & *ÿ ÿ % ÿ * ÿ &&ÿ ÿ , # ÿ $$ $$) $ÿ ÿ$ '- ÿ ÿ ÿ ! ÿ ÿ ÿ % ! ÿ$ ! ! ÿ ./0ÿ1& * ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ7 #2$ÿ ÿ * ) $ÿ+ &!ÿ $ ) '&#ÿ &#ÿ ÿ #ÿ & ÿ ÿ ÿ1 ÿ3 & ÿ2 +"ÿ ÿ $ÿ! $ % + !ÿ #ÿ &ÿ && * ÿ !ÿ $ $ $ÿ ÿ $ÿ * ) $ÿ ÿ % +ÿ ÿ& ) !ÿ ÿ+ ÿ ÿ$ ÿ $ÿ $ &ÿ $ÿ & !ÿ ÿ ÿ/456ÿ $$ $$) ÿ ÿ7 & 2$ÿ # ÿ3 "ÿ+ ÿ! ÿ ÿ$ &#ÿ $ ! ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ7 #2$ÿ * ) $8+ ÿ ÿ $ 2$ÿ !ÿ) ! & *#"ÿ & ÿ! $ "ÿ ÿ $ ÿ ÿ ÿ & ÿ !ÿ % *ÿ % ! ÿ$ ! !ÿ% & ÿ ÿ9 ÿ7 $ ÿ ÿ ÿ '$ ÿ9 ÿ $ ! ÿ &#ÿ+ ÿ ÿ1 ÿ3 & ÿ2 +"ÿ $ÿ & !ÿ ÿ7 & 2$ÿ/456ÿ ,ÿ $$ $$) "ÿ% & !ÿ ÿ9 ÿ7 $ ÿ '#ÿ% & *ÿ7 & 2$ÿ ÿ' & +ÿ ÿ) : ÿ% & ÿ ./;ÿ9 ÿ' * ÿ ÿ &#$ $ÿ ÿ ÿ$ 2$ÿ $ & #ÿ<+ ÿ ÿ $ ÿ ÿ $ÿ ÿ ÿ2 * $& ÿ ÿ $ ) !ÿ $ &"ÿ $ &&#ÿ+ ÿ! & *ÿ+ ÿ ) ÿ) $ÿ' $ !ÿ ÿ &ÿ $$ ) $ =ÿ>?@ÿABC@DÿE@FG "ÿ; 5ÿH /!ÿ ÿ5I4 ÿ<3 ÿ $ ) ÿ ÿ $ & #ÿ & $ÿ+ ÿ & ÿ ÿ ÿ ,ÿ$ $ =ÿJK ÿ ÿ 5I5LÿMNN@FKÿOPM PFÿEQRS ÿ ÿT?BUPBVÿJQN "ÿ/444ÿ93ÿ/I"ÿ.ÿ5 "ÿII0ÿH /!ÿ;4/ ÿ 1 !ÿ+ ÿ $ &% ÿ< #ÿ $ '& ÿ! ' $ÿ ÿ % ÿ ÿ $ & # =ÿ JQÿFPÿEW?BKPFXYZFMS"ÿ/4/5ÿ93ÿ5["ÿ.ÿ5\"ÿ\ 6ÿH [!ÿI;ÿ] & !ÿ ^ ÿ<_3` ÿ #ÿ : *ÿ ÿ $ & #ÿ ÿ ÿ$ ÿ $ÿ ÿ' ! ÿ ÿ ) % &#ÿ! ) $ *ÿ ÿ ÿ$ ÿ $ÿ $ & =ÿ T?BUPBVÿJQN "ÿ/444ÿ93ÿ/I"ÿ.ÿ5 ÿ] & !ÿ ^ ÿ3 $ÿ $ÿ< ÿ %#ÿ' ! "=ÿ ( *ÿ ÿ #ÿ ÿ< % ! ÿ ÿ$ ÿ' $ $ÿ ÿ$ ÿ && * "ÿ !ÿ ÿ) &#ÿ ÿa) :#2ÿ' $ $ÿ ÿ$ *ÿ_ ÿ$ `ÿ $ ! =ÿJQÿFPÿ EW?BKPFXYZFMS"ÿ/4/5ÿ93ÿ5["ÿ.ÿ; ÿ] & !ÿ ^ ÿ ./6ÿ1ÿ$ ÿ<) #ÿ' ÿ $ &ÿ ÿ ÿ $ÿ ÿ ÿ $ÿ & !ÿ ÿ ÿ $ÿ ÿ ÿ* % ÿ $ =ÿZ?BBD@Fÿ ÿbcDD?RÿEQRS "ÿ/454ÿ93ÿ ;I"ÿ.ÿ/6"ÿ/\;ÿH [!ÿ54/ÿ] & !ÿ ^ ÿ< ÿ ÿ $d & !ÿ && * "ÿ ÿ #ÿ ! $ÿ ÿ ÿ && * !ÿ$ ÿ) #ÿ' ÿ &&#ÿ $ &"ÿ ' ÿ * $ÿ ÿ ! ÿ ÿ & ÿ $ÿ ÿ ÿ #2$ÿ $ "ÿ ÿ $ ÿ+ $ÿ & !ÿ ÿ ÿ $ &ÿ) =ÿJK ÿ.ÿ/6ÿ] & !ÿ ^ ÿ3 ÿ) ÿ ÿ' ! ÿ ( !ÿ ÿ ÿ $d & !ÿ $ &ÿ && * "ÿ ÿ7 #ÿ) $ ÿ$ +ÿ ÿ< ÿ+ $ÿ$ ) *ÿ ( &#ÿ $ &ÿ ' ÿ ÿ+ #ÿ ÿ+ ÿ ÿ_1 & ÿ3 & ÿ2 +`ÿ +_ $`ÿ & !ÿ =ÿ7 & 2$ÿ/456ÿ $$ $$) ÿJK ÿ.ÿ[4 ÿ ÿ ÿ 0123ÿ2156ÿ789 3 ÿ ÿ31 ÿ78 00 8 ÿ 7 ÿ ÿ ÿ93ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !ÿ" # ÿ $# ÿ ! ÿ ÿ"# % &ÿ'ÿ ÿ" '(ÿ) ! ÿ7 *' +ÿ ,* ÿ ! -ÿ ! ÿ ! ÿ1 #.# / ÿ0 &* 'ÿ2 -(ÿ ÿ ""& 1ÿ2+ÿ ! ÿ 7 ,, '(ÿ# *& 1ÿ 'ÿ3 & 4 ÿ 5 2& ÿ" # '$ÿ"#" # +ÿ2 '$ÿ 1ÿ2 &-ÿ/ #ÿ, #6 ÿ% &* ÿ7 '1ÿ !* ÿ.' # #+ÿ ÿ9 !ÿ7 ' 8ÿ # 8ÿ (ÿ9ÿ 7:;;8<ÿ= ÿ.'.&*1 ÿ ! ÿ ! ÿ7 *' +ÿ! ÿ' ÿ, ÿ ÿ2*#1 '8ÿ ÿ3! ÿ7 *' +ÿ. '' ÿ1 , ' # ÿ ! ÿ ! ÿ ""& . 'ÿ/ÿ ! ÿ 1 #.# / ÿ0 &* 'ÿ2 -ÿ# *& 1ÿ 'ÿ*'1 #% &* '$ÿ3 & 4 ÿ #.# / ÿ 2 . * ÿ ÿ1 1ÿ' ÿ/*&&+ÿ % &ÿ &/ÿ/ÿ ! ÿ / +ÿ% &% ÿ"#% 1 1ÿ 'ÿ ! ÿ * 8ÿ3! ÿ1 #.# / ÿ0 &* 'ÿ2 -ÿ &&- ÿ ! ÿ7 ,, 'ÿ ÿ* ÿ 'ÿ & #' % ÿ% &* 'ÿ, ! 1ÿ /ÿ ! ÿ"# / ## 1ÿ1>?ÿ, ! 1ÿ1 ÿ' ÿ # /& . ÿ/ #ÿ, #6 ÿ% &* 8ÿ931@ÿ7836ÿ9ÿA B B :7 ;71;8ÿ /# ÿ 'ÿ & #' % ÿ, ! 1ÿ. 'ÿ2 ÿ* 1(ÿ! - % #(ÿ ! ÿ * ÿ# C* # ÿ - ÿ .'1 ' ÿ ÿ2 ÿ, 8ÿDE ÿ3! ÿ7 *' +(ÿ ÿ ! ÿ"#" ' ' ÿ/ÿ* '$ÿ 'ÿ & #' % ÿ, ! 1ÿ/#ÿ% &* '$ÿ3 & 4 ÿ"#" # +(ÿ! 1ÿ ! ÿ2*#1 'ÿ/ÿ 2& ! '$ÿ2 !ÿ.'1 ' 8ÿFGGÿHIJKÿLM ÿNO ÿ ÿHIJKÿFIJIGÿPJQÿNORRST(ÿ ÿ93ÿ (ÿ ÿU(ÿAÿ>8 1ÿUA ÿ7' '$ÿ ! ÿ ! ÿ"# '$ÿ 5" + #ÿ! 1ÿ ! ÿ2*#1 'ÿ ÿ 2& !ÿ - ÿ.'1 ' ÿ2 /# ÿ ! ÿ7 ,, 'ÿ.*&1ÿ 1 " ÿ ÿ&- #ÿ% &* ';8ÿ ÿ3! ÿ/ # ÿ.'1 'ÿ 'ÿ . 'ÿ7 ;71;ÿ# C* # ÿ).& #ÿ '1ÿ .'% '. '$ÿ % 1 '. ÿ ! ÿ ! ÿ #.# / ÿ% &* ÿ# /& . 1ÿ 'ÿ ! ÿV1>?Wÿ1 ÿ ' ÿ# ' 2&+ÿ# /& . ÿ/ #ÿ, #6 ÿ% &* ÿ/ÿ ! ÿ #.# / 8<ÿ931@ÿ7836ÿ 9ÿA B B :7 ;71;7 ;8ÿ 'ÿ *"" # ÿ /ÿ ÿ ! - '$ÿ*'1 #ÿ *2 . 'ÿ 7 ;71;7 ;(ÿ ! ÿ7 *' +ÿ // # 1ÿ % 1 '. ÿ ! ÿ ÿ*' #+ÿ% &* 'ÿ , ! 1X *.!ÿ ÿ ! ÿ '., ÿ, ! 1X# /& . 1ÿ ! ÿ/ #ÿ, #6 ÿ% &* ÿ /ÿ3 & 4 ÿ #.# / ÿ2 . * ÿ ÿ% &* 1ÿ ! ÿ #.# / ÿ ÿ ÿ! $! ÿ '1ÿ2 ÿ * (ÿ ! ÿ (ÿ ÿ)" # ÿ/ÿ ÿ*' ÿ/ÿ #ÿ # ' " # 'ÿ"#" # +ÿ/*'. ' '$ÿ ÿ ÿ$ '$ÿ.'. #'8<ÿ3! ÿ7 *' +4 ÿ ""# #ÿ " ' 1ÿ ! ÿ ! ÿ *,, 'ÿ, ! 1ÿ# C* # 1ÿ2+ÿ ! ÿ1 #.# / ÿ0 &* 'ÿ2 -ÿ1 1ÿ' ÿ ) &&-ÿ ! ÿV7 ,, 'Wÿ ÿ, ÿ ! ÿ.' * ' &&+ÿ, '1 1ÿ/ #ÿ , #6 ÿ% &* ÿ '1 #1<ÿ-! 'ÿ '$ÿ3 & 4 ÿ #.# / ÿ2 . * ÿ 3 & 4 ÿ"#" # +ÿ.*&1ÿ' ÿ2 ÿ% &* 1ÿ ÿ ÿ)! $! ÿ '1ÿ2 ÿ* (<ÿ -! .!ÿ- *&1ÿ2 ÿ ÿ" # ÿ/ÿ 'ÿ" # '$ÿ #& ' 8ÿ3! ÿ1 ' ÿ3 # . #ÿ /ÿ ! ÿ3 % 'ÿ& #$ &+ÿ $# 1(ÿ 5"& ' '$ÿ ! ÿ 2 ' ÿ ! ÿ1 #.# / ÿ 0 &* 'ÿ2 -(ÿ! ÿ- *&1ÿ& 6 &+ÿ"& . ÿ ! ÿ, ÿ- $! ÿ'ÿ 'ÿ '., ÿ ""# .!ÿ-! 'ÿ% &* '$ÿ ! ÿ" # '$ÿ"#" # +ÿ/ÿ 'ÿ #& ' ÿ2 . * (ÿ )'ÿ 'ÿ '., B"#1*. '$ÿ"#" # +(ÿ. !ÿ/&-ÿ ÿ ! ÿ"# , #+ÿ1# % #ÿ /#ÿ! -ÿ ! ÿ"#" # ÿ # ÿ2 *$! ÿ '1ÿ &1ÿ '1ÿ! -ÿ8ÿ8ÿ8ÿ ! +4# ÿ % &* 18<ÿ1'1ÿ ! ÿ ' $ #ÿ/ÿ ! ÿ3 % 'ÿ , & #&+ÿ / 1ÿ ! (ÿ 2 ' ÿ ! ÿ1 #.# / ÿ0 &* 'ÿ2 -(ÿ! ÿ- *&1ÿ! % ÿ# & 1ÿ"# , # &+ÿ'ÿ ! ÿ '., ÿ ""# .!ÿ2 . * ÿ)-! 'ÿ2*+ # ÿ '1ÿ && # ÿ/ÿ ! ÿ*' #+ÿ "#" # ÿ& 6 ÿ3 & ÿ8ÿ8ÿ8ÿ$ ÿ ' ÿ ! ÿ, #6 ÿ ÿ2*+ÿ ! ÿ +" ÿ/ÿ "#" # (ÿ ! +ÿ"# , # &+ÿ # ÿ& 6 '$ÿ ÿ '., ÿ ""# .! ÿ ÿ% &* 8<ÿ ÿ ÿ 0123ÿ2156ÿ789 3 ÿ ÿ31 ÿ78 00 8 ÿ 8 ÿ ÿ ÿ7 ÿ ÿ ÿ3 ÿ7 !ÿ"#$ ÿ $ %ÿ & % ' ÿ " ÿ"ÿ " !ÿ&"# " ÿ ( %ÿ) #%ÿ&"# ÿ* # "+$ÿ "#ÿ " ,ÿ !ÿ( ' ÿ , ÿ " ÿ ÿ$ " !ÿ$ ((" ÿ( %ÿ #! ,ÿ ÿ ÿ1-./ÿ9$ ,ÿ ÿ 1-.+$ÿ&"# $ÿ ÿ "' ÿ" ' " ÿ" %ÿ" #! ,ÿ ÿ # ÿ% $' ÿ "'' % ,ÿ ÿ ÿ1 ' " ÿ0"# " ÿ2")1ÿ ÿ7 (( $$ ÿ'"#' #" %ÿ ÿ " ÿ(" 2 ÿ&"# ÿ ÿ* # "+$ÿ " ,ÿ !ÿ" ÿ3 4/5ÿ6 ## /ÿ 9$ ,ÿ"ÿ " !ÿ( %ÿ ÿ' ( " $ ÿ $ # %ÿ ÿ"ÿ " ÿ(" 2 ÿ&"# ÿ 6 ) ÿ3 7/8ÿ6 ## ÿ" %ÿ34 /7ÿ6 ## /ÿ 9ÿ: ÿ $ $ÿ ÿ $ÿ & )ÿ) ÿ"$$ ( 1ÿ) ÿ% ' % ,1ÿ " ÿ $ÿ & % ' ÿ)"$ÿ$ ' ÿ ÿ & ÿ6!ÿ'# " ÿ" %ÿ' & ' ,ÿ & % ' ÿ " ÿ ÿ1-.ÿ( %ÿ&"# %ÿ* # "+$ÿ" ' " ÿ6 # )ÿ " ÿ(" 2 ÿ&"# 1ÿ $" $ ! ,ÿ ÿ$" !ÿ&"#& +$ÿ $ ÿ' % /ÿ; ÿ & ÿ ÿ ÿ $ ÿ ' % ÿ $ÿ$" $ %1ÿ ÿ7 (( $$ ÿ'" ÿ $ ÿ" ÿ"# " & ÿ &"# " ÿ( %ÿ # $$ÿ ÿ7 (( $$ ÿ<'" ÿ % !ÿ" ÿ "# " & ÿ" ' " ÿ ' ,ÿ, % ÿ (ÿ) ' ÿ ÿ' (( $$ ÿ("!ÿ % ( ÿ" ' " ÿ&"# /=ÿ>? @ÿ87A9A9 B4CB%CB C/ÿ3 ÿ7 !ÿ "$ÿ ÿ $ ) ÿ " ÿ ÿ( ÿ " ÿ$ ' %ÿ' % /ÿ ÿ3 ÿ7 !ÿ% $ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ" !ÿ & % ' ÿ ÿ ÿ ' %ÿ " ÿ ) #%ÿ$" $ !ÿ$ 6$ ' ÿB4CB%CB C/ÿ1$ÿ ÿ7 (( $$ ÿ ' , D %1ÿ ÿ 7 !+$ÿ E ÿ% %ÿ ÿ & % ÿ<" !ÿ% $' $$ ÿ ÿ" "#!$ $ÿ ," % ,ÿ ÿ0 6$ ' ÿB4CB%CB Cÿ F ( /=ÿ* # "+$ÿ E 1ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ " %1ÿ $ %ÿ " ÿ ÿ) ÿ ÿ" # ÿ ' ,ÿ, % $ÿ (ÿ ) ' ÿ ÿ7 (( $$ ÿ' #%ÿ "& ÿ% ( %ÿ" ' " ÿ&"# /ÿ1 %ÿ <G H ÿ ÿ' ( " %ÿ) " ÿ" ' " ÿ&"# ÿ) #%ÿ6 ÿ"' & %ÿ (ÿ ÿ ' ,ÿ, % $ÿ' ( " %ÿ ÿ ÿ1-./=ÿ1'' % ,#!1ÿ ÿ7 (( $$ ÿ ' '# % %ÿ " ÿ<0 6$ ' ÿB Cÿ "$ÿ ÿ6 ÿ"%% $$ %ÿ" %ÿ ÿ 7 !+$ÿ" , ( ÿ ÿ" ÿ"# " & ÿ( %ÿ ÿ&"# ,ÿ ÿ" ' " ÿ $ÿ $ %/=ÿ 4ÿI ÿ'" ÿ' '# % ÿ " ÿ ÿ1 ' " ÿ0"# " ÿ2")ÿ $ÿ ' $ "#ÿ"$ÿ" # %ÿ) ÿ ÿ7 !ÿ% %ÿ ÿ "2 ÿ"%&" ", ÿ ÿ ÿ$ " !ÿ$" !ÿ&"#& ÿ ÿ' "## , ÿ ÿ"$$ $$( ÿ ÿ* # "+$ÿ !/ÿ1# , ÿ ÿ7 !ÿ % ' %ÿ & % ' ÿ % ÿ$ 6$ ' ÿ B4CB%CB Cÿ " ÿ ÿ$ " +$ÿ$ ((" ÿ" "' ÿ % &"# %ÿ* # "+$ÿ " ' " ÿ ÿ' ( " $ ÿ ÿ"ÿ " !ÿ" "' 1ÿ ÿ & ÿ ( %ÿ " ÿ ' ( " $ ÿ ÿ ÿ"&" #"6# ÿ ' ,ÿ, % $ÿ"$ÿ F %ÿ6!ÿ $ 6$ ' ÿB4CB%CB C/ÿI ÿ ' , D ÿ " ÿ ÿ " ÿ ÿ ÿ7 !+$ÿ " , ( ÿ $ÿ " 1ÿ ," %# $$ÿ ÿ) " ÿ ' ,ÿ, % $ÿ" ÿ $ %1ÿ< ÿ ) #%ÿ, "##!ÿ6 ÿ' ' % "#ÿ ÿ ÿ$ " +$ÿ ! ÿ ÿ$ ((" ÿ ( % # ,!ÿ "' %ÿ " ÿ(" 2 ÿ&"# /=ÿ; ÿ ÿ7 !ÿ & ÿ " ( %ÿ ÿ$ )ÿ " ÿ ÿ"&" #"6# ÿ ' ,ÿ, % $ÿ) #%ÿ "& ÿ "' %ÿ " ÿ(" 2 ÿ&"# ÿ ÿ* # "+$ÿ" ' " ÿ ÿ $ÿ " ' #" ÿ'"$ /ÿ ÿ ÿ 0123ÿ2156ÿ789 3 ÿ ÿ31 ÿ78 00 8 ÿ 7 ÿ ÿ ÿ93ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ3 ÿ !ÿ ÿ ÿ1 "#" $ ÿ% &' (ÿ2 !ÿ ÿ'(# ( ' ( &ÿ ÿ ))& *ÿ ÿ+ & , ÿ -ÿ . ( /ÿ ÿ7 '( 0ÿ$ " ÿ( * *ÿ ÿ # && (1 ÿ ÿ2 &' (ÿ' (1ÿ ÿ. # ( .ÿ)" 2 * *ÿ30ÿ ÿ ' 4ÿ 5 " ÿ ÿ7 '( 0ÿ* *ÿ( ÿ$'&&0ÿ 2 &ÿ &$ÿ $ÿ ÿ ' , ÿ $ 0ÿ2 &2 /ÿ ! ÿ# (( ÿ# (#&'* ÿ ÿ ÿ ' ÿ ÿ'(# ( ' ( &ÿ ÿ ))& *ÿ (ÿ ÿ) " #'& "ÿ# 4ÿ 67869:;<78ÿ >ÿ? # ' ÿ ÿ7 '( 0ÿ$ & *ÿ ÿ$'&&0ÿ 2 &ÿ &$ÿ $ÿ9 ÿ7 * ÿ # (ÿ @A A B CB*CB C/ÿ ÿ# (( ÿ !ÿ ÿ ÿ1 "#" $ ÿ% &' (ÿ 2 !ÿ2 & *ÿ ÿ9 ÿ7 ( ' (ÿ ÿ ))& *ÿ ÿ+ & , ÿ -ÿ . ( 4ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ

Primary Holding

The Supreme Court affirmed the Utah State Tax Commission's determination that the Property Tax Division correctly followed the requirements of the Aircraft Valuation Law in determining the 2017 value of Delta Air Lines' aircraft, holding that the Law was not unconstitutional as applied to the Commission.

Disclaimer: Justia Annotations is a forum for attorneys to summarize, comment on, and analyze case law published on our site. Justia makes no guarantees or warranties that the annotations are accurate or reflect the current state of law, and no annotation is intended to be, nor should it be construed as, legal advice. Contacting Justia or any attorney through this site, via web form, email, or otherwise, does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.