KIRKLAND v. TREZEVANT

Annotate this Case

KIRKLAND v. TREZEVANT
1913 OK 455
134 P. 1198
38 Okla. 445
Case Number: 4991
Decided: 07/08/1913
Supreme Court of Oklahoma

KIRKLAND et al.
v.
TREZEVANT et al.

¶0 June, 1913, Decided

Error from Superior Court, Muskogee County; Farrar L. McCain, Judge. Action by J. T. Trezevant and others against Ira B. Kirkland, and others. Judment for plaintiffs, and defendants bring error. Dismissed.

Chas. F. Runyan and J. Fentress Wisdom, for plaintiffs in error.
Bert E. Nussbaum, for defendants in error.

¶1 a suit in damages for the breach of a bond, the superior court of Muskogee county, pursuant to stipulation of counsel for all parties in interest, on November 15, 1912, rendered and entered judgment in favor of plaintiffs and against defendants for $ 58.22 and $ 20 attorney's fees, and the latter, after motion for a new trial filed and overruled, in which they alleged "that the verdict is not sustained by sufficient evidence" and "is contrary to law," bring the case here. The judgment entry was approved before entry by defendants. The motion to dismiss is sustained, for the reason that the appeal is frivolous. In the language of Johnson v. St. Paul, etc., Co., 68 Minn. 408, 71 N.W. 619, we say:

"Notwithstanding decisions to the contrary, we are of the opinion that an appellate court has the inherent power to dismiss an appeal, which is manifestly and palpably frivolous and without merit. This power is necessary in order to prevent the court itself from being imposed upon, and the administration of justice being trifled with and perverted for mere purpose of delay."

¶2 All the Justices concur, except DUNN, J., absent and not participating.

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.