Brent Taylor v. Allen County Board of Commissioners, et al.
Annotate this Case
Download PDF
FILED Dec 13 2023, 3:11 pm CLERK Indiana Supreme Court Court of Appeals and Tax Court IN THE Indiana Supreme Court Supreme Court Case No. 23S-CT-378 Brent Taylor, Appellant-Plaintiff, –v– Allen County Board of Commissioners, et al., Appellees-Defendants. Decided: December 13, 2023 Appeal from the DeKalb Superior Court No. 17D02-2207-CT-35 The Honorable Monte L. Brown, Judge On Petition to Transfer from the Indiana Court of Appeals No. 23A-CT-131 Per Curiam Opinion Chief Justice Rush and Justices Massa, Slaughter, Goff, and Molter concur. Per curiam. Brent Taylor sued the Allen County Board of Commissioners, the Allen County Public Defender’s Office, and two individual Allen County public defenders. The trial court dismissed Taylor’s action against the Allen County Board of Commissioners and granted judgment on the pleadings to the Allen County Public Defender’s Office and the individual public defenders. Taylor appealed the trial court’s order. Following extensions of time, his appellant’s brief and appendix were due to be filed by June 9, 2023. Taylor timely filed a “Motion to File Appellant’s Brief and Appendix” on June 7 and tendered his brief and appendix with that motion. The Clerk then issued a Notice of Defect that specified three issues with Taylor’s brief and appendix that he needed to correct. The Notice of Defect gave Taylor, who is housed in the Indiana Department of Correction, twenty business days to submit corrected documents. Three days after the Clerk issued the Notice of Defect, the Indiana Court of Appeals issued an order dismissing Taylor’s appeal with prejudice. Taylor now seeks transfer and asks this Court to review the dismissal of his appeal. Discussion & Decision Indiana Appellate Rule 23 addresses correction of documents that are not compliant with the appellate rules: “Individuals who are incarcerated . . . and are not represented by an attorney must correct defect(s) no later than twenty (20) business days from the date of the Notice of Defect.” Ind. Appellate Rule 23(D)(1)(a). Indiana Appellate Rule 45 allows for an appeal to be summarily dismissed when an appellant’s brief is not timely filed. App. R. 45(D). The record here indicates that Taylor timely tendered his brief and appendix, and he had twenty days from the date on the Notice of Defect to cure the defects in those documents, making them due by July 19, 2023. The record also shows the Notice of Defect’s deadline had not yet expired at the time Taylor’s appeal was dismissed. Indiana Supreme Court | Case No. 23S-CT-378 | December 13, 2023 Page 2 of 3 Conclusion Under these circumstances, we find Taylor’s appeal was prematurely dismissed. We grant transfer, vacate the Court of Appeals’ order dismissing Taylor’s appeal, and remand for the Court of Appeals to resume jurisdiction over this appeal. See App. R. 58(A). Rush, C.J., and Massa, Slaughter, Goff, and Molter, JJ., concur. APPELLANT PRO SE Brent Taylor Michigan City, Indiana ATTORNEYS FOR APPELLEE ALLEN COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS Theodore T. Storer Alison M. Yeager Beers Mallers, LLP Fort Wayne, Indiana ATTORNEYS FOR APPELLEES WILLIAM LEBRATO AND GREGORY FUMAROLO John C. Theisen Nathaniel O. Hubley Theisen Hubley Law Fort Wayne, Indiana Indiana Supreme Court | Case No. 23S-CT-378 | December 13, 2023 Page 3 of 3
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
