State Of Washington, Respondent V. Sandy Jones, Appellant (Majority)
Annotate this Case
Download PDF
FILED COURT OF APPEALS DIVISION 11 2013 JUL -2 AM 9: 08 IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE i Ttgfiaq DIVISION II EpUTY No. 43538 1 II - - STATE OF WASHINGTON, Respondent, V. UNPUBLISHED OPINION SANDY JONES, PENOYAR J. Sandy Jones appeals from his judgment and sentence, arguing that the trial court erred by imposing legal financial obligations without finding that he had the present or likely future ability to pay those obligations. Finding no error that is ripe for review, we affirm. A jury found Jones guilty of possession of a stolen motor vehicle, first degree trafficking in stolen property, and forgery. At sentencing, the trial court imposed the following " tandard " s legal financial obligations: 500 victim assessment, 200 criminal filing fee, 250 jury demand $ $ $ fee, $ 000 court appointed attorney fee, $ 00 defense costs, $ 1, 4 500 fine, and $100 DNA collection fee. CP 10 11. - Jones's judgment and sentence form contained the following paragraph 2. : 5 Ability to Pay Legal Financial Obligations. The court has considered the total amount owing, the defendant's past, present, and future ability to pay legal financial obligations, including the defendant's financial resources and the likelihood that the defendant's status will change. The court finds: That the defendant has the ability or likely future ability to pay the legal financial obligations imposed herein. RCW 9. 753. 94A. 1 A commissioner of this court initially considered Jones's appeal as a motion on the merits under RAP 18. 4 and then transferred it to a panel of judges. 1 2 ( Report of Proceedings May 21, 2012)at 208 09 43538 1 II - - The following extraordinary circumstances exist that make restitution inappropriate (RCW 9. 753): 94A. The defendant has the present 760. 9. 94A. means to pay costs of incarceration. RCW Clerk's Papers at 8. The trial court did not check any of the boxes in paragraph 2. . 5 Jones argues that the trial court erred by imposing the legal financial obligations without making a finding that he had the current or likely future ability to pay them. State v. Bertrand, 165 Wn. App. 393, 405, 267 P. d 511 (2011), 3 review denied, 175 Wn. d 1014 (2012).But Bertrand held 2 that the trial court erred by finding that Bertrand had the current or likely ability to pay legal financial obligations without first "[ taking] into account the financial resources of the defendant and the nature of the burden"imposed by the legal financial obligations. Bertrand, 165 Wn. App at 404 (quoting State v. Baldwin, 63 Wn. App. 303, 312, 818 P. d 1116, 837 P. d 646 -1991)). 2 2 ( Because there was no evidence in the record to support the finding, we remanded with instructions to strike it. Bertrand, 165 Wn. App at 404 05. Here, by contrast, the trial court did not make a finding that Jones had the current or likely ability to pay legal financial obligations. Thus, there is no error under Bertrand for us to address at this time. And, as Bertrand and Baldwin hold, Jones's challenge to the legal financial obligations themselves only becomes ripe when the government seeks to collect the obligation."Bertrand, 165 Wn. App at 405 (quoting Baldwin, 63 Wn. App. at 310)emphasis in Bertrand omitted).Because the State has not sought ( to collect Jones's legal financial obligations, his appeal from them is not ripe. At the time the State seeks to collect, it will have to establish that Jones has the ability to pay them. Bertrand, 165 Wn. App at 405. 4 43538 1 II - - We affirm. A majority of the panel having determined that this opinion will not be printed in the Washington Appellate Reports, but will be filed for public record in accordance with RCW 040, 2.6.it is so ordered. 0 We concur: f Hunt, J. J Go 1 J Johanson, A. . J. C 3
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
