Jimmy Miles, Individually and as Next Friend of Michael Miles and Joseph Miles, minor children v. Jerry Kidd Oil Company--Appeal from 114th District Court of Smith County (majority)

Annotate this Case
HTTP/1.1 200 OK Cache-Control: private Content-Type: application/pdf Server: Microsoft-IIS/7.5 Content-Disposition: inline; filename=CCAOpinion.pdf X-Powered-By: ASP.NET Date: Tue, 06 Mar 2012 16:28:09 GMT Connection: close %PDF-1.5 %ãÏÓ 210 0 obj endobj 216 0 obj stream hÞbbd``b`š$[AÄ+ Á $¸¶‰w3˜,FÜÄÆ¿ îî endstream endobj startxref 0 %%EOF 224 0 obj stream hÞb```¢ ÉÎÀˀ¼@1fŽ‰ ɳwΘ÷Á Yáöœ™ ¬á ûÿ`8l8ãLš±dÏ1† ÆÉÐ`Áր¡$Ž³if›ÿŠ‡Y~ÎK"W'á´ Ø9œê@š‘¹HÉ20ÄQb:•Au«öy°6"Õ Éëë‹ÍX*E@n[‰ú¥XPX.öQßÚ¾«4ú2lŨ"&݉·Ò'i]+ÎJ›‹Öל•šSR‹R‹9ùŠÎ'ããXY­.1G÷á«ŸÆ&Áo|WÑGŸá7ÄUÇ1ÿ¾ö\«(ç[Z§²ÈÚïƽzÅü©³'g:Ë\:o¡*Á߯£¡‡  ñþ,Σöl9£À¬®Ž,ôjø\e5,ù@K"YµËåUÔ=SàîV¼‡§ É~š€CñýèKÍjŽÉ㧱²kPí÷¯jÚ×b°C‹Ô)0Ð cø¢†Gä7Ÿ±^ ÅÇ tч£sòàF„w;I¥mýzpLx{ËKˆ½ èöÎàwáÊÖ?Љ‘:r_h®Ýï«©eivª©:9«:½,áíí`bµ=??¿ãcz¯m">kgmQ¡ðoTQójªl>}^?Êtl,¥µ±uü•ìöT: BË´úIåv©írÿ§R_uSÿ#$.Á\¨œºy2fÝ­¢ü;Dãæ‹~¡7ªPù֘×¾Ñ •o&õ/ÛKþ•_=£ÜU¼@ÉØѳGX¿¡ø„žÅ­RÅ5„=©¸àbµ šG{6ÒH­w*XíLHÚ¾5!é¯_èxª.˜ªÁ¿m+×ÞBm¯ðyÔR‘;×±Þ(­`bGL¹"g×3£Ï§5¢ˆB•Iïg‘* ,Î?#¨Æ.bXüB9€¦ÐRÄÑÄ=x©Ðx"uÁû³èŸ¾#(AY?Q›ä}î¤Æ§T¥=y¥ Iq›eûpè,YÍ õõÎÞˆ)‹Rœash¥½ÁäYt*Š:ˆLWèŸÄÕïvR/᫧ðS 3BÓwB#)T]å)Y19Àqå WBZ"t)Ÿõ j¨yʼ->Î]!¹9ÒàÿÄa²›EK¢€$O-G`¹Ÿ™³è£Kˆ6àVtç„9=ÓEL2‰‰o"߆£Cª¤*"8PK£´Èj›­ëqsÓ²*Cþs°¤ý YîûVªr1œRî[YAž&G¦¨Äö-w"bç¥æ-r}4þÒ:q^ø!Ñ$NRVC¦`pÉ"ýk‹jÊã[kðŽÀo½ @$ïÖ"+ʀ{ÅÔé¨ê„Ð4ō€i È6 ¼ÓS»5+ì¯JýúÕ~tj"åŽRÚ#ïܲ6ŸšÁxD èškûíÆ7y²ÈšnL¯3'2$öëØ.†fz=±%-O¡/s½À8{°lw×A¶Aûñ&åñÞº¹lTÉ© Û,å ï-A+°"иYÉfÆÐ ÅsÎ*«}úàbqrvþ4¬ïšå Þ¼9;†fùЮÄÍÙE? ý£øzvqÑ7e!U•‹¹'F•#TÉ º¾ž]ín‡×m+Î~êû¡}g úúÜܯ»fX÷xûöÝ¥89»¼ÊÄò›È„ø¶ìN΋L(±¸;Qú ­…ÉŒ¨*Y‰ÅãI'§‹¿N¿3UK]ˆ™'ª‹•í}ÿ­~Æ£¼üðL؝2©ŒX¼# -ᐰ&¹NgeÒ¦y"әNvßҙJlŠíSjhˆúv4N3iø¡&OÄÎgüy‰óä5ÕY"^Rôha%ú;øgW‘°‰7²Øþu†í•@=|f î p¾Øî|Ƕ÷si¬[Ï¬àÐé×ů'³Lfxb) ¡sôÎÌ CçšÝÓ>§38\L+¸˜ÓÑ./h®Ç1¼s²Ø«ýNÿ¼ÆGW´œ~áÐ3¥x~Oóé¶þ>Ða  €Z¹B$¼ðîf(-e±ÏõÙf}ëZK¡©zt»*7AšEÚI€¦ ÚSeááuxå§%¿êLð±Šli íütl ëÌJ_ކÇì*;å!!ú"Ø1lOAq÷(éWHL[zÌÙeÄÛӎ-çÀ"INÔXi`jE'40á&zºøŽlãyѐ¬|º.NIÛ´eêMZ³Ti‰J\æÚ%Í*ùrví}²s^r ´‡NÑ£žµàÕë.ðe'5ã›ó¶¢I{{¯'®ŽÐc¸uŒ†' `pW¯æ#ðŽÁ…dÔsYVÉ§× ¤v²Ñ 9অ¶É½šñ¼/Ò¼~¶•¸0îgb+Bé|/‰6„‘˜Û×lC M×q°PμH£4C´í²ìl"Ó3z°+G6#:Ö5£ã®/Œö¡[U˜(Ѿw¡ÞPü(N'•TIW×՞>úh«ì¹P+¨Óhýç3j‡AÿŒ"º‘Ž >¼?®ÞôçśiIdð­m72GÚ)1=‡¡go¦ëÒvp1½z~qérò|œ¸«ÒµyyÿþR^ò²yçÅõŠH%"  ¤0*üþ‡ÔvJågJLyÖËp21KëV‘÷"¶2äzV"®TŠ\4±ý£o%§®qüšC¦GíU%Z§;RlSŸGÍÚó1zAV­V$뽉Údì Iÿ7Ï ¾ÀY"Ô)bp!¥ëê³ß3bNœyºå CÛØÔÄÌ;|]‹­éôöAY¼‡°C¨Éa•{¸jß¾dFvÊg¥ål ÀYq$å7"ǧIÙu¿RŠç'š¡ÐJ0î'•ÍÚ¡Ç*ÍýÛ`2Š«6¾ò³§E·Ï>ªå¹³áZ*ܛO?ý/À1­%© endstream endobj 8 0 obj stream hÞ,ŽA @…ÿÊë 3®¹ˆ …Ô!/JÑa‘Ev]Y÷ÿ>š:¾ï潄3dyåÒ«)°QÀQÎg¥‡1°},à¤~*Jx µ‘µ›BU¹÷3"%Ç8"ÒÙZZmÖMéµ4["´ (_;mð*ô#4Î[iÝÅ;D¸it_NQ ¡ ÊÞXA·ÎŠN¿¼žóðøïMãCQ|VÒBº endstream endobj 9 0 obj endobj 10 0 obj stream H‰"WÛnÛH}÷WôÓ¢v_x؎3›`' ba³ %'(ۚ•HÁ¦ÆÉ|ýÖ¥›lRkL·Èêêªêª:§®'WOÍê~¶hÄ/¿\^5Ílñ¸,Åôòºnšz#¾_^_×?Ä4M¤Îc‘iiu*¬µB+%sxõýòn7o~nò]]7Ë'q9¡_Ÿg«jÖ¬êJüúëõÛqqys§ÄY(!žÕÅåd¢„"û m଍°ÊŠÙ0¤"I»'ÓjWQp)œZ´np¯ZÓÚHíϛ‰'\£m÷]E[G3W}?b™æ¡t„uGà¢ïÒ=DÕBûJ 'e¯#,?HaW‘Qrp!R(º«Øë{M5-ê8 >ml¡äaå,è¾Wî § ÌÛ|§×"Ùzϟd/&ý:Vm*CØ®åQÆÝS?3A ÷ˆ¯VmêñMˆ-J×ôäêöÿ¡zûB…EYñNÛlx…PWйÙ«öìe#g&ˆm«ªíãa㠑ZPTRö}PŠìãŒ1Ö!è¢^N¢‹†N؋|)§›£F:6øM¨ñ7z¾‘ sà¼T÷ãBfy׋¦ÔàÊrÕOX艮ÄçË8‰±Ò]Gí*¼¡*X2cj¿Œœ&nª§‡dk, ´B·…M™{½3¿õŽà"Á-¥Õ«Ðy"èð½(>ç„qŒœý6 ‹"§„ñuŠü¤y¡! ĸU…ËíÏNø6¾Y#ä!J"ïFy´B)|Õ¼a ÔG!PÇÒìc v¼…ñ>¶qêEã©åVž°ŠIíÈH"ûC»K@)ÉVA2­½ ©£° ¸üØ£0áýTõÞ%hE06)rÄ ·‰F`ˆë‘£p‹†Z[µ»^áÍ1[׫ÆS$Ó/ít‡qfQÖ2°aü½ü‹ØïZš» P!e†èÆeÞ6®®oÓšB±åû ‘Ö¾š'ϵËDÑFiRÌÙ¹¡üʬ±‹9΀é(pÅlG•àö5Š7¸BnÇj)‹ég¯YÏ • ‘mëÑ´K6+|B0~#Znz*ó0ÿˆù„šyíu…Ëùš8#8=‰>¢ü¶3lÞ&­ëP"Ôõ?PmB{CIÔ9ðX3q(¹ ‘Ô_ôÙk"wË]çdcÉã,û¯Q¿'¬›ZÒ½{›YFÀµgî U%"SÅÆ[Y3ñ£+7á!¨3Ñêf…'£ KVØÎRĵh"£Œ8OùYGÿòjÛm#G¢ïù >ÍJAÜÙWÎ>Ŏ˜‡É‰±»€wÚRËV©•ËßOÕ)'Íîlo€Èl²HëvN¹þ {ç¾Uó¯Ê¢¶ÆáP ŠNºj$ô}´T‹ôþÙñM"%E~†»9¶7ì1M{;K ,ÿP]›hërËÍÁþ,k¦^³àªÍ3iÇ!¶æQM6zD戎™øÕñá¦t`œ‡hŒ£kñ4=­9p‰Op­ íÐ="Ôäˆë!ˆÄ©xöñáçöÙȳ4ÈP¶T¸!ù7«¤\ ü® 3S"ï"5˹¾…Œ•Ì[#Ù¡ÈY…¡Ì]=¯ÖìSö±Ää^hÖµ\}z1•GÔ9„™ -BÐ¥Eùàã[…N5Dõø•k¯ò„Üå¼#¦™dÙ ÜÔå¯ZHkäéz×0UR?$_ã¦> ‡´ˆ-Q;èg¹ì¸ÁJ'óM"ªÝnþûØõߧ.Ç7PK-P`F%g>kRDäÝ{2Ó|ËEDãgÅ?®»£¨Vµ t}ó#|Ï*ì}cKr5ÇÔ ÝY¨‘ªžãdõÀsÇzø_çìS XÁlê×v"Ûs$Þ"û  žÍBqhTí^+¥e£Þ»êi _6FºÌöÜéÑï#4åjà±@]Ñ.‹ÿ&¦Ò¶P‰Ñ¦P‹Æí¾ÿ¹~fÕ¿üðŽX8I©Nsµx¤jRrñîl qb£^íï,jãiô#¶tðHoYóaK‡ÌWÌ°2¹SÆ-‰-tV²7gÖÙS5,º½a[´¯iäQõàߺRxp®Ë½÷ÊZ‹y*&ÕYæßLFÆ{Ør«Ý½áŸž¹C„#¸ SµZç«X-1&ºµ+µÿ£Vá&ž£@³ÆsZz8ìxÿœ¿Évä×V"ê6vÊ=¸+b•ˆnEyáÙ ðí¨xˆª Ja·Æï!Pµ ˆ¯(%¤¤³æ£ZF_À¹õ.gGgd9|}Dd…(É*x9'ü›¨Ft7H¼šž¹0YF_YÕـ0çÜPþg‰>W'j°ÛèY‘ ×_ùaÚ6Ï TM-Ƕ"[x,ìXµžÝ\­Ý¡¨yð/E´n˜b\uà¤\tÐÏê^c àïܽØÊ*îbˆsÖc^Ñ×uß ³&Þ¶hç7ô.¢Qμ¼Y 'R&Ç"£½> ©dóupØø8Vw´t`vÁó0híø6Î/0§¸råŽ`þ7¬1¾Bt´l®mҞ¦1QQšš@ù ßÙô¼Øñó¶Æ„"Ðr«àSÞÛÕl ×)J±Ç™:;¼øN÷tà,ýÀYo¬Z-ûEŠ"À¤Sä"&þ0EŽHŒÀ$š©î]×Ïb´j„¨õp(ÿÙ_›(ՙy6PüóŸD jÑ´x2Çt ž%ÓØðð ñ=,nãõÜÞ UE•ñP¸(§P@!\:„¿FÆL0c3ö¡3ïÐbQᚠ£´U«Ë#pqTŒŠü´iԄ\ ëÊ%õ¯Ùáhe=zVÝ ¤u©;Ñ…ZÎü±5Ž¤›uè~¨[%ì„C+ bÜP7S!Fé9ÕQ˜3DH£0…>ˆéûë`wé ÒWÖ®¨I~ŠLÑ' î¿=ՀblŠk?YšèÀ!!Á dÓhrZ¸ ï ê'j$é%F¼ó>F?ЧVŸ©ËÖ㮋W#îï»ÑTH*ëÏÎΚ¯&Ϥš§¢PÒ¨\c„J9‡¡Ï³‡ÛöÛ¾³Ÿ›¦­ÅlI¿>"÷õ®lëf'Þ¾=»8'³ó‰X}‰_V»"Ùr™%w'J¼ka#æs9ËíITÄË?N"Ï©ZH‰©'*˵½¼ÆU? ë×çW°„Ý)‘I¢År%°‡Åža*ÓÜ]^œÜDM¬£»8‹DûoUœG_Jxy„áí~s_bµ8Ù`¨Å±OZk°ÄŸàZ¬à¿[4¥Å­[gSoc•D5­°¦=ÐQïØÖî¿p´¢ ¼»eüyùî$±Ëñ\ºf§˜Ü€õTñ£ŒÓ谉§à.>&þ=T0|7ˆV»µhºÉG˜d[|"Ž¾Å&€ÓÞ]`"vÊ@f í¼PQ½­7.œbe_ê­;'Äc‹wd¸…=Ü#Œ9Æ@"Öÿ*»FKi]ºZÅñk‘bÝàåXì8q_ÉÜFÿÓh2GÔ$ Z1.:œÙx³Lþ"´A5b'î&·Ü/2ê°qÁÕ¶p`¹=X‹mèC^¶%c.$ÅÍbåv4óÀ*ÙV«ã¡ÝÛPð_1©Ñ:Œ#i4"bcð€ 4À#7cTüÀ‰\Ö úÖ¢Ï~!ÒG±ÏZØ'c·>ñUp…‡O8HîR¯äg`9ùž 0úÈs¢íÖ0ÄãׄŽµuÛ¾öÖƑ¥#.I\~èÖ­®õi^çÚ|nۼɥÍs…Þc6Ì)©dù¨¸Ý"'Ÿ\ÊhϋV ÕêûTËsŸå"+,hm¹Cq+Kµ³ššJáÿN‰3eÏl¼Å՚À°Ù°ä˜"®C îºÑxz+j0P¡SHÝ}äé2o{"øD Þ á¸2Úʪ³êW²'eIîûQîªq/Î#xð&Ø't®‹{°UÇ-üŽÜfÏ7BFQNü˜«¦ß½ I‹8%o>zæ- `ÝJ+å0;#}í«kà©#Å&N?4ç6tÄàÿQV¦¹.lÞotèn\8ÍWä$ºÒ ,ºÿ^Õpå,^xIÁͦñ äS´VôM}|Þ «LÓî°o™,Ø7ä""ùˆq]ݚ4Óó26{÷,ukŽc›î9t ¦a×måP¥‘­›çÙ Tñ¾‡‡kQ0e¥Óò0³t°ÈÖ¶ditڌP«ì=ê3ˈJ"˜™UQ ªówîY&^ŸJ©ÝŒÛwT}.bµÐ¦ ²h™xNõÅç:€ü6¢Åê0Ï ÛQ4bÌéôV'ìÁ] ÿO÷Vç²jte˜û:¢R¢áý"-çA )"BoñD½²õ·j¼G¥„šòü‹F¿øô?üNjC endstream endobj 16 0 obj endobj 17 0 obj stream H‰"WÛnã8}ÏWðQDŒH] è¤{v{°af§[IÜc[GJÒ¿uáM²Óé}ˆ#Qd±X 6ʄ`1 rÎÜ­…îz×Àp D}Õ*ôþ\‰æT Wêˆ:¨ dŽ±‘ÊØ!È Ç¡öñpÀè,h¸'×ÛVÜS‡C¡¨%&˜jYðÎ)´"f‰e¬U°N°š9FN¨•,³ÍI¿=³=$£'e ªqñ˜Î‹ˆTCàm·[s˜çþÊí¨,á[.:p¼³_¾Üþ ÁȜzË/Ç­¸Ÿ*"ÿ 0 „2ÆՎCÄxo êH˜yýlÑߨ§tìŒv猀b@ éîݽa5ÅUv±aÚ2ä`°\Fԋæ°ç¸EeanÎ`ò%ê]ï~˜å Ý˜€ÜU~œ¸Ç ?(Ì=vžO蝨ɑëސ>%==:¦ èÆfÌÍ ô g7vA€£@€X쉬=sù6‹±a· ƱԱf:Qä&ÉÌÖ8mO‡x¦û:؆ 0W%qð 1%¥Sˆ6ÈlÝθ!ÈkêoéAe™Ô"›AúäØãFŸþ".óKÓdø§òBÖáT‰3'æòz1ºIõJkÝ?¨|ÒB+³ÙcÚt'Ó^#ø,ŠßRDcZíÒ¬JÓR^1Ú®ˆMUs܀֋Òb¦V]݁ão{Ú-òÊõòf¨ŽN¾©ÓÓ"›áՅÊÔÙÙù…~§×Ÿx/GþŒ\fœlS[§ð"Aéƕ֍Ð÷C{E±\Q‹GIʘܛ6î|Õý2üLÇú~KÅ{¥/aÀ¯qLlVôSÚUèIÔzz4{g" è t#iZ‘»s±ò¡G|îóà܅œÛ-é°m¢•UŒøèü8»U.å=Uw÷è#ÔÀTí QɾTÌÜ+Šµ‘…Àëde×PB£tKIÓ9¹$ä"6äRÓÈ@>MD!‰ŒXù`q¬šÚXM%ªc×õÑ܁T+=ùÄ4ÈãíÊê睯N´dxÇ©ÖËÔǀ[ˆ}& ï/mÐg%Åz‹¼§®9‘F/ùŽúć×xY×ÊÁ²rzmÁ®¯ïËÀÖ"ÛE¶á ²÷¿Ô2HŒÉ jIg‘sɞÆP´ßü@3¡Q( êK *áóõøÞw]"íÕ֐\ ðØ|vù)%?†tSïé҅Vs ¡¿§tJæ^mWíµçêÑßK‹ð)L'ç#Ȏ$‘/ÈœÍä‡gr,¬ ²v^3Ê¨-RûñsPÏ+M«\÷9ב?oºü8wGe‡¯mŠ»Å€¦֞-s×làKÖPøMàÁ«gJ…¿Óþ~ ²®©¢ ,t)*bòD Ðóè¾ËqRFUáw1ÊÓ4&Èþ 0»5Ø endstream endobj 18 0 obj endobj 19 0 obj stream H‰´VmOÛ0þÞ_qmDûì8‰„H[52MSáCéËèíaÿ~>'Mӊ2KÓ¾8gû^|Ïsg§({ñÑc5ŸÆÄGU5ßM'0Œ‹eU-à&.ŠåoÚD¨Ì@ª„V´Ö ¤™[º‰¯žo«SˆOËjúqégÑ·ùbTÍ 8ò‡ô „=‘ã_ì IYûÅ ¯óŽÈᝆè$7žXÿJAx ÊOJÁ ûþbYT5=Õ0n¬Ž é[ðŸ»ìFÁºñY‹Äc×,x`ÛA ¥ ˆýÐÇL…kªÍá¡ÿéa%×Ú ÿí°lRÇû¿0ók'ZÈAÛ Ø8$¶ø_Ø"?ktÅf͈$ ˆõ_Ø"?¦„4¶4$˜+¤½uñãÁ¤hºK×ð°ÿá"8ö -·Kácÿ±­†¿Òá7~P`ˆú²  -ŠKÚý„éE+&84®4‹øæ×ã † X4¬Ž=sþ?¢þàCG©CŠCÑzÿ°in•_×V+CèÎüõ‘GL%~AwðAýõŠ`¿„ ?ìÐ͞©:½‘®©ìûŽ¥:熌T®³Ž«¤é¯ðŠ÷V(UÇý[ºJ­Ý"‡­Hï×ð_J‘G¥úOüÛò@[ëWA#OøÌ^ž8£ÏÞ)jÒÇ&;OVé}( _÷»£Uä é.ñ~ý¹ ýë~5b'Èl{aýuWäu÷d1?è^ë¡ iÖS‘Îä‡ÈDøãUnaÝl Kkáyj,ýºX0¨aVǬï¥xÔ_Û· ¸íõ¹1ÈÇt?ÿ8^ªëFß½ZH/½‘Å#„þlÈü;MÒJ"yÇƨ]mÎ?¥Ó~+¦×·Ç û#‡/Tãþ¢"íN›ÒðRù8¤]DyTܶ›Ä01¨o„ ªû\Œùò¦Gá-̛ Y½µ\D¾÷«0‘g­Ú¶ ¤-P Ò[ÛD¹õ 4‘»c‘Ó1³ íö€Ø[öõљPŒÆL´F"÷&ŠÑ,ÎD…Ìj`¢¹@¼¢‰À+"F㬵&&ÈjŸ!á4È \9Qo'‘2G"œqÄ$‰KÁµÓTLžkðœW+;#¨œ· xÞe"çŽÐ\°j2ðó&/ ¨ ¼P`¼ˆx@¡‹xI¡^å ð²xS€aW€q¡»^qĐŒ«»g%_ïY žà[_Šñø\øJ´XÁt¢ó½Xg¼"G¼ybpYOzðPsŒE¨8F$XÙ+Nïk~Èr# jià&>äj ä(ÕÈÑWc ÇTœl5rò¶Ȍ(3¢rFšEœë-œ/¶¹¸j äRª1Êȳ(ê­›hÁ"K­ÈêPJRjÑd¡CÑ)2,ÈZPÔ¸€²­Þá8 kfW°"‹«•¬ȸa-~,rí ‡Ê°B¨}à+ÁµC7÷î͞Ô>²ædv>stream 2012-02-29T11:34:22-06:00 2012-02-29T11:34:20-06:00 2012-02-29T11:34:22-06:00 Acrobat PDFMaker 10.0 for Word uuid:bbd66720-4eaa-430b-93f3-0bf3f512bac0 uuid:7c11ca37-c8db-4325-82f0-d10a41bfa241 4 application/pdf batwood Adobe PDF Library 10.0 D:20120229143152 State of Texas endstream endobj 28 0 obj stream hÞ22°P0P°±ÑwÎ/Í+Q04Ð÷ÎL)Ž624 )I0i&-!PiˆŒ!DÊÐL€¨XýÊTý€ÄôÔb;;€›Õ1 endstream endobj 29 0 obj stream hÞlÍ͊@àWé›"›žÑdÏ"LǟôÒNм½­ˆìaoEQ|åp Ói>oӁÅ">ݘCÿðåBMºšWüõMg¶É'®aGwÕ^ȧÈM¡µ)&­CçÆÖ†û8ê!öÞ+•ç•°ê°)k"‹_5 ìYôpIÝMópÍá?Ó}̍ph+R4pIOV±/ÝKÍò-·R‘:±ŽþBýv:hË#UIÏv1Éd³ÙC€³rOÇ endstream endobj 30 0 obj stream hÞbb&Fá L ŒŸ„ÐU«D|ü[A¬? ‰0‹D|"Å VL› Іç uÚ01¿01˜2à šÞI ¶, Á¼dÊjŽ5 YU «teA\VÁ "x@#`ücA0þ Añ(1,ƹ£a@&Át~ ;Ä endstream endobj startxref 116 %%EOF

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.