Manafort Brothers, Inc. v. State of Rhode Island, Rhode Island Department of Transportation, C.A. (Amended)
Annotate this Case
Download PDF
STATE OF RHODE ISLAND AND PROVIDENCE PLANTATIONS PROVIDENCE, SC. SUPERIOR COURT [FILED: June 26, 2019] MANAFORT BROTHERS, INC., Plaintiff, VS. STATE OF RHODE ISLAND, by and through SETH MAGAZINER, in his capacity as General Treasurer, and RHODE ISLAND DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION, by and through PETER ALVITI, JR., P.E., in his capacity as Director, Defendants. : : : : : : : : : : : : : C.A. No. PC-2016-4542 AMENDED DECISION SILVERSTEIN, J. (Ret.) This Amended Decision is being filed to revise the Original Decision filed on June 24, 2019. On page 6 of the original Decision, the first paragraph should read as follows: The State, here, argues that full and complete adherence to the strict provisions of the contract did not occur. Our Supreme Court in Clark-Fitzpatrick, Inc./Franki Found. Co. v. Gill, 652 A.2d 440, 447 (R.I. 1994) found that “the trial justice noted that form should not be made superior to substance and found that the lack of formal notice under Section 105.17 was not a waiver in this instance. We agree.” This Court finds that Clark-Fitzpatrick stands for the proposition that in State construction contract cases substantial compliance rather than strict compliance with contract requirements as to notice (is the standard to be applied) so that form will not trump substance. Here, the facts demonstrate that Plaintiff substantially complied with the notice requirements. Accordingly, the Court finds that the pending litigation is appropriate, and that sovereign immunity here has been waived so as to permit Plaintiff to bring the present proceeding. The language “No. 578” has been removed from the last sentence of the above-referenced paragraph. The remaining contents of the original Decision filed on June 24, 2019 shall remain the same. 2 RHODE ISLAND SUPERIOR COURT Amended Decision Addendum Sheet TITLE OF CASE: Manafort Brothers, Inc. v. State of Rhode Island, Rhode Island Department of Transportation CASE NO: PC-2016-4542 COURT: Providence County Superior Court DATE DECISION FILED: June 26, 2019 JUSTICE/MAGISTRATE: Silverstein, J. (Ret.) ATTORNEYS: For Plaintiff: For Defendant: John A. Donovan, III, Esq. William M. Dolan, Esq. 3
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
