U.S. Bank N.A. v Stanmore

Annotate this Case

Download PDF

U.S. Bank N.A. v Stanmore 2020 NY Slip Op 30388(U) February 5, 2020 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: 850193/2013 Judge: Arlene P. Bluth Cases posted with a "30000" identifier, i.e., 2013 NY Slip Op 30001(U), are republished from various New York State and local government sources, including the New York State Unified Court System's eCourts Service. This opinion is uncorrected and not selected for official publication. [*FILED: 1] NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/05/2020 09:57 AM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 155 INDEX NO. 850193/2013 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/05/2020 SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK NEW YORK COUNTY PRESENT: HON. ARLENE P. BLUTH PART IAS MOTION 32 ·Justice ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------X U.S. BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION, AS TRUSTEE, SUCCESSOR IN INTEREST TO WACHOVIA BANK, NA, AS TRUSTEE, FOR J.P. MORGAN MORTGAGE TRUST 2005-A1, INDEX NO. MOTION DATE MOTION SEQ. NO. 850193/2013 01/29/2020 004 Plaintiff, -vROGER STANMORE AKA ROGER D. STANMORE, JPMORGAN CHASE BANK, NA, BOARD OF MANAGERS OF THE HORIZON HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION, BRANCH BANKING AND TRUST COMPANY, UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, CITY OF NEW YORK ENVIRONMENTAL CONTROL BOARD, CITY OF NEW YORK PARKING VIOLATIONS BUREAU, CITY OF NEW YORK TRANSIT ADJUDICATION BUREAU, JOHN DOE, DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION, JUDGMENT OF FORECLOSURE AND SALE Defendant. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------X The following e-filed documents, listed by NYSCEF document number (Motion 004) 96, 97, 98, 99, 100, 101, 102, 103, 104, 105, 106, 107, 108, 109, 110, 111, 112, 113, 114, 115, 116, 117, 118, 119, 120, 123, 127, 128, 129, 130, 131, 132, 133, 138, 139, 140, 141, 142, 143, 144, 145, 146, 147, 148, 149, 150, 151, 152, 153 were read on this motion to/for JUDGMENT - FORECLOSURE & SALE The motion by plaintiff for a judgment of foreclosure and sale is granted and the crossmotion by defendant Stanmore to vacate his default and to dismiss the complaint is denied. Background In this mortgage foreclosure action, plaintiff moves to confirm the report of the referee, which found that plaintiff is due $587,165.83 as of June 30, 2019. · Stanmore opposes and crossmoves to vacate his default on the ground that he was 'never served. Stanmore admits that he did not live in the apartment when service was purportedly effectuated and denies that he was served at his Alabama residence in 2013. He contends that the affidavit of serviCe for this purported 850193/2013 U.S. BANK NATIONAL vs. STANMORE, ROGER Motion No. 004 1 of 17 Page 1 of 11 [*FILED: 2] NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/05/2020 09:57 AM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 155 INDEX NO. 850193/2013 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/05/2020 service is false and stresses the purported discrepancies between himself and the description contained in the affidavit of service. In opposition to the cross-motion, plaintiff contends that Stanmore has not met his burden to rebut the affidavit of service. Plaintiff points out that Stallinore clearly knew about the instant action because plaintiff appeared in his bankruptcy case in 2014. Plaintiff complains that he is appearing at this late date despite knowing about this case for years. In reply to the cross-motion, Stanmore argues that a traverse hearing is required because of the discrepancies between his personal appearance and the description on the affidavit of service. He contends that improper service is a reasonable excuse for his default. Discussion "Where, as here, a defendant seeks vacatur of a default under both CPLR 5015(a)(l) (excusable default) and CPLR 5015(a)(4) (lack of jurisdiction), the court should determine whether or not it has personal jurisdiction over the defendant before reaching the 5015(a)(l) ground, since the defendant's lack of a reasonable excuse is obviated if the court is without personal jurisdiction over defendant, and all subsequent proceedings would be rendered null and void" (Wells Fargo Bank, NA. v Jones, 139 AD3d 520, 522, 32 NYS3d 95 [1st Dept 2016] [internal quotations and citations omitted]). A"[p]laintiffs affidavit of service constitute[s] prima facie evidence of proper service" (Wells Fargo Bank, NA. v Javier, 2020 WL 201240 [1st Dept 2020]). The affidavit of service submitted by plaintiff contends that service was effectuated on August 3, 2013 at an address in Huntsville, Alabama (NYSCEF Doc: No. 18). The process server claims that he served the defendant personally and described Stanmore as a black male, aged 45, between five feet eight inches and five feet eleven inches tall and between 175 and 199 pounds 850193/2013 U.S. BANK NATIONAL vs. STANMORE, ROGER Motion No. 004 2 of 17 Page 2of11 [*FILED: 3] NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/05/2020 09:57 AM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 155 INDEX NO. 850193/2013 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/05/2020 (id.). In his affidavit, Stanmore does not deny that he lives at the address in Huntsville, Alabama identified in the affidavit of service; instead, he asserts that in 2013, he was six feet two inches tall and weighed 225 pounds (NSYCEF Doc. No. 129, if 18). He also describes his skin as "brown" instead of black (id.). Here, the Court finds that Stanmore failed to rebut plaintiffs affidavit of service demonstrating that service was effectuated at Stanmore's residence in Alabama. Stanmore fails to contest that the address identified in the affidavit of service is not his residence nor does he claim that he was elsewhere on the day service was purportedly effectuated. His denial amounts to a discrepancy of a few inches· and pounds and the difference between .describing skin color as black versus brown. These are not sufficient to raise an issue of fact requiring a traverse hearing. Minor inaccuracies in a process server's affidavit do not compel the Court to hold a hearing (PNC Bank, National Association v Bannister, 161AD3d1114, 1115-16, 77 NYS3d 452 [2d Dept 2018] [holding that "A minor discrepancy between the appearance of the person allegedly served and the description of the person served contained in the affidavit of service is generally insufficient to raise an issue of fact warranting a hearing"]). Summary The Court observes that in October 2014 plaintiff made a motion to lift the automatic stay imposed by Stanmore's bankruptcy (NYSCEF Doc. No. 144). That motion details that plaintiff had a mortgage lien on the property that is the subject of this action (id. if 3). That motion was denied and Stanmore was directed to make monthly payments of $2,525.83 to plaintiff (NYSCEF Doc. No. 145). Despite the motion practice in bankruptcy court, Stanmore waited until plaintiff moved for a judgment before seeking to vacate and claim he was never served. 850193/2013 U.S. BANK NATIONAL vs. STANMORE, ROGER Motion No. 004 3 of 17 Page 3of11 [*FILED: 4] NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/05/2020 09:57 AM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 155 INDEX NO. 850193/2013 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/05/2020 In fact, Stanmore admits he learned about this case in 2016 (id.~ 14). Although he claims that he did not know what these documents were, the docket of Stanmore's bankruptcy filing makes clear he owns property all around the country (see NYSCEF Doc. No. 142). The Court questions why Stanmore waited until right before plaintiff moved for a judgment to move to vacate and dismiss. It may be that he was waiting until the statute of limitations became a potential issue before making the instant motion (although that issue is unclear given Stanmore's bankruptcy). In any event, the Court finds that service was proper, Stanmore failed to offer a reasonable excuse for his default or a meritorious defense. Accordingly, it is hereby ORDERED and ADJUDGED the motion to confirm the referee's report and for a judgment of foreclosure and sale is granted and the cross-motion by defendant Stanmore is denied; and it is further ORDERED that the mortgaged property described in the complaint and as described in this judgment, or such part thereof as may be sufficient to discharge the mortgage debt, the expense of sale and the costs of this action as provided in the RP APL be sold within 90 days of this judgment, in one parcel, at a public auction at the New York Couno/ Courthouse located at 60 Centre Street, New York, New York on a Wednesday at 2:15 p.m. under the direction of Elaine Shay, who is appointed Referee for this purpose; and it is further ORDERED that the Referee shall give public notice of the time and place of sale in accordance with RP APL 231 (2) in the New York Law Journal; and the referee need not conduct the sale unless plaintiff shall provide the referee with proof of publication of the notice of sale, and if the sale is adjourned due to plaintiffs failure to provide such proof, then said adjournment shall not be considered at the referee's request; and it is further 850193/2013 U.S. BANK NATIONAL vs. STANMORE, ROGER Motion No. 004 4 of 17 Page 4of11 [*FILED: 5] NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/05/2020 09:57 AM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 155 INDEX NO. 850193/2013 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/05/2020 ORDERED that by accepting this appointment the Referee certifies that she/he is in compliance with Part 36 of the Rules of the Chief Judge (22 NYCRR Part 36), including, but not ' limited to §36.2 (c) ('.'Disqualifications from appointment"), and §36.2 (d) ("Limitations on appointments based upon compensation"), and, if the Referee is disqualified from receiving an appointment pursuant to the provisions of that Rule, the Referee shall immediately notify the Appointing Judge; and it is further ORDERED that the Referee is pr~hibited from accepting or retaining any funds for herself/himself or paying funds to him/herself without compliance with Part 36 of the Rules of the Chief Administrative J,udge; and it is further ORDERED that the Referee shall conduct the foreclosure sale only if Pfaintiff, 'its successors and/or assignees or its representatives is present at the sale or the Referee has received a written bid and Terms of Sale from Plaintiff, its successors and/or assigns, or its representatives; and it is further ORDERED that ifthe Referee cannot conduct the sale within 90 days of the date ofthis judgment, plaintiff must make a motion to extend the time to sell the subject property explaining the reasons for the delay; and it is further ORDERED that at the time of sale the Referee may accept a written bid from the Plaintiff or the Plaintiffs attorney, just as though Plaintiff were physically present to·submit said bid; and it is further ORDERED that the Referee shall accept the highest bid offered by a bidder who shall be identified upon the court record, and shall require that the successfl!_l bidder immediately execute Terms of Sale for the purchase of the property, and pay to the Referee in cash, certified check or 850193/2013 U.S. BANK NATIONAL vs. STANMORE, ROGER Motion No. 004 5 of 17 Page 5of11 [*FILED: 6] NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/05/2020 09:57 AM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 155 INDEX NO. 850193/2013 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/05/2020 bank check, ten percent (10%) of the sum bid,.unless the successful bidder is Plaintiff; in which case no deposit against the purchase process shall be required and it is further ORDERED that notwithstanding the previous paragraph, the Referee shall have the right to refuse cash payments and require a bank or certified ch_eck fro~ the successful· bidder and the , Referee shall be entitled to qu~lify bidders and require bidder~ to show proof of funds before or during the auction; and it is further ORDERED that in the event the first successful bidder fails to execute the Terms of Sale j or fails to immediately pay the ten percent (10%) deposit as required, the property shall be immediately reoffered at auction on the same day; and i_t is further ORDERED the Referee shall deposit the down payment and proceeds of sale, as necessary in an FDIC-insured bank where the Referee has an account for that purpose in accordance with CPLR 2609; and it is further ORDERED that after the balance of the purchase price is paid or credited and the property is sold, the Referee shall execute a deed to the purchaser in accordance with RP APL 1353 and the terms of sale (which shall be deemed a binding contract); and it is further ORDERED that in the event a party other than Plaintiff becomes the purchaser at the sale, the closing of title shall be held no later than 30 days after the date of such sale; and it is further ORDERED that, pursuant to RP APL 1353(1), if Plaintiff (or its affiliate as defined in . paragraph [a] of subdivision one of section six-1 of the banking law) is the purchaser, the property shall be placed back on the market for sale or other occupancy within 180 days of the execution of the deed of sale or within 90 days of construction, renovation, or rehi;tbilitation of the property, provided that such construction, renovation or rehabilitation proceeded diligently to 850193/2013 U.S. BANK NATIONAL vs. STANMORE, ROGER Motion No. 004 6 of 17 Page 6of11. [*FILED: 7] NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/05/2020 09:57 AM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 155 INDEX NO. 850193/2013 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/05/2020 completion, whichever comes first, provided that this court grants an exte~sion upon a showing of good cause; and it is further ORDERED that the Referee, after receiving the proceeds of the sale, shall pay (from the proceeds) the taxes, assessments, sewer rents, or water rates, which are, or may become, liens on the property in accordance with their priority according to law with such interest or penalties which may have lawfully accrued thereon to the date of payment; ~nd it is further ORDERED that the Referee shall deposit the balance of the proceeds from the sale in his or her own name as Referee in an FDIC-insured bank where the Referee has an account for that purpose and shall make the following payments.in accordance with RPAPL 1354: 1. The Referee's fees for conducting the sale, which are $1,100. Plaintiff shall also compensate the Referee in the sum of $350 for each adjournment or cancellation made on less than two business days' notice unless the Referee caused the delay. 2. All taxes, assessments and water rates that are liens upon the property and monies necessary to redeem the property from any sales for unpaid taxes, assessments or water rates and any other amounts due in accordance with RP APL 1354(2). The purchaser shall be responsible for interest and penalties accrued after the sale. The Referee shall not be responsible for the payment of penalties or fees pursuant to this appointment. The purchaser shall hold the Referee harmless from any such penalties or fees assessed; 3. The expenses of the sale and the advertising expenses as shown on the bills presented and certified by the Referee to be correct, copies of which shall be annexed to the report of sale. 7 of 850193/2013 U.S. BANK NATIONAL vs. STANMORE, ROGER Motion No. 004 17 Page 7of11 [*FILED: 8] NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/05/2020 09:57 AM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 155 INDEX NO. 850193/2013 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/05/2020 4. The Referee shall also pay to the Plaintiff or its attorneys the follow~ng: a.. Amount Due from the Referee's Report: $587,165.83 with interest at the note rate from June 30, 2019 until entry of judgment together with any advances as provided for in the note and mortgage which Plaintiff has made for taxes, insurance, principal, and interest and any other charges due to prior mortgages or to maintain the property pending consummation of the foreclosure sale, not included in the computation upon presentation of receipts for said expenditures to the Referee, and then with interest from the date of entry of judgment at the statutory rate until the date the deed is transferred b. Costs and Disbursements: _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ (to be filled in by the Clerk) to Plaintiff for costs and disbursements in this action with interest at ( the statutory judgment rate from the date of entry of this judgment; c. The Court declines to award additional allowance. d. Attorneys' Fees: $4,950.00 is awarded as with interest at the statutory rate from the date of entry of this judgment. 5. Surplus monies from the sale shall be p_aid into Court by the Referee within five days after receipt in accordance with RPAPL 1354(4); and it is further ORDERED that if Plaintiff is the purchaser of the property, or in the event that the rights of the purchasers at the sale and the terms of sale under this judgment shall be assigned to or be acquired by Plaintiff, and a valid assignment is filed with the Referee, the Referee shall not require Plaintiff to pay in cash the entire amount bid at sale, but shall execute and deliver to Plaintiff or its assignee, a deed or deeds of the property sold upon the payment to said Referee of 850193/2013 U.S. BANK NATIONAL vs. STANMORE, ROGER Motion No. 004 8 of 17 Page 8of11 [*FILED: 9] NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/05/2020 09:57 AM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 155 INDEX NO. 850193/2013 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/05/2020 the amounts specified as 1, 2, and 3 above, and the Referee shall allow Plaintiff to pay the amounts specified in 2 and 3 above when if is recording the deed; that. the balance of the bid, after deducting the amounts paid by Plaintiff, shall be applied to the amount due to Plaintiff as specified in 4 above; that Plaintiff shall pay any surplus after applying the balance of the bid to the Referee, who shall deposit it in accordance with 5 above; and it is further ORDERED that all expenses ofrecording the Referee's deed, including real property transfer taxes, which is not a lien upon the property at the time of sale, shall be paid by the plaintiff from the sale proceeds and are recoverable as a cost of litigation; and it is further ORDERED that Plaintiff may seek to recover a deficiencyjudgment in accordance with RP APL 13 71 if applicable; ORDERED that if. the property is sold in one parcel in "as is" physical order and . condition, subject to any condition that an inspection of the property would disclose; any facts that an accurate survey of the property would show; any covenants, restrictions, declarations, reservations, easements, right of way, and public utility agreements ofrecord, if any; any building and zoning ordinances of the municipality in which the mortgaged property is located and possible violations of same; any rights of tenants or persons in possession of the subject property; prior liens ofrecord, if any, except those liens addressed in RP APL 1354, any equity of redemption of the United States of America to redeem the property within 120 days from the date of sale, any rights pursuant to CPLR 317, 2003 and 5015 or any appeal of the underlying action or additional litigation brought by any defendant or its successor.or assignee contesting the validity of this foreclosure; and it is further 850193/2013 U.S. BANK NATIONAL vs. STANMORE, ROGER Motion No. 004 9 of 17 Page 9of11 [*FILED: 10] NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/05/2020 09:57 AM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 155 INDEX NO. 850193/2013 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/05/2020 ORDERED that the purchaser be let into possession of the property upon production in hand of the Referee's Deed or upon personal service of the Referee's deed in accordance with CPLR 308; and it isfurther ORDERED that defendants in this action and persons claiming through them and any person possessing a junior interest in the property after the Notice of Pendencywas filed are barred and foreclosed of all right, claim, lien, title, and interest in the property after the sale of the mortgaged property; and it is further ORDERED that within 14 days after completing the sale and executing the proper conveyance to the purchaser, the Referee shall file with the clerk a report under oath of the disposition of the proceeds of the sale and upload the report to NYSCEF if it fs an e-filed case; and it is further ORDERED that ifthe purchaser or purchasers at said sale default upon the bid or terms of sale, the Referee may place the property for resale without prior application to this Court . unless Plaintiffs attorney elects to make such an application; and itis further ORDERED that Plaintiff shall serve a copy of this judgment with notice of entry upon the owner of the equity of redemption, any tenants named in this action, and any other parties entitled to service, including the Referee appointed herein; and it is further ORDERED that nothing herein shall be deemed to relieve Plaintiff of any obligation imposed by RPAPL 1307 or 1308 to secure and maintaii::i the property until ownership of the property has been transferred and the deed duly recorded; and it is further ORDERED that when the Referee files a report of sale, she or he shall also file a Foreclosure Action Surplus Monies Form and also upload this document to NYSCEF if an efiled case; and it is further 850193/2013 U.S. BANK NATIONAL vs. STANMORE, ROGER Motion No. 004 10 of 17 Page 10of11 [*FILED: 11] NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/05/2020 09:57 AM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 155 INDEX NO. 850193/2013 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/05/2020 J ORDERED that plaintiff shall upload the notice of sale to NYSCEF, at least 21 days before the sale and the Referee and plaintiff shall e-mail SFC-Foreclosures@nycourts.gov at least 21 days before the auction date so the auction may be placed on the auction calendar; IF THE AUCTION IS NOT ON THE CALENDAR, then the .auction will not go forward; and it is further ORDERED that, without further order of the Court, the referee shall be entitled to an •.. additional fee of $950 for conducting and attending a closing with a purchaser other than plaintiff, plus, if such a closing is scheduled for the referee's conference room, then the referee shall be entitled to a reasonable fee for 1:1se thereof, without.further order of the Court. A description of the premises is annexed hereto as schedule A. The property is commonly known as 415 East 37th Street, IOa, New York, NY 10016. DATE ~ NO~-FINA::~~:::~:LUTH, J.S.C. CHECK ONE: CASE DISPOSED APPLICATION: SETTLE ORDER . CHECK IF APPROPRIATE: INCLUDES TRANSFER/REASSIGN GRANTED D DENIED . . 850193/2013 U.S. BANK NATIONAL vs. STANMQRE, ROGER Moti9n No. 004 11 of 17 G~ANTED IN PART . SUBMIT ORDER x . FIDUCIARY APPOINTME~T D D OTHER REFERENCE Page 11 of 11 ~ {J) ..,Q 8 2! 0 \D 0 IU'"I Iir1 HHHHfiflfiHnn ~tia.,lf 1--1••~'.3 1 1'1 , u i n hH!.n1 WW s;'l,a 'gs lh:t t~tn 11 12 of 17 00 Hi HI \D ... 0 Ii! !~ I- I "~ l J~ !!!l!~fil~iil~l!!J a.1 • 1~ .... ', -, ,-;"~ I. . fr .tft.& a. ~ l'l 0 l'1 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/05/2020 09:57 AM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 155 [* 12] H 2: 0 I.'.! "'1 • .... a> Ut 0 \D z: -...:~ ~ z 0 0 0 ........... \D "" ............ N I\> ........0 0 INDEX NO. 850193/2013 H RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/05/2020 ~ 0 [*FILED: 13] NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/05/2020 09:57 AM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 155 INDEX NO. 850193/2013 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/05/2020 INDEX NO. 850193/201 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/09/201 NYSCEF DOC .. NO. 90 mJNNIMOTHBMc:B..-.,alaq6e...-.,t1aaflfat•--.M11etlM laaMI; 'fB114\W....., ...........................,. ...........,t!Mi. THBNCB .-ty 11111,..u.t wllla lbl IOlltllll'b' lllle ollllt 39" lltnet. 25 lid; 111BNCB..,,,ltlfl'il 111&111tolhl laltn'Ollll:1rLt ~ t llet 1 IQo!I; 'l'Hl'NCB.-df pll'IDll wlda&tOlllaOll1lldoaflutSP11C1eet. 'I t.t" ofIll 11111111; TSDICB..aa.tJcmaU.wldola._•llllmfaraalowllbtblllltmwtoaecl_. of'l2 ..... Sl•mllmlllSS ...... 17111tMlldllll; 1'BBNCB 1111111'1cnalllllwhldlllllllla.8dedorapwllb'llle list'""""'*' acnne otlS ..... 41lllfmrlll40 ....... 2 tiet' . . . . mBNCBadlsb'=a.Dnewbldlilmla.lalld«..Pwldl 11io mcmeadmld acim. olll deplal 1mlaute40 . . . . 11 flll7 lallllll; 'IHB'NCI Wllllrtf •a.Um wJdl1a bml a lallrlarq1nrlth 111o lut mntloned DOllllO ot11i depell I lldaulll25 . . . . 5 f'tllt~,111i1Dals; ..._.,Oil TflBNCB allllllwtdaltt:lmla lallrlotqllwllb t.prohqlthl wmmly oftlDIP&mcadaaod aoumafll--·23 ~501-=-. ts M2Kmotalltotke _,.n , 11.W. or..m11m111; 1'RINCB 'MllllllW llqtlll ~ llde otlfutS.,- &nit, "MM t 2IJ lullM; 1RB'NCB aordMrdJ llld plNIJel wlda .. ....., lido (Jf PlntAftlllae, '2 lllt IH ...._ '1'BINCB ~ pmllel wllb !Ii& S'PllNet. l'K fmi1iaJ aul 'l'HBNCBnordllrff Cll a Hmwbfcb bmlmcaalar aqle wtda dlalCllldlerly llde of11a& ,_.llNltot8'c1epwftmbaa.20 ..... 1041'11tNa.-..tD1ht~at.lof But !P Slalet.1be pola&arplloeofBB<IDOONO. TOOBTHBa wllh apGIPCGlt-b up&lllldllr cnw llld llb!M,._ alldq impro'ttlllmdl m doalbeid IDaZoaJaala ad Dmkfr'.,, ,\p •t ......._ ......,Amol&fll. MLlndA.mMimlDdXCILOMm'lllllDCalp,. daedu olMaf '- 1'11reomdlldMlf11.191l lnbll Sf7 Jlll8 770; a4 dlo,..- 4 o~ 10 4 of 9 13 of 17 ~ en ~ ..., 8. 21 0 · 11 1•n UI uliU ~ 'is IPH n1 iun 1 · fJI U1 '~ d1U! Id ~f 1 ' ift llu =1e I H '! n i~J' ·. 11 . t1 l hi un =Ii H f~ II ll Ji di ~. 'i' !'U h[r'.: H II !! I ~J n U ~ ?l d.. , t ID 0 1 (J\ 14 of 17 L -~ 0 UI "'."' HlO ! 0 r .& ~ei, .f U i J 1 i ;u II H! ;i rl ti= , 'II h Jil~- •1 1 !;1 •. fl ~. ! ' :1 HI ll I f J ! ID r I= I 11 1 1 l... ~ ~ . 1 "'i ... .t1r1 . a. 11 ! I! . i =" -·- ~ 0 l:'l ·1-4 r;j 0 H ~ ~rn ~ z 'sJ 0 : '""' CD ·ui l"1 0 0 ............ 0 ID IO I\) !'\) W .............. 0 0 .......... INDEX NO. 850193/2013 0 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/05/2020 . 8 t !•f-t i, FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/05/2020 09:57 AM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 155 [* 14] ~ Ch ~ "'.I g ~ .1u;1 u11 u11n u1 u11urun1 . tl 11i! i!ji n 11 n 1 au • 11 1111 11 tl \ i! l ! i! Jih 1 l 11 rjh ! =i i ;I !l i( i I ;; p~i ~i 'i I i' . I JI • Jr 1rfr 1• fr ! If i 1 !1 1h1 t d IQ 0 1 1 s 15 of 17 !! l Jt II Ht ,- 1( HI r~ U ii ,., tIfJ'1i1 irlI ,.U II !I I ia r' iI f fi iI r.. '' fr u "'1 f i u r: r •J p ~"'I' 'i a r i I i ! I j ~J ~ If' I it' I I I I I l! !1r Ii' • fa. · l· "' ir ,1 Ia._I Cl\ 0 OI HiO "' IO ... D 0 s !~ i: s '• .• ~· Q 1-1 ~ .... Cll 0 ll'J "l z ez 0 • CX> .... (JI 0 0 ID W ....~ ~. ..... 0 ~ \Cl ........... 'l .... ____ ~- ~-~·-&- ~~ --. ----.~----' ..... INDEX NO. 850193/2013 -· 1-1 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/05/2020 ~ 0 ... ~--- •. ~~- FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/05/2020 09:57 AM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 155 [* 15] ~ {/J 0 l"J "'] 8 () 111111 IfIn f!H K11 uuII 111 1 1 1 ((£ e:, }I ....J tc tla .q. • l i J 1= fl lf i If- I =j -i Id -j - i ! 16 of 17 1 t f t f J!(J' fl 1,11 ·~· i !( !1 !1} JI f J It JJ JJjl= 1,J hh i !1!1 hj ! I I= . I= i h I fr 'J r ! I ! I ! I =l J I .!..,._,,., J i i ~ 1·11: ~: 1.f Jllf f · f fl fI f1 f J .I l ! l f f f ~ if J I i r .-: • r I ; i if I i i i li(;; ti1 lh l 11' 1' _ }11 i 1' I ... .., l . "' 0 a f o-4 ... . HiO \0 l- qa ~ I= a .~ f l.. ~ ·~ ' i. ~ 0 l'J H ~ 0 ,/ H z ~ ~ () z t>;1 ~ . 0 co ..... U1 0 0 ........... O· IQ " ~- - - -~-~---- - --...·-~---- -- ·--- --~- -~ ~-~----~ ·--..-------"' \D w ' ...... 1') ""> 0 0 .......... ' INDEX NO. 850193/2013 CJ> RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/05/2020 = i rs11.~111e: FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/05/2020 09:57 AM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 155 [* 16] [*FILED: 17] NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/05/2020 09:57 AM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 155 INDEX NO. 850193/2013 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/05/2020 . INDEX NO. 850193/201 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/09/201 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 90 . i ft&NIS....-., •• 11owhlell.................... _ ' h.. _ of73 ..... 31mlllldll35 . . . . . 17-fKfM1111; 'l'HBNCB..-..Voa1Uao9lddslllml&--mlltwlllldlolut.........,.. 0011111 otlS..,_"8..._40....,2WPllDI; . l'BBNCl.....,.... w111a1a .............. w111a ....... daaedolll ..... l lllflalu'40 ...... '1k7blllli . TRl!NCIWlfllllr• •Bnl 1'tdall bml. bdllrlorqlowtaa 6D lllt'Nllloadoll l2 ........... 25 . . . . 5 tlietMolm.~ TBBNCB.-..Vaaallll,...llnualatlllarqll.wllb111epm1,,,..,,.1NlllrJJ of1MlaC-diM OOU1WofU d.-23mlmdlll0 . . . . . JI tllt2Mt.a.talb palllt ar pJaw ofBBOINN1NG. 'l19lCBllClltllarJf, 1b1a lllt lllllMldlm1ecl ..... 14 MO tm1aar, ud 'l"'SBNc:Baaa••lbtldwfdl andlmof'l.Otilt maa ...,.ot4' M llK lllClbel todlopofat arpllae ofBBOINNINO. ....7ciUI · a of 10 · 8 of 9 17 of 17

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.