Deans v Treber Realty, LLC

Annotate this Case

Download PDF

Deans v Treber Realty, LLC 2018 NY Slip Op 30040(U) January 10, 2018 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: 155636/14 Judge: Jennifer G. Schecter Cases posted with a "30000" identifier, i.e., 2013 NY Slip Op 30001(U), are republished from various New York State and local government sources, including the New York State Unified Court System's eCourts Service. This opinion is uncorrected and not selected for official publication. [*FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 01/12/2018 09:32 AM 1] NYSCEF DOC. NO. 85 INDEX NO. 155636/2014 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 01/12/2018 SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF NEW YORK: PART 57 ----------------------------------------x RAMAR DEANS, DECISION AND ORDER Index No. 155636/14 Plaintiff, -againstTREBER REALTY, LLC and 715-723 SIXTH AVENUE OWNERS CORP, Defendants, ----------------------------------------x TREBER REALTY, LLC and 715-723 SIXTH AVENUE OWNERS CORP . I Index No. 595454/14 Third-Party Plaintiffs, -againstCITIBANK, N .A. I Third-Party Defendant. ----------------------------------------x JENNIFER G. SCHECTER, J.: Pursuant to CPLR 3212, N.A. third-party defendant Citibank, (Citi) moves for summary judgment dismissing the action against it. Third-party plaintiffs, Treber Realty, LLC (Treber) and 715-723 Sixth Avenue Owner's Corp (the Co-op), oppose Ci ti's motion. summary judgment. Treber cross moves for conditional The motion is granted in part and the cross motion is denied. Background Plaintiff Ramar Deans, a Citi employee, commenced this action against Treber and Co-op seeking recovery for injuries 2 of 11 [*FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 01/12/2018 09:32 AM 2] NYSCEF DOC. NO. 85 INDEX NO. 155636/2014 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 01/12/2018 Index No. 155636/14 Page 2 Deans v Treber Realty, LLC. that he allegedly sustained to his left wrist and hand on July 8, 2013 at West 101 23rd Treber owns the Building. Street in Manhattan (Building) . It leased the residential portion to the co-op and the commercial portion to Citi (Premises) (Affirmation in Support [Sup] , Ex G) . Mr. Deans claims that a day after water leaked into the basement, he slipped on stairs while ascending from the basement level to the main floor of the Premises because his feet got wet. Although Mr. Deans did not observe water, he noticed that the carpet was damp and saw blowers in the basement (Sup, Ex E at 57-60) For years the Building, and specifically the Premises, suffered from water infiltration stemming from a roof leak and a ground-water basement floor leak that caused water retained a seep into (Sup, Ex H Affidavit of Daniel Garley) . exact source of the water infiltration, discovered. to however, The was never In an effort to address the infiltration, Citi contractor, Dolphin, and Treber agreed to pay $11,078.04 for the work (Treber Opposition [Opp], Ex 5). June 2 O, the 2O13 The agreement between Ci ti and Treber regarding payment for the work stated in relevant part: "Tenant is making the repair as an accommodation and the undertaking of such repair and the partial payment by Tenant is 3 of 11 [*FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 01/12/2018 09:32 AM 3] NYSCEF DOC. NO. 85 INDEX NO. 155636/2014 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 01/12/2018 Index No. 155636/14 Page 3 Deans v Treber Realty, LLC. not an admission of any responsibility of Tenant pursuant to the Lease. Landlord is making the Payment to Tenant solely as an accommodation to Tenant and the Landlord has stated that it does not have any responsibility under the Lease to make or pay for such repairs and/or to make the Payment and/or to pay any other additional sums in connection with this matter" (Treber Opp, Ex 5) The Lease The lease between Treber and Citi (Treber/Citi Lease) provides: 10. Repairs (a) Co-op' s Obligation to Repair: "Tenant understands that [Co-op] which occupies the residential portion of the building in which the demised premises are located is required under the terms of its lease to make necessary exterior and structural interior repairs to the premises (including cleaning, maintenance and repair of the sidewalks abutting the demised premises) and shall keep in good order, condition and repair all plumbing, heating and electrical equipment . the Co-op shall not be obligated to make any repair or rectify any condition necessitated by any act or omission of Tenant . their respective employees, agents, invitees, licensees or contractors. (b) Tenant's Obligation to Repair: Tenant shall keep and maintain in good order, condition and repair the premises and any part thereof . . . except for those matters within the Co-op' s obligation to repair . 4 of 11 [*FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 01/12/2018 09:32 AM 4] NYSCEF DOC. NO. 85 INDEX NO. 155636/2014 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 01/12/2018 Deans v Treber Realty, LLC. 20. Index No. 155636/14 Page 4 Access by Certain Persons Landlord, Co-op and its designee(s) shall have the right to enter upon the premises for the purpose of inspecting the premises, making repairs or alterations to the premises or the building in which the same are located . " 24. Non-Liability of Landlord: Landlord shall not be responsible to Tenant for any loss or damage that may be occasioned by . . . or for any loss or damage resulting to Tenant or its property from water, gas, steam, fire or the bursting, stoppage or leakage of sewer pipes, provided that such loss or damage is not occasioned by the negligence of the Landlord or its agents, contractors, servants or employees. 25. Indemnity: Tenant agrees to indemnify, defend and save Landlord harmless from and against any and all claims and demands(except such that result from the negligence of Landlord or its agents, contractors, servants or employees) for or in connection with any accident, injury or damage whatsoever caused by any person or property arising, directly or indirectly, out of the business conducted in the Premises or occurring in 'or about the Premises or any part thereof, and from any and all costs, expenses and liabilities, incurred in connection with any such claim or proceeding brought thereon. Tenant shall obtain at its own expense and keep in full force and effect during the Term, a policy of commercial general liability insurance ., under which Tenant is named as the insured, and Landlord, Landlord's managing agent, the Co-op, are named as additional insureds. 39. 40. Tenant's Insurance: Enforcement of Co-op Obligations: For purposes of this Lease, 5 of 11 the term "Co-op [*FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 01/12/2018 09:32 AM 5] NYSCEF DOC. NO. 85 INDEX NO. 155636/2014 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 01/12/2018 Index No. 155636/14 Page 5 Deans v Treber Realty, LLC. Obligations" shall mean the obligations of the Co-op to make certain repairs to the demised premises and/or the building to otherwise provide services and benefits required to be provided by the Co-op and granted to the Tenant pursuant to the Co-op Lease and/or any terms or provisions of this Lease requiring Tenant to look to the Co-op not the Landlord for performance (collectively, the "Co-op Obligations") . Notwithstanding anything to the contrary . (A) Landlord shall use reasonable efforts to cause the Co-op to observe and/or perform the Co-op Obligations . [If the Co-op does not cure] then, unless Landlord, in its sole discretion and without obligation to do so undertakes to perform the Co-op Obligations of the Co-op, Tenant shall have all the rights granted to Landlord as landlord under the Co-op Lease. " (Sup, Ex G at~~ lO[a] and [b], 20, 24, 25, 39 and 40). The Third-Party Action Treber and the Co-op commenced a third-party action against Citi and asserted causes of action for contribution, common-law indemnification, contractual indemnification and breach of contract based on Citi's alleged failure to procure insurance (Sup, Ex C) . Ci ti moves for summary judgment dismissing all of the third-party plaintiffs' claims against it arguing that Workers Compensation Law contribution and indemnification claims. § 11 bars common-law It urges that it was not negligent in creating any hazardous condition or in making any repairs as the repairs were 6 of 11 not its responsibility. [*FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 01/12/2018 09:32 AM 6] NYSCEF DOC. NO. 85 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 01/12/2018 Index No. 155636/14 Page 6 Deans v Treber Realty, LLC. Lastly, INDEX NO. 155636/2014 it maintains that it satisfied its obligation to procure insurance. The Co-op opposes Citi's motion and argues that, pursuant to its lease with Treber, it was not obligated to make repairs to the Premises because the ~ (Co-op Opp at source of the 12) . . It also urges that water infiltration was never discovered, issues of fact remain precluding summary judgment (Co-op Opp at ~ 13). Treber cross moves for summary judgment based on Citi's breach of its contractual defense obligations, breach of its indemnity obligations and breach of its insurance obligations. Alternatively, Treber seeks an order directing Citi to undertake the legal defense of Treber and to indemnify it (Affirmation in Opposition [Opp] at ~ 2) . Analysis Summary Judgment is a drastic remedy that should not be granted if there is any doubt as to the existence of material triable issues(see Glick & Dolleck v Tri-Pac Export Corp, 22 NY2d 439, 441 [1968) [denial of summary judgment appropriate where an issue is "arguable" J ; LLC, 101 AD3d 490, 493 Sosa v 46th Street Develop. [1st Dept 2012)). The burden, which is "a heavy one," is on the movant to make a prima facie showing of entitlement to judgment as a matter of law by presenting 7 of 11 [*FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 01/12/2018 09:32 AM 7] NYSCEF DOC. NO. 85 INDEX NO. 155636/2014 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 01/12/2018 Index No. 155636/14 Deans v Treber Realty, LLC. Page 7 evidence in admissible form demonstrating the absence of any disputed material facts (see William Jenack J. Estate Appraisers and Auctioneers, Inc. v Rabizadeh, 22 NY3d 470, 475 [2013]) . "Where the moving party fails to meet this burden, summary judgment cannot be granted, and the non-moving party bears no burden to summary judgment. a prima facie otherwise persuade the Court against Indeed, the moving party's failure to make showing of entitlement to summary judgment requires a denial of the motion, regardless of the sufficiency of the opposing papers" (id.). Common-Law Indemnity and Contribution Claims In an action arising from a workplace injury, a third party may assert a claim against plaintiff's employer sounding in common-law indemnity or contribution only if the plaintiff suffered grave injury (Ironshore Indem., Inc. v W&W Glass, LLC, 151 AD3d 511 [1st Dept 2017]; Aramburu v Midtown West B, LLC, 126 AD3d 498 [1st Dept 2015]; Keita v City of New York, 128 AD3d 409 [1st Dept 2015]). By statute, "grave injury" is of an arm, defined as "permanent and total loss of use . leg, hand or foot" (Worker's Compensation Law § 11). Here, plaintiff, who was injured while working for Citi, does not allege a permanent or total loss of use of his hand or wrist 8 of 11 [*FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 01/12/2018 09:32 AM 8] INDEX NO. 155636/2014 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 85 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 01/12/2018 Deans v Treber Realty, LLC. Index No. 155636/14 Page 8 (Sup, Ex F at ~ 5); thus, the third-party plaintiffs' claims for common-law indemnification and contribution are dismissed. Contractual Indemnification Pursuant to the Treber/Citi Lease, Citi agreed to "indemnify, defend and save Landlord harmless from and against any and all claims and demands(except such that result from the negligence of Landlord servants or employees)" or (Sup, Ex G its agents, at~ 25). contractors, The Treber/Citi Lease references the lease between the co-op and Treber in setting forth (Sup, Ex G at the parties' ~~ obligations 10 and 40) . to perform repairs It also authorizes Citi to look to the Co-op for enforcement of the Co-op's repair obligations for the demised premises under the Co-op's lease with Treber (Sup, Ex G at ~ 40) . The Treber/Co-op lease states that the Co-op shall make all repairs to the Premises, except when Citi is negligent however, (Treber Opp, remains Ex 2 Article 9) . responsible for certain The landlord, repairs Premises regardless of its contract with the Co-op.* to the Because, ·Treber is an out-of-possession owner and retained the right to reenter the Premises (Sup, Ex G at ~ 20) . "An outof-possession landlord is generally not liable for the condition of the demised premises unless the landlord . . [has the] right to reenter in order to inspect or repair, and the defective condition is a significant structural or design defect that is contrary to a specific statutory safety provision. While a landlord may not delegate its duty to keep its premises in a safe condition with regard to 9 of 11 [*FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 01/12/2018 09:32 AM 9] NYSCEF DOC. NO. 85 INDEX NO. 155636/2014 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 01/12/2018 Index No. 155636/14 Page 9 Deans v Treber Realty, LLC. among other things, there was no expert evidence attesting to the cause of the water infiltration that was the source of plaintiff's accident, no party established the negligence of any other party, the absence of its own negligence and whether the contractual Accordingly, the indemnification motion and clause cross motion was triggered. for contractual indemnification are denied. The insurance fourth is cause of dismissed. action Citi for failure submitted to proof procure of self- insurance through Citigroup, Inc. and neither Treber nor the Co-op have come forward with any proof to the contrary (Sup, Ex I). Rather, Treber and the Co-op's insurer commenced a declaratory-judgment action urging that Citi must tender a defense in this action Citigroup Inc., (Greater New York Mut. Index No. Ins. 154475/2015; Opp at 26). Co. v It is clear that Citi obtained insurance pursuant to the lease. It is unclear whether Citi must defend Treber and/or the Co-op in third parties, a landlord is free to contract with its tenant to maintain and repair the premises, and to allocate the risk of liability to third parties by the procurement of liability insurance for their mutual benefit. If that party violates the contract by failing to maintain the premises, that party may be required to indemnify the landowner, and in such case the landowner's liability would be vicarious" (Velez v 31 Oliver St. NYC, LLC, 2014 WL 4063041 [Sup Ct, New York County 2014]) . 10 of 11 [*FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 01/12/2018 09:32 AM 10] NYSCEF DOC. NO. 85 INDEX NO. 155636/2014 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 01/12/2018 Index No. 155636/14 Page 10 Deans v Treber Realty, LLC. this action as the cause of the water infiltration has not been established. Accordingly, it is ORDERED that Citi's motion for summary judgment is granted to the extent that the first, second and fourth causes of action in the third-party complaint are dismissed; and it is further ORDERED that the cross motion for summary judgment is denied in its entirety. This is the decision and order of the court. Dated: January 10, 2018 G. SCHECTER 11 of 11

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.