TPE Inc. v Travelers Cas. & Sur. Co. of Am.
Annotate this Case
Download PDF
TPE Inc. v Travelers Cas. & Sur. Co. of Am. 2014 NY Slip Op 33427(U) December 1, 2014 Supreme Court, Queens County Docket Number: 701699/2014 Judge: Orin R. Kitzes Cases posted with a "30000" identifier, i.e., 2013 NY Slip Op 30001(U), are republished from various state and local government websites. These include the New York State Unified Court System's E-Courts Service, and the Bronx County Clerk's office. This opinion is uncorrected and not selected for official publication. [*FILED: QUEENS COUNTY CLERK 12/05/2014 11:36 AM 1] INDEX NO. 701699/2014 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 43 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/05/2014 Short Form Order NEW YORK SUPREME COURT - QUEENS COMMERCIAL DIVISION Present: HONORABLE ORIN R. KITZES Justice COUNTY IA Part ---------------------------------------x TPE INC, d/b/a The Plumbing Exchange, Index Number 17 701699/ 2014 Plaintiff, Motion Date -againstTRAVELERS CASUALTY AND SURETY COMPANY AMERICA, FEDERAL INSURANCE COMPANY FIDELITY ANF DEPOSIT COMPANY OF MARYLAND, ZURICH AMERICAN INSURANCE COMPANY, LIBERTY MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY and CONTINENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY, July 18, 2014 Motion Seq. No. __ 1_ OF Defendants. ---------------------------------------x PILeo DEC .• 52014 Q~~~~;rcg~e:~ read on this motion by The following papers numbered E9 to E42 the defendants for an order pursuant to CPLR 3211 (a) (1) and (7) dismissing the complaint against 'them. Notice of Motion - Affidavits - Exhibits Memoranda of Law Answering Affidavits - Exhibits Reply Affidavits . . . . Papers Numbered E9-38 E36 E39-E40 E4l-E42 Upon the foregoing papers it is ordered that the branch of the motion to dismiss the complaint pursuant to CPLR 3211 (a) (1) is granted. The branch of the motion to dismiss the complaint pursuant to CPLR 32ll(a) (7) is denied as moot . • The defendant sureties issued a labor and material bond to a joint venture comprised of Turner Construction payment Company [* 2] and Scalamandre & Sons, Inc. in connection project at JFK International Airport. with a construction The bond precludes a suit against the sureties "unless claimant shall have given written notice to any two of the following: the Principal [Joint Venture], the Owner [Delta], or the Surety. . within ninety (90l days after such claimant did or performed the last of the work or labor. or furnished the last of the materials for which said claim is made, stating with substantial accuracy the amount claimed and the name of the party to whom the materials were furnished, or for whom the work or labor was done or performed." The first notice of claim that TPE submitted to defendant sureties was by letter from its attorneys, dated September 12, 2013. This letter reads in relevant part: "We represent TPE, Inc. d/b/a The Plumbing Exchange ("TPE"). TPE supplied plumbing materials and supplies to contractors/agents, Bass Plumbing & Heating Corp. and J.E.S. Plumbing and Heating Corp. for the above mentioned project." According to plaintiff TPE, the letter gave defendants written notice of a claim for money owed on materials plaintiff supplied for the project, the last of which was supplied to J.E.S. Plumbing and Heating Corp (J.E.S.) around August 29, 2013. Plaintiff has submitted a copy of invoices showing (1) products were sold to J.E.S. and shipped to "Delta Airlines, JFK" and (2) the "date ordered" as August 29, 2013. Plaintiff TPE also sent a letter dated October 25, 2013 and a completed bond claim form' sworn to on October 10, 2013 in which TPE's president asserted that the last date on which TPE supplied labor and/or materials to Bass Plumbing & Heating Corp. was June 5, 2012. that the last date that TPE could have Upon determining provided timely notice under the bond was September 3, 2012 and that the first notice was over a year too late, the sureties rejected the claim. In response, TPE's attorney sent a letter, dated February 28, 2014, with a revised notice of claim form alleging that TPE had also supplied materials to J.E.S., the final date being "around August 29, 2013." The letter reads in relevant part: "However, as noted in our claim, TPE continued the work at the project for another subcontractor, J.E.S []. Thus, TPE's work continued at the project until the last day it supplied materials to J.E.S., which was about August 29, 2013. *** This should clarify the last day materials and labor was supplied at the project was around August 29, 2013. Thus, TPE's claim, served on September 12, 2013, was 2 [* 3] well within the time limits provided in the bond." (TPE sent invoices to J.E.S., dated May 7, 2013 and August 29, 2013, totaling $935.90.) Pursuant to CPLR 3211 provides a party may move to dismiss one or more causes of action asserted against him on the ground that a defense is founded on documentary evidence. (See, Galvan v 9519 Third Avenue Restaurant Corp., 74 AD3d 743.) To prevail on a CPLR 3211 (a) (1) motion, the documentary evidence submitted "must be such that it resolves all the factual issues as a matter of law and conclusively and definitively disposes of the plaintiff's claim." (Fernandez v Cigna Property and Casualty Insurance Company, 188 AD2d 700, 702; see Galvan v 9519 Third Avenue Restaurant Corp, supra; Vanderminden v Vanderminden, 226 AD2d 1037; Bronxville Knolls, Inc. v Webster Town Center Partnership, 221 AD2d 248.) A subcontractor is bound, as a third-party beneficiary, to the terms of a material and labor payment bond entered into specifically to secure payment to such parties." (Krugman and Fox Canst. Corp. v Elite Associates, Inc., 167 AD2d 514.) In this case, defendant sureties have submitted documentary evidence which is dispositive of this case. The letter from TPE's attorney dated February 28, 2014 admits that "TPE finished supplying materials and labor for Bass Plumbing & Heating Corp" on June 5, 2012. The letter dated February 28, 2014 from TPE's attorney makes clear that TPE calculates the time to submit a claim to the sureties from the date on which it last supplied materials to J.E.S., that is, around August 29, 2013. However, the documentary evidence shows that the claim made against the bond by TPE is only for materials which TPE supplied to Bass Plumbing & Heating Corp. TPE's claim against the bond is in the amount of $123,005.62. TPE filed a mechanic's lien, dated September 12, 2012, related to the project in which TPE asserted that it was "employed" by Bass Plumbing & Heating and that it was owed $123,005.62, the same amount for which it made a claim against the bond. Moreover, the spreadsheet that TPE submitted to the sureties in support of its claim has items totaling $123,005.62, and none of these items concern J.E.S. In opposition to the instant motion, plaintiff TPE failed to show that any issues of fact remain to be tried. The affidavit of Zalmen Blau, the President of TPE, does not state unequivocally that J.E.S. failed to pay the invoices sent to it; the affidavit merely states ambiguously "the claim was based on materials which remain unpaid for the project, the last of which were supplied to J.E.S." 3 [* 4] The bond precludes a suit against the sureties "unless claimant shall have given written notice . . . within ninety (90) days after such claimant did or performed the last of the work or labor, or furnished the last of the materials for which said claim is made." The bond clearly provides that a claimant must give ninety days notice calculated from the time that it last furnished work, labor, or materials that are the subje t of the claim. The documentary evidence conclusively establish that TPE did not comply with the notice clause in the bond. The cumentary evidence in this case conclusively establishes that e sureties have a defense which is good as a matter of law, t', ing them to a dismissal based on CPLR 3211(a) (1) (see Goshen t 1 Life Ins. Co. of New York, 98 NY2d 314.) Dated: December 1, 2014 4
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
