McKay v Papageorge

Annotate this Case

Download PDF

McKay v Papageorge 2006 NY Slip Op 30831(U) February 28, 2006 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: 101249/04 Judge: Joan B. Carey Cases posted with a "30000" identifier, i.e., 2013 NY Slip Op 30001(U), are republished from various state and local government websites. These include the New York State Unified Court System's E-Courts Service, and the Bronx County Clerk's office. This opinion is uncorrected and not selected for official publication. [* 1] i-_-<' ' - .•~ t ! !·_"=~ ! ..I • ~ ·-_ !_ •, • I-.,;: •~ ,' ; , .. .• ":- . . - . -: ~" - -1 "':,'~_..•";r;~·:!., ~ ·• ;· - - 1 · .• - . : ' - - l. ·.·. ·-~·· t r '. [ -. - I·: t.. {--- (- [-•,: Despi_te plaintiff's contention to ..the c:onfrary, th~ f~ct that Dr~ Papag~org~'s · supporting pr.oof was -submit1ed by way· of _attorney ~ffir(n$tion a·n·n~xfng. depositi9n · 1 . · f~stio.lony :~~<( :O_ther docµmentary eviden_c~· d~e~;~otdefeafher. right to. S!JITISn'-·~y judgm~tit . .' '(see·Jblari ~v. 'i=arrell Liri"es~:fncv 64 NY2d J0'.9.2. !f1 Q$5li Lewis • • • • ,. • • • • • _. • • • . 4' • -tie'lm§ljt~'frnJ~ ;mi:, i:~f~t)~a ~~4 t1 st Q'~'t- ~11~.J!·_ • - - • ...;. ~ v. ,Safety- ·Disposal System ..of . .. - ·- :' ·. ·; " • ~ • ' • ' . - • •• .. < : -' : · - ,_" . • • _. '' : " .· ' . .' 4 : -:.' .. -- :.·,__ __ , .. - .·· - .· - .;:~- [* 2] . !_~. . .. .. . ~ .'. ~ ...... : • I. •• ; •. • . /; ~ .~ ·:; ·, ~) " ~ . [. I:· j:. .. f'. I . .. . hi. aCldi~lon to. '1~r ·cJa im$-· rel~t-ing ~ I I i ..., r · 1 1ire '~4~Je-ct -~9/~·:-9'Q·e~yftaf·:~tc!itu\~:~9f:fimlt~_{ip11§~" ~:;- ···> · ...... ••• :fo .~llrgi~~l-01alp~actice, .pt~in.tiff 8-lleges in ]~er, porhplaint that :or~. Papageorg~; .ih, remt)ving carti.lag·e Jroin 'the t_ip Qf- plaintiff~s :nose, perforin~d :~.:.P.ro<:~·ciure. ' that~pl~int~ff ·ci~tf not consent: to, W'1i~h1 accQrd.ing Jo plaintift,. . <:9fJ.iJ~litHte[dJ a; ·~ommpli.l~w. 8$sault. !I. Pefendant,·-~ek.s: sumrtJ~rv· jµ~gn1~·nt ctismis.~ing ~this cl~lm: a·rguing that it i~'.ti~.~: b~~r~d, . pur$u~nt_to cP:-..fi 2~ 5f~>~ ~hi~h ~J~t'S::forih~hafl~(~l1~i()q~~· tq~ ~lc(i~-~~ ·$uq~.as ass~~·~-~~.~d~batt~_ry; _ . ·> ;;. I· . :: ! ' '• ,• ~~·,·~ •I '' :_::.""~: ,~} . :-,.., -:, ..:. •• ,:. • •• ·~."': • .. ' ~:·-!.;.- -·.· ,_·, ,_ ,'_ ...~ : I f i • . -.~' ·· • , :·. ·",.. . · · _ · , -. .- - . ... . L· ... ._,":... ••& ' • ~, ~· I• ' ·:. • , · , . · . .. · , ., , , }:!I & ~ ~. · ..........: •.•::....:..::...;..,..;.-,_... ~l~,'~·--·_;' ., . . . , - . f" .·. ,- ... '. .. \ ~··~ ·.- .. ' ••• . .:.~ .:: .- .··~·· - ' [* 3] I i. [ .. I I·-· l ! .> l I I I 1· /, i · ., BJ~'ed pn 1ta~ :f_gr~a~ing, ii iS.· herellv ·. •. • • - -. • • • • • I - • - • • _·. -::: ~· \··. . ....:-_ ~ ., . --~ ~-i: .i.: . . . . _-: ,• - - I .. ' ~ ·, - . : .... • ~ ,.. -~ .-.· . .- . .. : , ;_ ~ ..... _ • [* 4] ORDERED that the defendant Ariadna Papageorge, M.D.'s motion for summary judgment dismissing the complaint i:; granted to the extent that plaintiff's assault claim and claim for breach of contract are dismissed, and the remainder of the motion is denied; and it is further, ORDERED that counsel for all parties are to appear before the court on April 17, 2006, at 9:30am, at 111 Centre Street, room 572, Part 400, for jury selec · Dated: 02/28/2006 Check one: 0 FINAL DIBPOSITION Check if appropriate: 0 DO NOT POST 0 REFERENCE F 'LE 0 ' I \ M~R-7?006 Net-1 ~OR~ ff'(& .couNt'< C\.E'lK'S o -•

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.