Jeffrey A. Cookson v. State of Maine
Annotate this CaseIn October, 2002, a trial court entered a judgment on a jury verdict finding Defendant Jeffrey Cookson guilty on two counts of intentional murder for the deaths of his ex-girlfriend and her best friend. The court sentenced Defendant to two consecutive life sentences. During the trial, witness David Vantol confessed privately to Defendant’s attorney and a private investigator that he had committed both murders. Immediately after the jury returned its verdict against Defendant, defense counsel disclosed the confession to the court and prosecutor. Later that day, Vantol lead police to a spot in the woods where he had buried miscellaneous articles of clothing, and a gun that testing would reveal was the murder weapon. Vantol continued to confess to the murders, but police did not believe him. They asked him to take a polygraph test, but he failed it. Frantic that no one believed him, Vantol threatened to harm himself. Later he would be admitted to the hospital. While there, Vantol recanted his confessions, and told investigators the items he provided were unrelated to murders. The State kept the items in its possession. Defendant filed motions with the court to have DNA testing done on the clothing and other items still in the State’s possession. The Superior Court denied Defendant’s motion regarding the clothing testing, but only gave an analysis of the applicable statute that was the basis of its denial. The court ultimately concluded that Defendant failed to meet the chain-of-custody requirement of the statute. The court did not engage in any analysis or provide any other reasoning for its decision. The Supreme Court vacated the Superior Court’s decision and remanded the case back to the court so that it may issue findings on all points raised by Defendant’s post-conviction DNA motion.
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.