State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. v. Koshy

Annotate this Case

Download PDF

STATE OF MAINE YORK, ss. 1J~6~~~~L: )~ 0 STATE FARM MUTUAL 10' INSURANCE COMPANY, '_':; iY SF Yl:i~'\ CU:'Ri'iS C)t:T!CE Plaintiff v. PRAMODH KOSHY, Defendant and ENTERPRISE RENT-A-CAR COMPANY OF BOSTON, INC., SCANDENT GROUP, INC., SCANDENT INDIA, ANDREW BOUCHARD, JR., TAMMY E. ROBBINS, KENNETH A. DIXON, ANNA N. DIXON, EUGENE LO and RANJINI, Parties-In-Interest ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) SUPERIOR COURT Civil Action Docket No. CV-06-A6<~ Pit F--, /('r:-~ ", 7;:>1 c".' !", i DEFENDANT'S MOTION TO STAY PROCEEDINGS Defendant Pramodh Koshy ("Mr. Koshy"), by and through undersigned counsel, respectfully requests that this Honorable Court stay all proceedings in this declaratory judgment action brought by State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company ("State Farm"), with the exception ofPlainiiffs motion for summary judgment, for the following reasons: In this declaratory judgment action, the discovery deadline has passed, the motion deadline is imminent, and preparation for trial is the next step. Plaintiff State Farm has filed a motion for summary judgment. In his opposition to the motion for summary judgment, Mr. Koshy drew a necessary distinction between the duty to defend and the duty to indemnify. Because the duty to defend is a separate question from the duty to indemnify, the Maine Supreme Judicial Court has held that, "if courts conclude that an insurer owes its insured the duty to defend an underlying action, it should defer ruling on indemnity." Northern Sec. Ins. Co. v. Dolley, 669 A.2d 1320, 1323 (Me. 1996). If, in ruling on the motion for summary judgment, the Court finds that State Farm has no duty to defend, afortiori State Farm will have no duty to indemnify. If, on the other hand, the Court finds that State Farm does have a duty to defend, the question of State Farm's duty to indemnify should be resolved not by a trial in the instant case now, but after the underlying tort action because, "[f]acts may come to light in the course of the underlying action that are material to the issue of indemnity." Am. Policyholders' Ins. Co. v. Kyes, 483 A.2d 337, 339 (Me. 1984). As the Law Court has pointed out, an insured "should not be required to litigate the underlying facts of a claim in order to obtain a defense to the litigation when he has already obligated an insurer by contract to defend him." Elliott v. Hanover Ins. Co., 1998 NIE 138, ~ 7, 711 A.2d 1310, 1312. WHEREFORE, Defendant respectfully requests that this Honorable Court stay all proceedings in this declaratory judgment action, with the exception of Plaintiffs motion for summary judgment, until after the resolution of the underlying tort action, Docket Number CY-04-151. ftA Dated at Portland, Maine this ~ day of July, 2007. mey for Defendant Pramodh Koshy 2 PETRUCCELLI, MARTIN & HADDOW, LLP 50 Monument Square P. O. Box 17555 Portland, Maine 04112-8555 (207) 775-0200 By: James B. Haddow, Esq. - Bar No. 3340 NOTICE Matter in opposition to this Motion must be filed not later than twenty-one (21) days after the filing of this Motion, unless another time is provided by the Maine Rules of Civil Procedure or set by the Court. Failure to file timely opposition will be deemed a waiver of all objections to the Motion, which may be granted without further notice or hearing. C> i~ ~ ~ ~ ~ r~ ~ flf)f?7L ~ ~eu-r-lf -k- ~ ...- ' ~ A.J.~" A~ /' ~ CV-Ol./-/SJ , - u. ~ Q.~ecA~. ~ ~ r~ 0- A~ 7- ~ ~ ~ -....r;r 6Jv--~. 7l~ ~~·.s~~~~ a h'Hlj ~ 4...::.7 ~ ~ ~ 7 'f/..A ~- (~4'~ ~ ~J ~ ~ ~ tyA;:k ~." ?1~ -J~~~,,-.-J., I ~ ~~, ~~ ~. tF~ (/ rJ! ~ / ft,~ (!~ ~ (, (; if A, ZcI ~ ~.s 'jh..:r f 3~.o~ 13;2 ~ ~ ~.A-e H;~ p- 'fk ~ ~ ~ -It... ~O~: ~ /0 'S ~ j,Q/07 /" ?t4.-:;-. ,.f~ ~ ~ ~?-I ~ Wf..p ~ {'~ ~ //VtC//..A7Y"Yl 3...., P 7 . / /1-1<-1'. h ~ ~ . -..:r -'- ~ f~ ~~ ~ ~ ~/'Y ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 3 ~ ~

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.