Shawn E. Canty VS Jose G. Barragan, Venture Transport Logistics and Zurich North American Insurance Company
Annotate this Case
Download PDF
STATE OF LOUISIANA COURT OF APPEAL, FIRST CIRCUIT SHAWN E. CANTY NO. 2019 CW 1515 VERSUS JOSE G. BARRAGAN, TRANSPORT ZURICH VENTURE LOGISTICS AND NORTH AMERICAN INSURANCE COMPANY In Jose Re: G. Zurich DECEMBER 19, Barragan, North supervisory Parish of St. BEFORE: WRIT GRANTED. in Duces complete business this reverse judgment. the So. 2d 287, a AND LANIER, the Motion Dr. to the trial court Compel Cenac 1099s and JJ. trial Christopher returns Sr., from court' per the show So. 2d income 388, and courts manner. the LLC' 2018 November the App. must this are s and 8, 2019 information Bianchi 4th v. Cir. clearly have state sources and, dispute"). La. Also could Pattison 1972) (" App. Cir. 1984) ( allowing " and that obtained Pontiac in Co., the party seeking establish good cause for information by relating its need In re Protest of Dow Chem. see returns required be further, 1st and confidential production by showing the unavailability of the 955 ( to information Tecum of Id.; La. return tax Duces whether 390 ( tax The curiam). Subpoena nature, intrusive the in M. D., 2014 s its abused Responses a 289 ( in 258 other applying for Court, District 123466. that the of Judicial and records. Stolzle v. non- party' s Safety & Consultants, Inc., 2002- 1197 ( La. 5/ 24/ 02), 819 requestor less tax of in requested the find Logistics Company, A showing of relevancy and good cause is required for Assur. personal We portion subpoena Systems No. PENZATO, granting Tecum for Subpoena 16th Mary, Transport Insurance writs, HIGGINBOTHAM, discretion Venture American 2019 to the Co., 458 unlimited its from issues So. 2d discovery solely on factually unsupported general allegations would render the confidentiality of the records meaningless"). failed the to show requested relevancy documents Accordingly, Dr. the Motion to Christopher Cenac Sr.' for and through complete 2018 is tax and good from the Quash s the 1099s returns AHP WIL OF APPEAL, J2 DEPUTY CL FOR FIRST CIRCUIT RK OF COURT THE COURT for non --party all Plaintiff the Subpoena from from granted. TMH COURT cause at Duces this Tecum insurance business has production for of time. as to companies years 2014
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
