Jonathan Lefeaux VS Andrea Craven, Shelter Mutual Insurance Company, and Southern Farm Bureau Casualty Insurance Company

Annotate this Case
Download PDF
STATE OF LOUISIANA COURT OF APPEAL FIRST CIRCUIT JONATHAN N0 LEFEAUX 2013 CW 0903 VERSUS ANDREA CRAVEN MUTUAL AND SHELTER INSURANCE SOUTHERN CASUALTY COMPANY FARM BUREAU INSURANCE Louisiana applying In Re Farm BEFORE RUHN 2013 supervisory emergency District No 18 Bureau Casualty Insurance Company for Judicial Rouge MARCH COMPANY writs Parish East Court of 19th Baton 162 596 PETTIGREW AND McDONALD JJ WRIT DENIED JTP JEK McDonald concur in concurs J with and judgment granting the prior the use to La claims of this Code to and dissents in part I issue of the admissibility of as the noting however that trial progresses and the relevancy of the evidence may be developed the trial court is to revisit its evidentiary rulings considering admissibility in light of any newly trial s court established the Furthermore relevancy prior regard claims part the lawsuits the and motion evidence COURT dissent I OF APPEAL t C Kc EPUTY art for limine evidence impeachment CLERK FOR THE 607 as it pertains should to not preclude purposes pursuant should test at trial so the of the issue to regard of evidence the reflecting s plaintiff admissibility reported income on his tax returns and I would reverse the trial court judgment and deny the plaintiff motion in s s of limine on that issue deferring any rulings admissibility of this evidence to the trial warrant Evid in lawsuits with FIRST CIRCUIT C LC I OF COURT COURT

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.