Organic Cannabis Foundation v. Commissioner, No. 17-72874 (9th Cir. 2020)
Annotate this Case
The Ninth Circuit affirmed the tax court's dismissal, based on lack of jurisdiction, of untimely petitions for redetermination of federal income tax deficiencies. In this case, taxpayers' attorneys selected an overnight delivery service that was not then on the published list and the error would not have mattered if the petitions had nonetheless arrived the next day. However, they were not received by the tax court until two days after being dropped off at a FedEx office in California.
The panel held that the tax court did not err by concluding that the petitions had not been timely received and that the mailbox rule did not apply. Furthermore, because I.R.C. 6213(a)'s time limits are jurisdictional, the panel held that equitable exceptions such as equitable tolling and waiver do not apply. Finally, the panel held that there was no basis for declaring the notice of deficiency invalid because of an improperly addressed notice.
Court Description: Tax. The panel affirmed the Tax Court’s dismissal, for lack of jurisdiction, of untimely petitions for redetermination of federal income tax deficiencies. Taxpayers operate marijuana dispensaries. In response to notices of deficiencies from the Internal Revenue Service, taxpayers sought to file their petitions for redetermination by April 22, 2015, the last day to file such petitions under I.R.C. § 6213(a). Taxpayers’ attorney used FedEx to send the petitions for filing in the Tax Court. The petitions were delivered to the Tax Court on the morning of April 23, 2015. The panel first rejected the contention that the petitions were timely because the Tax Court was inaccessible on the filing deadline. The panel held that, for non-electronic filings, a clerk’s office is “inaccessible” on the “last day” of a filing period only if the office cannot practicably be accessed for delivery of documents during a sufficient period of time up to and including the point at which “the clerk’s ORGANIC CANNABIS FOUND. V. CIR 3 office is scheduled to close.” The panel explained that here, taxpayers presented no evidence to show that the Tax Court Clerk’s Office could not be accessed during the substantial remaining portion of the day after FedEx unsuccessfully attempted delivery of the petitions earlier in the day on April 22, 2015. The panel next held that the petitions could not be deemed timely under the mailbox rule set forth in I.R.C. § 7502, because the particular FedEx service used here was not on the IRS’s formal list of designated delivery services to which the mailbox rule applies. The panel also held that because § 6213(a)’s time limits are jurisdictional, equitable exceptions such as equitable tolling and waiver do not apply. Finally, the panel rejected Organic Cannabis Foundation’s contention that its notice of deficiency was invalid because it was improperly addressed and that the error was not harmless, because the panel disagreed with the premise that the notice was misaddressed.
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.