Raul Plaza-Ramirez v. William Barr, No. 19-2945 (7th Cir. 2020)

Annotate this Case

Download PDF

'H H !, H'&$1H!&H '* & H/!, H >H >H ((>H >H65>4 United States Court of Appeals '*H, H . &, H !* -!, ! '?H $$!&'!+H93937H - %!,, H 1H47?H5353FH ! H 1H4;?H5353H H H '* H H >H ?$ $ H H H H >H ?$ $ H H H H >H ?$ $ H H H '+>H4<G5455H=H4<G5<78H ,!,!'&+H '*H .! /H ' H *G H G ?H *+H' H, H ' * H' H %%! * G H ?H ,!'&H (( $+>H H H H >H '>H 3;:G<7:G;6<H H >H ?H ,,'*& 1H & * $?H H >H H H H /'H1 *+H '?H, !+H '-*,H &! H -$H $ 2 G %!* 2D+H( ,!,!'&H '*H* .! /H' H H !& $H '* *H '*H !+H* %'. $H *'%H, H &!, H , , +H,'H 0! '>H ! # !$ "$ ?H<3;H >6 H5;5HB:, H !*>H534;C>H !$ H, ,H( ,!,!'&H/ +H( & !& ?H $ 2 G %!* 2H !$ H/!, H, H ' * H' H %%! * ,!'&H (( $+H ', H H%',!'&H,'H* '( &H & H H%',!'&H,'H* '&+! *>H H ' * H &! H, '+ H%',!'&+?H & H $ 2 G %!* 2H ! H&',H+ #H"- ! ! $H* .! />H &H H H FH , *H 0 %!&!& H , H *! +H & H , H * '* ?H / H . H '& $- H , ,H '* $H * -% &,H !+H -&& ++ *1>H H >H >H ((>H >H67B CAH !*>H >H67B C>H H '+>H4<G5455H=H4<G5<78H H5H !$ H H+ '& H%',!'&H,'H* '( &?H '&, & !& H, ,H H!+H&'/H, H , *H' H H !$ ?H/ 'H /'-$ H+- *H * + !(H! H *H , *H/ * H* %'. H,'H 0! '>H H !, $ $ "$ ?H 46;H >H ,>H5438HB534;C?H!&H+-(('*,H' H !+H* )- +,H '*H & $$ ,!'&H' H* %'. $?H, '- H H ! H&',H 0($ !&H '/H, ,H !+!'&H $( H !%>H H H ' * H &! H, !+H%',!'&H '*H,/'H* +'&+@H !*+,?H, H+, ,-, H & H* -$ ,!'&+H $G $'/H'&$1H'& H%',!'&H,'H* '( &?H/ ! H%-+,H H !$ H/!, !&H<3H 1+H' H, H'*! !& $H !G +!'&>H;H > > >HE455< B CB:CB C?HB CB!CAH;H > > >HE4336>5B CB5C>H $ 2 G %!* 2D+H& /H%',!'&H / +H-&,!% $1H & H+- ++!. >H '& ?H, H ' * H '& $- H, ,$ H ! H&',H '* H $ 2 G %!* 2H &1H* $! >HB H ' * H H, ,H!,H/'-$ H&',H 0 * !+ H!&H, H $! &D+H G .'*H!,+H !+ * ,!'&H,'H* '( &H $ >CH H $ 2 G %!* 2H !$ H H( ,!,!'&H+ #!& H"- ! ! $H* .! /H' H, ,H !+!'&?H & H H $+'H +# H, H ' * H,'H* '&+! *>H H ' * H &! H, ,H%',!'&?H* !, * ,!& H!,+H '& $-+!'&H , ,$ H ' +H&',H(*'.! H $ 2 G %!* 2H/!, H &1H & !,H & H !& H, ,H!,H &&',H % # H 0 (,!'&+H,'H, H+, ,-, H'&H & * $H -% &!, *! &H *'-& +?H+- H +H, H * + !(H -+ H 1H+ ( * ,!& H H( * &,H *'%H H !$ >H $ 2 G %!* 2H !$ H H( ,!,!'&H,'H* .! /H, ,H !+!'&H,''>H H . H"-*!+ ! ,!'&H,'H, H 0, &,H, ,H $ 2 G %!* 2H . & +H$ $H *G -% &,+>H H # $ "$ ?H473H >H ,>H4395HB5353C>H H $ 2 G %!* 2H +#+H-+H,'H '$ H, ,H H% # +H !%H $! ! $ H '*H & $$ ,!'&H' H* G %'. $H'&H, H *'-& H, ,H!,H(* . &,+H !, *H, H'*! !& $H ',! H,'H (( *HB , H -& H8?H 5343CH'*H, H$ , *H ' -% &,H+ ,,!& H, H *!& HB , H -& H49?H5343CH *'%H+,'((!& H, H *- $H' H,!% H,'/ * H43H1 *+H' H( 1+! $H(* + & H!&H, H &!, H , , +>H H!,+ $ H ' +H&',H * ++H, H)- +,!'&H/ , *H,/'H ' -% &,+HB'& H/!, H H *!& H , H & H '& H/!, '-,CH &H H '% !& H,'H1! $ H'& H. $! H ',! H,'H (( *?H/ ! H+,'(+H, H G *- $H' H,!% >H /'H '-*,+H' H (( $+H . H $ ?H '/ . *?H, ,H H!%($! +H H& ,!. H &+/ *?H/ !$ H,/'H', *+H . H $ H, ,H,* ,!& H,/'H ' -% &,+H +H'& H. $! H ',! H!+H ( *%!++! $ >H '%( * H $ "$ $ ?H<84H >6 H494HB6 H !*>H5353C?H & H # # !$ "$ ?H<86H >6 H44:9HB43, H !*>H5353C?H/!, H # $ "$ ?H<73H >6 H 4<5?H535HB9, H !*>H534<C?H & H !# $ "$ ?H<85H >6 H56<HB8, H !*>H5353C>H ,H)- +G ,!'&H!+H( & !& H '* H &', *H( & $H' H, !+H '-*,H!&H $ "$ ?H '>H4<G56:8HB * - H *>H6?H5353C>H H H &+/ *H ' +H&',H% ,, *H,'H, !+H(*' !& ?H '/ . *?H -+ H $ 2 G %!* 2H$'+,H '&H,/'H *'-& +@H, H,!% G & G&-% *H$!%!,+H & H, H ' * D+H '& $-+!'&H, ,$ H ' +H&',H ++!+,H !%>H $ 2 G %!* 2H '&, +,+H, H+ '& H -,H! &'* +H, H !*+,>H H &G 1D+H *! H!&H, !+H '-*,H '&, & +H, ,H, !+H '&+,!,-, +H H/ !. *H & H +#+H-+H,'H &1H, H ( ,!,!'&+H '*H, ,H* +'&H $'& >H $ 2 G %!* 2H ! H&',H !$ H H* ($1H *! ?H ,!. $1H '&G !& H, H('!&,>H '+>H4<G5455H=H4<G5<78H H6H +H/ H . H $ H* ( , $1?H &H $! &H/ 'H$'+ +H '* H, H ' * H'&H%-$,!($ H *'-& +H%-+,H '&, +,H $$H' H, %H!&H, H '-*,H' H (( $+>H H '' H * -% &,H'&H'& H *'-& H ' +H&',H% ,, *H! H &', *H!& ( & &,H *'-& H+-(('*,+H, H !+!'&>H ?H > >?H $ "$ ?H<73H >6 H<9;HB:, H !*>H534<C>H H* &,$1H (($! H, ,H(*!& !($ H,'H !+G %!++H &', *H $! &D+H( ,!,!'&H, ,H* $! H'&$ H/ !$ H! &'*!& H H,!% G & G&-% *H (*' $ %>H H $ "$ ?H '>H4<G59;5HB:, H !*>H *>H7?H5353CHB&'&(* &,! $H !+('+!G ,!'&C>H H+ % H'-, '% H!+H ((*'(*! , H * >H H H ' * H!+H * H,'H (,H &H-&,!% $1H'*H&-% *G ** H%',!'&H! H, H $! &H(*'G .! +H H '' H* +'&>H ,H $ 2 G %!* 2H +H&',H '&, & H, ,H, H ' * H -+ H!,+H !+ * ,!'&H!&H '& $- !& H, ,H H$ #+H H '' H* +'&>H .!& H! &'* H, H,!% G & G &-% *H(*' $ %?H $ 2 G %!* 2H +H 1( ++ H &1H'(('*,-&!,1H,'H * - H -+ H' H !+G * ,!'&HB! H, ,H+- " ,H!+H'( &H,'H* .! /H-& *H, H ((*' H' $ # C>H & H!,H !+H ! ! -$,H,'H+ H '/H $ 2 G %!* 2H '-$ H . H H H '' H* +'&H '*H/ !,!& H +H$'& H +H H ! >H +H/ H' + *. H!&H $ $ "$ !# ?H<86H >6 H844HB:, H !*>H 5353C?H, H)- +,!'&H(* + &, H!&$ H H &H#! #!& H *'-& H '*H1 *+?H & H, H '-*,D+H !+!'&H/ +H + H'&H H+, ,-, H & , H!&H4<<9?H$'& H '* H $ 2 G %!* 2D+H * %'. $H(*' !& +H &>H H H( ,!,!'&+H '*H* .! /H * H &! >H

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.