Lyons v. Dart, No. 17-3170 (7th Cir. 2018)

Annotate this Case

In 2013, while Koger was serving a 300-day sentence in the Cook County Jail, Lyons sent him at least 10 books, plus magazines and newspapers. More than 30 books were seized from Koger’s cell for violation of Jail policy. In a suit under 42 U.S.C. 1983, Lyons and Koger claimed that limiting inmates to three pieces of reading material violated the First Amendment. The district court rejected the suit. The Seventh Circuit affirmed with respect to Lyons, who lacked standing because Koger received everything she sent, but vacated as to Koger. The court noted that Koger challenged the policy, rather than the particular seizure, and that the policy provides for no pre-deprivation process.

Download PDF

In the United States Court of Appeals For the Seventh Circuit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

Primary Holding

Seventh Circuit reinstates a First Amendment challenge to a jail policy limiting inmates to three books.

Disclaimer: Justia Annotations is a forum for attorneys to summarize, comment on, and analyze case law published on our site. Justia makes no guarantees or warranties that the annotations are accurate or reflect the current state of law, and no annotation is intended to be, nor should it be construed as, legal advice. Contacting Justia or any attorney through this site, via web form, email, or otherwise, does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.