Ramsey v. Penn Mut. Life Ins.Co., No. 14-3869 (6th Cir. 2015)
Annotate this CaseRamsey applied for $2 million in life insurance from Penn. His application indicated that he was a Cleveland firefighter and had last seen his physician for a checkup in 2006. During a medical examination by a nurse, Ramsey disclosed that he suffered from chronic ulcerative colitis; in 1984 a colorectal surgeon had surgically removed Ramsey’s colon to alleviate his symptoms. After reviewing his medical records, in mid-April, Penn offered him a policy with one of the lowest ratings Penn offers and an above-average premium. On April 28, Ramsey was examined at the Cleveland Clinic. Having had no treatment for 10-12 years, his visit was precipitated by “frequent bloody [bowel movements] and feel[ing] bad.” On June 1, Penn drafted and Ramsey signed amendments, changing the policy value to $500,000. Ramsey stated: I have not had a colon[o]scopy since 2004 and have had no gastrointestinal problems since that time. Ramsey was soon diagnosed with stage IV metastatic rectal cancer and died in September 2011. Penn denied an application for benefits, rescinded the policy, and returned $14,761.45 in premiums. The district court granted Penn summary judgment, finding Ramsey had failed to inform Penn of a change in the status of his health before the delivery of his policy, breaching a representation in the contract. The Sixth Circuit reversed, finding a genuine dispute as to whether Ramsey misrepresented the state of his health by failing to disclose his rectal bleeding and doctor visits.
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.