Migliaro v. Fidelity National Indemnity Insurance Co., No. 17-1434 (3d Cir. 2018)Annotate this Case
Migliaro purchased a Standard Flood Insurance Policy (SFIP) under the National Flood Insurance Program, 42 U.S.C. 4011(a), from Fidelity for his property, which sustained flood damage in October 2012's Hurricane Sandy. Fidelity’s adjuster recommended a payment of $90,499.11, which Fidelity paid. Five months later, Migliaro submitted a proof of loss, claiming an additional $236,702.57. On July 15, 2013, Fidelity sent Migliaro a letter titled “Rejection of Proof of Loss,” stating: This is not a denial of your claim. Your field adjuster provided you with an estimate and Proof of Loss regarding covered damages. If there are additional covered damages identified, please forward documentation and they will be considered. Migliaro did not provide additional documentation or submit a second proof of loss but filed suit. Migliaro's July 2015 complaint was dismissed as untimely. Because SFIP claims are ultimately paid by the government, SFIPs are identical and state: You may not sue ... unless you have complied with all the requirements of the policy. If you do sue, you must start the suit within one year after the date of the written denial of all or part of the claim. The Third Circuit affirmed. Although the rejection of a proof of loss is not per se a denial of the claim, it does constitute a denial if the policyholder treats it as such by filing suit against the carrier.