State of Delaware v. All Approved Auto Sales, LLC, a Delaware limited liability compnay; William Marker, an individual; and Wholesale Motors, Inc.

Annotate this Case

Download PDF

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

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.