Curtis S. Wayne v. Division of Motor Vehicles

Annotate this Case

Download PDF

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

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.