Stephen W. Pringle, et al. v. Fred Barakat, et al.

Annotate this Case

Download PDF

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

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.