Car Homes Inc. v. Joseph Frederick and J&S Home Repair

Annotate this Case

Download PDF

! ! "" # ! $ , ,/ %&&'(&)(&*+ - !. 0 " !. ! 1 # 1 230 .4 . .4 03 5' %&&* 3 6 %&&* , 7! $ , 182 2 %&& 6'5 7 ! 0 !9 ! 5)6&5 ! <" ! "" # ! ! "" " . . " !. ! 1 " 1 > , 1 7 !9 7 : 2 5'&' 0 !9 ! ! <" # 0 1 ! 0 1? 3 !91 7 1 . " 0 @ 3 . 55+ $ !2 5)6&; " !. ! 1 1 ! 182 ! =7 ! " . 2!. 3 7 " 1 ! ! " 9 !9 9 0 !1 " !. ! 1 , 1 7 > . . @? . ! 1 7 7 0 !< ! ! . ! ! A " 0 . 2!. $. . " . ! " !1 1 . " < ! " 2 7 B %* %&&% 7 ! " 7 !1 0 @ !1 ! " ! "! . 1! ! ! 11 < ! 2. . 7 $ @ 7 ! . ! !. 1 @ 2!. ! " 1 . !9 $ !. . 7 7 1 " 0 $ 71 " 3 @ 0 !. % @ . 7 7 . . !9 1 . !9 ! .B B !. 7 3 1 0 ! 1 C% *&& 1 D 2 . ! 3 " 71 9 . < 1 7 1 .1 ! 7 7 " 0 !. 3 9 0 ! $. ." . !. ! " .< 0 ( (3<( 1 ! 1 C+ +)+ 2!. < .9 !9 ! . ! 5' %&&% !. !1 ! !. . 0 9 . " 1 !. !1 7 3 ! " ! 7 " 1 1 1 . 0 9 . ! D 1 !9 1 . !9 7 . 71 " 0 . 2!. . 0 !. !1 1 " . 7 1 @ 112 (3<(" 2 ! 7 1 3 D !1 1 @ ! ! 2. . ! !9 ! 1 ! !1 !. 3 1 0 ! . ! 2. . !1 7 0 $ !9 !. 7 1 ! $ 7 " 1 . 1. 0 " ! 1 @ " 1 . 0 9 1 " . 1 " . 7 7 !. !1 0 " 0 " 7 1 . 0 !1 ! 1 1 0 $ !9 7 3 7 . !. " $ !9 !9 9 ! " 1 ! " . # !1 2 3<(" 2 " =7 0 1 !9 0 ! !. 0 $ !9 ! 7 " 1 7 0 01 . ! < 3 @ !. ,/ " 71 0 $ !9 . 3 !. 0 1 C5 *+& 7 !. 7 . " 71 9 1 !. 3 @ . !. !. 1 ! " 0 !9 7 7 ! 1 " $. . " D 1 . "" 71 ! ! !9 ! 1 3 ! 3 0 2! 7 " C% +&& && 0 2! " D 1 !9 ! "! . 7 " 2 7 7 7 ! 2. . !12 ! !. ! 0 7 7 "! 0 2!. @ $. 1 C5 5A+ " ! . 1 3 7 " 1 %' %&&% ! % " C' &&& && !. 7 1 . 20 ! 1 .0 " " CA'+ 0 2! 1 .2 2!. ! 1 " 71 1 0 2! 1 .2 2!. %6 %&&% ! 7 0 $ 1 CAA+ ! 1 " . 7 0 ! 1 C5 &&& && %* %&&% @ ! 7 11 < !. !1 71 " 71 ! " 7 1 !1 ! 7 7 7 7 1 !1 . ! $. . " @ ! 7 3 1 0 ! 1 ! 7 0 ! ! !. C5 *&& && " C+ ++& && $ 03 . 1 ! . 5 %&&% ! 7 ! ""E1 D7 3 ) 7 1 "2 7 . " !. ! 17 7 1 < 3 0 2! $ 03 7 @ . 7 <0 ! 1 !. $ .2 1 1 " 0 %% %&&% ! 7 A%* . 14 5 1B % " C5 *&& && . 1 " . 7 " ! 17 7 17 7 @ 03 . 1B ' " C5 ;6& && C6A& && ' 7 0 2! $ 03 < 3 0 0 2! 1 . @ " . " !. ! <0 ! ! 7 0 ' %&&% ! ! 0 A&; . < 3 0 2! ! .. " C5 ;6& && 5+ %&&% ! 7 7 @ A5' . 0 1 ! 7 . 1B !. * 0 2! " 7 0 !< F 3 0 7 1 7 7 " 7 1 ! "! !1 !9 1 !1 . 71 7 7 7 < " 7 1 1 . . . 7 1 . !9 . 3< . " !. ! ! 7 @ 7 ! 1 !. !9 7 . 3 1 ! . "! . ! 0 ! .F ! !9 82 @ . 0 !. 1! !. 7 . " !. ! . . ! !. " 7 2 7 % 7 !1 ! " 7 ! % 1 ! .1 !3 . 32 7 82 ! < " 7 F 3 2! $ ! 1 1 1 7 !. ! F !1 7 !. ! !9 0 ! ! 9 1 !9 7 . 7 !. 7 7 0 . !9 3 1 0 ! !. 7 1 < " 0 . 7 7 7 ! 7 0 $ 1 !1 7 . ! 1 @ !9 !. 7 7 .2 1 . 1 2.1 7 1 "2 7 < . 2!. . !. 7 . < . 3 1 0 ! 7 7 .< 7 % 82 1 " !. 2!. $1 1 7 . 7 ! " 7 !9 1 . 1 " . 7 !1 !. !1 2 7 1 . " 7 .< . 7 . ! 2!. 7 (3<(" 2 1 1 12 . ! .. 7 7 12 ! 11 1! 2.3 1 . < !1 2 7 1 .! !1 ! !9 7 " 7 3 01 9 1 . " !. ! 0 !. !. 7 7 . 7 $ !< 1 0 1 !. ! ""E1 1 " 7 7 21 < !1 ! 7 ! 7 !9 ! 7 " ! 1 " . 1 !1 1 2 2 1 3 !1 . * . ! ! !. 7 9 2 . !. ! $ ! . 7 ! < 7 . 2!. ! 7 < !1 !. .9 1 82 9 1 3 1 ! 1 1 !. 7 @ ! 7 ! . " 0 3 !9 . 1! !1 7 ! . . 1 ! . ! "" ! .2 . 1 $ 7 9 71 7 7 17 . 7 @ ! 7 7 21 7 7 1 9 . !9 7 1 ! " 7 "2 7 @ 3 01 0 @ 7 !1 11 < < " 7 . 7 7 21 1 ! < # 1 . ! @ 9 . !9 7 1 $ " 7 @ 7 ! (2 . 7 ( !1 1 ! . 2 7 2. ! 7 .1 $ ! $ 03 9 11 3 01 !. 7 1 ! < !. 7 7 7 . " !. ! !. 7 0 7 2!. 1 ! 7 @0 !17 . 1 .. 11 . 6 %&&% . . 7 )4'& 7 2 12 0 11 ! ! !92 9 " . #2 7 2.3 11( D 0 ! ! !. ! . , 1 7 . D0 . 7 " !1 @ < 5& < 1 ! "" 7 1 7 1 1 " . !. . 7 .< 1 . 71 D @ 3 . ! 3 " . 1 7 297 7 !1 . 3< 3 7 7 !. ! 7 7 7 # 2! < 7 . 1 2 1 7 7 7 < " ! 21 7 7 0 . !9 321 ! 11 " 0 !9 ! !. 7 32 7 ! 7 " 1 . 7 " 1 !. 1 !. !1 1 ! 32 . !9 + @ . 1 0 !< " . " !. ! 1 " .7 ! 9 7 " 1 3 1 7 @ . 7 7 1 3 ! ! 7 7 0 C% 0 ! . . 7 "< 7 1 ! . 1 7 1 7 7 7 77 1 2! < !. !12 . " 1 ! %. 1! 7 ! 7 . " !. ! !< ! " 1 2 1 @ 82 7 . " !. ! 0 . !$ 1 7 7 7 7 . " !. ! !. 7 ! $ !1 1 " . 7 . 7 0 " 0 1 . " !. $ 1 "2 7 1 " .7 !1 !1 1 ! 1 1 ! 7 1 7 7 ! "" 7 ! . ! 7 3 D 1 . " 21 2.3 $ !. 1" " $ 7 1 @ 1 7 7 9 7 7 1 21 7 (3<(" 2 1 7 ! . 1 21 . 3< 7 !. 1 7 7 21 . 7 (3<( . ! 7 7 21 1 " . 7 2.! 1 ! !9 # ! 7 9 1 7 1 1 . !. 7 ! 1 . !9 1 !1 .2 7 3 1 0 ! 7 7 !9 1 : " 1: 7 7 . 7 0 . !9 3 0 2 7 1 . 7 7 1 1 . 2!. 7 7 21 32 . 7 !. ! ! 7 . !. . 7 " 7 0 2! 21. ! ! . 1 7 1 . !91 % 0 2! 1 " 7 2 7 1 !9 7 1 . !9 7 0 . @ 0 . 7 !7 .1 7 ! !1 $ 7 . 9 . 20 ! !. ! 1 " .7 ..! ! "" . ! 7 7 21 . 1 " . 7 0 . !. !1 ! . 7 .. ! 0 . 7 82 1 . !$ $ 1 !1 !. 1 !. !9 " F ! 1 $ 03 .. 7 1 . !9 3 2 . 7 " 1 .3 ! 2. . ! 7 0 ! . !1 7 3 .< . 1 ! < 7 7 7 . 0 $ . 7 $. . ! 7 " !1 7 7 1 1 " . 7 D7 3 ! 7 @ 7 ! !. 71 1" ; " .1 ! " .< ! 21 @ 7 @ !9 !. 1 !. !9 ; %&&% = ! 2. . 1 " . 7 2. . 7 ! @ 1 . "2 7 1 0 ! " . ! !1 1 C+ +)+ !. . 1 ! !17 !3 ! C5 ;&& && 17 . 5 82 3 1 1 " !. ! 71 @ 1 " . 7 .. 7 @ 2!. 7 ! 7 7 ! 2. . !9 !. 1 !. !9 " 7 F !1 . !. 1 3 1 " . 7 " 2 ! 7 0 @ 12 !. 7 !. ! 1! 1 !9 3 !9 " !. ! ! . 7 ! !9 7 7 " . " !. ! 3 1: 0 !9 .. " 7 !. 7 ! !9 !. 7 0 7B 7 " < 182 . 7 " 7 ! ""E1 ! 7 9 1 " 7 7 !9 $ 03 !. 9 71 10 7 ! 7 (3<(" 2 1 1 ! ; %&&% 7 77 11( D 0 ! " 0 ! "" ! 0 " @ !. . 7 01 ! 7 1 @ ! < 1 32 . ! " ! 1 82 " 0 . 1 # 7 1 7 ! % C; A'& 7 $ . $ . !. ! . ! 0 ! < C+ +&& . !91 . ! 3< . " !. ! " 7 92 1 7 82 1 " .7 ..! !. ! ! "" 32 7 ; %&&% $ 03 1 7 . 32 7 < $ . 7 1 !. ! 1 12 . ! 7 9 1 < !1 ..! . ! "" 2 7 1 . 7 0 7 . " !1 1 " .7 < 7 ! "" " ! 0 1 . . ! 1 7 7 . 1 " . 1 ! 12 !. 2 7 $ !. 1 < 7 0 2 7 1 . 3< 12 . ! D ! "" 7 D 2. . ! "" 1 ! 7 @ 7 1 . !9 . 2!. A 7 77 " C+ +6A A& " ! . 92 1 ! "" < . ! 2!. 1! 7 " 0 . $ 2!. 7 !. 7 ! @ !. 7 ! . 2!. 7 $ 2 " 7 1 01 82 . 3< . " !. ! 1 7 120 1 " !. ! 01 ! 7 71 9 0 ! 1 7 A 1 0 !< !. 7 . 20 ! 1 1230 . 7 . ! 1 ! " 0 7 3 !. !9 ! !1 2 ! !. !1 . !. ! . < 2 7< $ 1 7 7 7 $. ." 1 ! "" 0 !12 ! ! 0 !< 2 7 @ 5))A ! +%65;& =5))A 7 . " !. ! ! 5 7 .1 2 ! 7 ! !1 1 1 7 ! !1 7 ! "2 ! " !. 7 " 7 7 . F 1 2!. 0 2! 2!. " !. 3 ! 7 21 7 ! 1 1 1! " ! 7 0 @ !1 !1 1 " C*A+ && ! 7 1" 1 ! 3 ! "" 1 " . $ 0 . 7 " 7 9 < 7 ! 71 7 2 7 1 . 3< !. . . 3 01 7 < 7 ! 12 ! " 7 1 0 7 F 1 2!. " 71 . 2!. !1 1 !. ! 82 7 1 1! 5 " C% *&& && 32 . . ! "2!. " 7 1 ." 7 . 1 21 . " !. ! . . ! . 7 7 112 . " !. ! 1E D 7 7 " 1 1 " . 3< ! ! ! "" 7 7 32 ! 3< . 20 ! 1 !. 1 " . 7 1 @ ! "" 1 " 2 " 7 01 1 . 1! ! "" . 7 120 " C+ +&& && 01 " 0 . . 7 120 " C5%+ && !. 1 . !9 !. 7 < ! 7 3 !1 0 ! ! ! . . " !. ! . 1! . 1 % 82 " ! 17 F 3 ! !1 92 1 7 . !. 7 . < " 2 !. 12 7 @ 7 2 !9 !. 1 !. !9 7 6 $ " " ! 17 7 1 ! !9 !. 1 !. !9 1 " 7 .< ! 7 1 021 7 $ 3 ! 71 ! 0 . 3< 7 ! 1 $ 1! 7 ! "" !. 2!" ! 17 . @ !. " 2 0 7 ! "" $ .1 0 ." 7 1 . !9 ! . 7 @ 2!. " . 7 " 7 0 2! " 0 2! " C5 ;+6 && . !9 < F2.90 ! C% 5'' && 1 !. 1 (F2.90 ! ! 1 ! 1 . " 7 ! "" ! 7 9 7 1 67 . < " 3 %&&* GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG D, 0 1 7 " ,2.9 0 1( &* )

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.