Frank Garneski, Executor of Alice Garneski, Executrix of Frank D. Gyles vs. Terry and Rose Hack

Annotate this Case

Download PDF

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

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.