James R. Williams v. Lori A. Nagyiski

Annotate this Case

Download PDF

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

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.