Manhattan Telecommunications Corp., d/b/a Metropolitan Telecommunications, a/k/a MetTel v. Granite Telecommunications, LLC

Annotate this Case

Download PDF

ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ 01234ÿ16ÿ07890 3 ÿÿ 16ÿ47 ÿÿ 484 ÿ16ÿ 8 83 ÿ !"#ÿ ÿ $%$&ÿ $'&&$ÿ ()*&'+ÿ(&,%-%'&ÿ"../"ÿ &,&01)2&3ÿÿ45/67ÿ#5.8!5.#ÿ 9%:;<=<,&3ÿÿ45/67ÿ#5.8>"#.ÿ ÿ (%$&ÿ ?@=<$$&A3ÿÿ :$)@&'ÿ".+ÿ6/6/ÿ (%$&ÿ(&:<A&A3ÿÿ)*&=@&'ÿ".+ÿ6/6/ÿ )''&:$&A3ÿÿ)*&=@&'ÿ6/+ÿ6/6/ÿ ÿ $&*&2ÿ ÿ %0)2<+ÿ ;B?<'&ÿ ÿ ?A;)2ÿ :%GG;+ÿ ' +ÿ ;B?<'&ÿ C%$$1&-ÿD ÿ )&,,&'+ÿ ;B?<'&ÿ C)''<;+ÿ<:1),;+ÿ ';1$ÿFÿ ?22&,,ÿ ÿ EF ÿ %$&;ÿ ÿ "6/"ÿ)'$1ÿC%'J&$ÿ $'&&$ÿ >//ÿE<2Gÿ $'&&$+ÿ ?<$&ÿ./"ÿ H<,=<2G$)2+ÿ( ÿÿ".I/"ÿ H<,=<2G$)2+ÿ( ÿÿ".I/"ÿ ÿ (%*<Aÿ ÿ );;+ÿ ;B?<'&ÿ ÿ %''&$$ÿ <:&+ÿ ;B?<'&ÿ );;ÿ ')2;$%=ÿFÿC)'<$Kÿ ÿ "//ÿ ÿH&;$ÿ $'&&$+ÿ ?<$&ÿ!//ÿ H<,=<2G$)2+ÿ( ÿÿ".I/"ÿÿ ÿ &3ÿLMNOMPPMNÿRSTSUVWWXNYUMPYVNZÿ[V\]^_ÿ`abaMÿ LSP\V]VTYPMNÿRSTSUVWWXNYUMPYVNZ_ÿMacaMÿLSPRSTÿd^ÿ e\MNYPSÿRSTSUVWWXNYUMPYVNZ_ÿff[ÿ ÿ) ÿ6/6/8/!>I8 ÿ (&%'ÿ )?2;&,3ÿ 1&ÿ0,%<2$<ggÿ<2ÿ$1<;ÿ$'%A&ÿ,<@&,ÿ:%;&+ÿC%21%$$%2ÿ &,&:)==?2<:%$<)2;ÿ )'0 ÿ 4hC&$ &,i7+ÿ1%;ÿ@')?G1$ÿ%ÿC)$<)2ÿg)'ÿ )2$<2?&Aÿ )2g<A&2$<%,ÿ '&%$=&2$ÿ<2ÿ-1<:1ÿ<$ÿ ;&&J;ÿ%ÿ:)?'$ÿ)'A&'ÿ;&%,<2Gÿ%,,ÿ'&g&'&2:&;ÿ<2ÿ$1&ÿ0,&%A<2G;ÿ$)ÿ$1&ÿ%,,&G&A,jÿA&g%=%$)'jÿ ;$%$&=&2$; ÿÿ9)'ÿ$1&ÿ'&%;)2;ÿ&k0,%<2&Aÿ@&,)-+ÿC&$ &,l;ÿ=)$<)2ÿ=?;$ÿ@&ÿA&2<&Aÿ%2Aÿ $1&ÿ'&A%:$&Aÿ0)'$<)2;ÿ)gÿ$1&ÿ0,&%A<2G;ÿ=?;$ÿ@&ÿ=%A&ÿ0?@,<: ÿ 012314412ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿÿ 12 47ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !" #$%ÿ &'()'*ÿ+,-ÿ ÿ ./0'ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ 12ÿ4567859ÿ;56<=>?8@Aÿ B'CD'Eÿ/FGÿH*/FIC'ÿD'E'J ((KFIJ/CI FL-ÿMM ÿNOH*/FIC'PQÿR* &IG'ÿ/ÿ&/*I'CSÿ TÿJ ((KFIJ/CI FLÿL EKCI FLÿC ÿU'E/V/*'ÿ'FCICI'L +ÿÿW CXÿJ (R/FI'Lÿ/RR/*'FCESÿ R* &IG'ÿL'*&IJ'LÿC ÿ/Fÿ &'*E/RRIF0ÿJKLC ('*ÿ)/L'-ÿIFJEKGIF0ÿCX L'ÿKFIYK'ESÿ/TT'JC'Gÿ )SÿCX'ÿ Z[\U +,ÿR/FG'(IJ-ÿLKJXÿ/LÿX'/ECXJ/*'ÿR* &IG'*L ÿÿ\FÿICLÿ (RE/IFC-ÿ B'CD'Eÿ/EE'0'LÿCX/CÿLX *CESÿ/TC'*ÿCX'ÿR/FG'(IJÿL'CÿIF-ÿH*/FIC'ÿ)'0/FÿJ FC/JCIF0ÿL ('ÿ TÿCX'L'ÿ &'*E/RRIF0ÿJKLC ('*LÿC ÿL VÿG K)CLÿ/) KCÿB'CD'E]LÿTIF/FJI/EÿJ FGICI Fÿ /FGÿ/)IEICSÿC ÿV'/CX'*ÿCX'ÿR/FG'(IJ *'E/C'Gÿ'J F (IJÿKFJ'*C/IFCS ^ÿÿÿ DX'L'ÿJ FC/JCLÿTI*LCÿJ/('ÿC ÿEI0XCÿ/TC'*ÿB'CD'EÿV/Lÿ/RR* /JX'Gÿ)SÿJ FTKL'Gÿ JKLC ('*LÿVX ÿ*'J KFC'GÿH*/FIC']LÿLC/C'('FCL ÿÿ LÿCI('ÿR/LL'G-ÿB'CD'EÿJ/('ÿC ÿ E'/*FÿCX/CÿH*/FIC']Lÿ/EE'0'GESÿT/EL'ÿ/FGÿG'T/(/C *SÿLC/C'('FCLÿV'*'ÿF CÿIL E/C'G-ÿ)KCÿ ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ +ÿ ['*ITI'Gÿ (RE ÿ_FG'*ÿ%'/EÿNO (RE PQÿNU \ ÿ+Qÿ``ÿ!ab-ÿ+ a++ ÿ ÿ (RE ÿ``ÿ-ÿ ÿ ^ÿ (RE ÿ``ÿ+!a+b ÿ ÿ (RE ÿ`ÿ+, ÿ 012314412ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿÿ 12 47ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !" #$%ÿ &'()'*ÿ+,-ÿ ÿ ./0'ÿ1ÿ ÿ ÿ 234'56*'/4-ÿ/74ÿ2'*'ÿ8 (370ÿ9* (ÿ/::ÿ:'&':5ÿ23;<37ÿ=*/73;'>5ÿ *0/73?/;3 7 @ÿÿ 5ÿ/ÿ *'5A:;ÿ 9ÿ;<'5'ÿ8 7;/8;5-ÿB';C':ÿ/::'0'5ÿ5A)5;/7;3/:ÿ</*(ÿ; ÿ3;5ÿ*'6A;/;3 7ÿ/74ÿ/ÿ 4'8:37'ÿ37ÿ) ;<ÿ8A**'7;ÿ/74ÿ9A;A*'ÿ)A537'55 !ÿÿÿ DDEÿÿHIJKLMNIOPÿQDRSJITÿ B';C':ÿ *3037/::Uÿ)* A0<;ÿ5A3;ÿ/0/375;ÿ=*/73;'ÿ 7ÿB/Uÿ+,-ÿ VÿÿW7ÿ#A7'ÿ,-ÿ -ÿ=*/73;'ÿ*'( &'4ÿ;<'ÿ/8;3 7ÿ; ÿ;<'ÿX73;'4ÿ%;/;'5ÿY35;*38;ÿ A*;ÿ9 *ÿ;<'ÿY35;*38;ÿ 9ÿY':/2/*' ÿÿB';C':ÿ;<'7ÿ& :A7;/*3:Uÿ435(355'4ÿ;</;ÿ/8;3 7 "ÿÿB';C':ÿ373;3/;'4ÿ;<35ÿ /8;3 7ÿ 7ÿ#A7'ÿ+@-ÿ ,ÿÿC<'ÿ 6'*/;3&'ÿ (6:/37;ÿ/55'*;5ÿ8:/3(5ÿ9 *ÿ4'9/(/;3 7-ÿ ; *;3 A5ÿ37;'*9'*'78'ÿ23;<ÿ6* 56'8;3&'ÿ'8 7 (38ÿ/4&/7;/0'-ÿ; *;3 A5ÿ37;'*9'*'78'ÿ ÿ@ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ ÿ (6: ÿZZÿ+,[ -ÿ , ÿ !ÿ (6: ÿZÿ1! ÿ Vÿ \'*393'4ÿ (6: -ÿ012314412ÿ67879 ÿ ÿ ÿ 12 47ÿ67879 ÿ -ÿ ÿ ÿ 1" #$%ÿ]Y ^ ÿ+_ ÿ "ÿ ; 38'ÿ 9ÿ`3:370ÿ 9ÿ ;38'ÿ 9ÿ$'( &/:-ÿ012314412ÿ67879 ÿ ÿ ÿ 12 47ÿ 67879 ÿ -ÿ ÿ ÿ 1" #$%ÿ]Y ^ ÿ+_aÿB ; ÿ9 *ÿ 7;37A'4ÿ 7934'7;3/:ÿ C*'/;('7;ÿ]bB ; c_ÿ]Y ^ ÿ+_ÿZÿ1 ÿ ,ÿ ]Y ^ ÿ+_ ÿ 012314412ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿÿ 12 47ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !" #$%ÿ &'()'*ÿ+,-ÿ ÿ ./0'ÿÿ ÿ ÿ 1234ÿ5 63*/537/8ÿ*'8/32 69-ÿ3*/:'ÿ82)'8ÿ/6:ÿ:'5';32&'ÿ3*/:'ÿ;*/5325'9 + ÿÿ 9ÿ</537/8ÿ ;*':25/3'9ÿ< *ÿ34'9'ÿ58/2(9-ÿ34'ÿ (;8/263ÿ8/=9ÿ 73ÿ) 34ÿ0'6'*/8ÿ:'95*2;32 69ÿ/6:ÿ 9;'52<25ÿ'>/(;8'9ÿ <ÿ93/3'('639ÿ(/:'ÿ)=ÿ?*/623'ÿ'(;8 =''9ÿ34/3ÿ@'3A'8ÿ58/2(9ÿ/*'ÿ :'</(/3 *=-ÿ/9ÿ1'88ÿ/9ÿ34'ÿ*'/9 69ÿ@'3A'8ÿ)'82'&'9ÿ34'ÿ93/3'('639ÿ1288ÿ *ÿ4/&'ÿ 5/79':ÿ4/*( ++ÿÿA4'ÿ (;8/263ÿ1/9ÿ<28':ÿ76:'*ÿ9'/8ÿ/9ÿ;'*(233':ÿ)=ÿ 7*3ÿ <ÿ 4/65'*=ÿ$78'ÿB + ÿ C4'6ÿ@'3A'8ÿ<28':ÿ34'ÿ;7)825ÿ&'*92 6ÿ <ÿ34'ÿ (;8/263-ÿ34'ÿ5 63'63ÿ*'8/3':ÿ3 ÿ 34'ÿ/88'0':ÿ:'</(/3 *=ÿ93/3'('639ÿ1/9ÿ*':/53': + ÿÿ@'3A'8ÿ<28':ÿ239ÿ26232/8ÿ@ 32 6ÿ< *ÿ 6<2:'632/8ÿA*'/3('63ÿ 6ÿ#76'ÿ D-ÿ +DÿÿA429ÿ( 32 6ÿ9 7043ÿ/6ÿ *:'*ÿ/88 1260ÿ @'3A'8ÿ3 ÿ<28'ÿ239ÿ@ 32 6ÿ3 ÿE>;':23'ÿ5 6<2:'632/88=ÿ76:'*ÿ 7*3ÿ <ÿ 4/65'*=ÿ $78'ÿB + +ÿÿA429ÿ76 ;; 9':ÿ( 32 6ÿ1/9ÿ0*/63':ÿ 6ÿ#76'ÿ -ÿ +Bÿÿ@'3A'8F9ÿ ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ + ÿ (;8 ÿGGÿD"HI+ ÿ ++ÿ (;8 ÿGGÿ+IHDI ÿ + ÿ J'*2<2':ÿ (;8 ÿ$':/53':ÿ.7)825ÿJ'*92 6ÿKL M ÿ N ÿ +Dÿ .8 F9ÿ@ 3 ÿ< *ÿ 6<2:'632/8ÿA*'/3('63ÿKL M ÿN ÿ +ÿ OP ÿGÿI ÿ +Bÿ Q*:'*ÿ?*/63260ÿ@ 3 ÿ< *ÿ 6<2:'632/8ÿA*'/3('63ÿKL M ÿBN ÿ 012314412ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿÿ 12 47ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !" #$%ÿ &'()'*ÿ+,-ÿ ÿ ./0'ÿ1ÿ ÿ ÿ 2 34 5ÿ3 ÿ678'943'ÿ:/;ÿ<4='9ÿ 5ÿ#>5'ÿ 1-+!ÿ:43?ÿ3?'ÿ*'9/@3'9ÿ8>)=4@ÿ&'*;4 5ÿ)'450ÿ <4='9ÿ 5ÿ#>=Aÿ -ÿ +Bÿ .*4 *ÿ3 ÿ3?'ÿ<4=450ÿ <ÿ3?'ÿ8>)=4@ÿ&'*;4 5ÿ <ÿ3?'ÿ2 34 5ÿ3 ÿ678'943'-ÿ 5ÿ#>5'ÿ ,-ÿ -ÿC53'*';3'9ÿ./*3Aÿ.* <';; *ÿ6>0'5'ÿD = E?ÿ;>)(433'9ÿ5 34@'ÿ>59'*ÿ$>='ÿ1 +F<Gÿ @?/=='50450ÿ3?'ÿ@ 5<49'534/=ÿ3*'/3('53ÿ <ÿ3?'ÿ (8=/453-ÿ43;ÿ'7?4)43;ÿ/59ÿ3?'ÿ2 34 5ÿ 3 ÿ678'943' +"ÿÿC5ÿ*';8 5;'-ÿ2'3H'=ÿ<4='9ÿ3?'ÿ8*';'53ÿ2 34 5ÿ< *ÿ 5345>'9ÿ 5<49'534/=ÿH*'/3('53ÿ 5ÿ#>=Aÿ+ -ÿ ÿF3?'ÿI2 34 5JG +,ÿÿC5ÿ?4;ÿ 88 ;434 5ÿ3 ÿ3?'ÿ 2 34 5-ÿ.* <';; *ÿD = E?ÿ;3/3';ÿ3?/3ÿ?'ÿ:4;?';ÿ3 ÿ>;'ÿ3?'ÿ@>**'53=Aÿ*'9/@3'9ÿ 45< *(/34 5-ÿ 247 ÿ18 1-ÿ3 ÿI8>)=4@=Aÿ94;@>;;-ÿ 5ÿ?4;ÿ$'/; 5ÿ2/0/K45' ? ;3'9ÿ)= 0ÿ /59ÿ8 3'534/==Aÿ45ÿ/ÿ=/:ÿ*'&4':ÿ/*34@='-ÿ? :ÿ=4)'=ÿ=4340/53;ÿ/*'ÿ3*A450ÿ3 ÿ>;'ÿ3?'ÿ='0/=ÿ ;A;3'(ÿ3 ÿ*';3*4@3ÿ;8''@? J ÿ ÿ+ÿ!ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ ÿ.= L;ÿ2 3 ÿ3 ÿ678'943'ÿM59'*ÿ%'/=ÿFN C ÿ!G ÿ +Bÿ .= L;ÿ2 3 ÿ3 ÿ678'943'ÿFN C ÿ++G ÿ +"ÿ 34@'ÿ <ÿ ?/=='50'ÿ3 ÿ 5<49'534/=ÿH*'/3('53ÿFN C ÿ+ G ÿ +,ÿ FN C ÿ+G ÿ ÿ O88L5ÿ3 ÿ2 3 ÿ< *ÿ 5345>'9ÿ 5<49'534/=ÿH*'/3('53ÿFIO88L5JGÿFN C ÿ+!GÿPÿ+1 ÿ 012314412ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿÿ 12 47ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !" #$%ÿ &'()'*ÿ+,-ÿ ÿ ./0'ÿ!ÿ ÿ ÿ 1'23'4ÿ(/5'6ÿ27*''ÿ8*9(/*:ÿ/*0;('<26ÿ= *ÿ> <29<;'?ÿ> <=9?'<29/4ÿ2*'/2('<2 ÿÿ @ 4-ÿ92ÿ/*0;'6ÿ27/2ÿ27'ÿ8*'6;(829 <ÿ =ÿ8;)49>ÿ/>>'66ÿ96ÿ &'*> ('ÿ)'>/;6'ÿ8;)49>ÿ />>'66ÿ2 ÿ27'ÿ/44'0'?4:ÿ?'=/(/2 *:ÿ62/2'('<26ÿA ;4?ÿ>/;6'ÿ9**'8/*/)4'ÿ7/*(-ÿ/6ÿ *'> 0<9B'?ÿ):ÿ2796ÿ> ;*2ÿ9<ÿ 1 C419DÿE1 3 887ÿFÿ ÿ ÿ0G ÿH724 7ÿI1 427 ÿ JK 1 C419DLM +ÿÿC79 2N-ÿ92ÿ/*0;'6ÿ27/2ÿ.* ='66 *ÿO 4 57P6ÿ9<2'*'62ÿ9<ÿ2796ÿ 9<= *(/29 <ÿ96ÿ< 2ÿK> (8'449<0ÿ'< ;07Lÿ2 ÿ ;2A'907ÿ27'ÿ8 2'<29/4ÿ7/*( ÿÿ63 N-ÿ92ÿ /*0;'6ÿ27/2ÿ27'ÿ8*'&9 ;6ÿ=9<?9<06ÿ =ÿ0 ?ÿ>/;6'ÿ= *ÿ> <=9?'<29/492:ÿ9<ÿ2796ÿ>/6'ÿ?9>2/2'ÿ 27'ÿ6/('ÿ=9<?9<0ÿ7'*' Qÿÿÿ .* ='66 *ÿO 4 57ÿ> ;<2'*6ÿ27/2ÿ1'23'4ÿ7/6ÿ=/94'?ÿ2 ÿ*');2ÿ27'ÿ8*'6;(829 <ÿ =ÿ 8;)49>ÿ/>>'66ÿ= *ÿ/ÿ(;4292;?'ÿ =ÿ*'/6 <6 ÿÿR'ÿ8*9<>98/44:ÿ/*0;'6ÿ27/2ÿ7'ÿ8 66'66'6ÿ/ÿ 4'0929(/2'ÿ9<2'*'62ÿ9<ÿ27'ÿ*'?/>2'?ÿ9<= *(/29 <-ÿA794'ÿ1'23'4ÿ4/>56ÿ/<:ÿS;629=9/)4'ÿ ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ +ÿ1 2 ÿÿTTÿ++U+VÿJ>929<0ÿ 1 C419DÿE1 3 887ÿFÿ ÿ ÿ0G ÿH724 7ÿI1 427 -ÿ +"ÿ WXÿQ,, VÿJY'4 ÿ 7 ÿ ;0 ÿ+!-ÿ +"MM ÿ ÿ1 2 ÿTTÿ+"U QZÿ$'84:ÿ9<ÿ%;88 ÿ =ÿ.4 P6ÿ1 2 ÿ= *ÿ <29<;'?ÿ <=9?'<29/4ÿ3*'/2('<2ÿ JK$[LMÿJY \ ÿ +MÿTTÿ"U+ ÿ Qÿ 1 2 ÿTTÿ U ]Zÿ$[ÿTTÿ+]U+! ÿ 012314412ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿÿ 12 47ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !" #$%ÿ &'()'*ÿ+,-ÿ ÿ ./0'ÿ1ÿ ÿ ÿ 234'*'54ÿ23ÿ6 3728'342/924: ÿÿ;'ÿ7<*4='*ÿ/*0<'5ÿ>'4?'9@5ÿ729230ÿ 7ÿ/3ÿ<3*'8/64'8ÿ > 42 3ÿ4 ÿ$'(/38ÿ23ÿA'8'*/9ÿ <*4ÿ<38'*(23'5ÿ245ÿ/*0<('345ÿ23ÿ4=25ÿ 642 3- Bÿ/38ÿ 4='ÿC<)926ÿ234'*'54ÿ='*'ÿ25ÿ='20=4'3'8ÿ)'6/<5'ÿ>'4?'9ÿ5= <98ÿ)'ÿ8''('8ÿ4 ÿ)'ÿ/ÿ C<)926ÿC'*5 3 !ÿÿÿ Dÿ/(ÿC'*5</8'8ÿ4=/4ÿ4='ÿC<)926ÿ234'*'54ÿ23ÿ4='ÿ*'8/64'8ÿ237 *(/42 3ÿ/4ÿ255<'ÿ <4E'20=5ÿ4='ÿC 4'342/9ÿ7 *ÿ=/*(ÿ4 ÿ>'4?'9ÿ79 E230ÿ7* (ÿ82569 5<*' ÿÿ?='ÿ> 42 3-ÿ 4='*'7 *'-ÿ25ÿ8'32'8 ÿÿÿÿ FFFGÿIJIKLMFMÿ <*4ÿ 7ÿ =/36'*:ÿ$<9'ÿB +ÿ0 &'*35ÿ4=25ÿ> 42 3ÿ7 *ÿ 3423<'8ÿ 3728'342/9ÿ ?*'/4('34 ÿÿ?=/4ÿ*<9'-ÿ23ÿ'55'36'-ÿ6 8272'5ÿ4='ÿOC E'*7<9ÿC*'5<(C42 3ÿ 7ÿC<)926ÿ ÿ ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ ÿPCC@3ÿQQÿ+BR+1-ÿ+"R ÿ BÿPCC@ 3ÿQQÿ SR ÿÿ 66 *8230ÿ4 ÿ>'4?'9-ÿ4=25ÿ82569 5<*'ÿE/5ÿ23/8&'*4'34ÿ/38ÿOT4U='ÿ V254*264ÿ <*4ÿ=/5ÿ5236'ÿC9/6'8ÿ4='ÿPC'3230ÿW*2'7ÿ23ÿ%<CC *4ÿ 7ÿ> 42 3ÿ4 ÿ$'(/38ÿ<38'*ÿ 5'/9 Xÿÿ$WÿQÿ+ ÿ !ÿ PCC@3ÿQÿ B ÿÿY2&'3ÿ/ÿ5<77262'34ÿ5= E230ÿ4=/4ÿ4='ÿC<)926@5ÿ234'*'54ÿ23ÿ<38'*54/38230ÿ4='ÿ C* 6''82305ÿ <4E'20=5ÿ>'4?'9@5ÿ234'*'54ÿ23ÿ6 3728'342/924:-ÿDÿ3''8ÿ3 4ÿ8'628'ÿE='4='*ÿ >'4?'9ÿ25ÿ/ÿOC<)926ÿC'*5 3 Xÿÿÿ 012314412ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿÿ 12 47ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !" #$%ÿ &'()'*ÿ+,-ÿ ÿ ./0'ÿ"ÿ ÿ ÿ /11'223ÿ4 ÿ1 5*4ÿ6* 1''78902ÿ/97ÿ*'1 *72 :ÿÿ;<'ÿ*5='ÿ/=2 ÿ*'1 098>'2-ÿ< ?'&'*-ÿ4</4ÿ 4<'ÿ6*'25(648 9ÿ @ÿ65)=81ÿ/11'22ÿ82ÿ9 4ÿ/)2 =54'-ÿ/97ÿ4</4-ÿ89ÿ1'*4/89ÿ18*15(24/91'2-ÿ =8480/942ÿ/*'ÿ'9484='7ÿ4 ÿ1 9@87'948/=84A ÿÿ;<'ÿ4 51<24 9'ÿ@ *ÿ4<'ÿ'B1'648 9ÿ4 ÿ/11'22ÿ82ÿ C0 7ÿ1/52' 3 "ÿÿD 7ÿ1/52'ÿ'B8242ÿ8@ÿ4<'ÿ6/*4Aÿ2''E890ÿ1 9@87'948/=ÿ4*'/4('94ÿ1/9ÿ 7'( 924*/4'ÿ4</4ÿC4<'ÿ65)=81ÿ894'*'24ÿ89ÿ/11'22ÿ4 ÿ 5*4ÿ6* 1''78902ÿ82ÿ 54?'80<'7ÿ )Aÿ4<'ÿ</*(ÿ4</4ÿ65)=81ÿ7821= 25*'ÿ @ÿ2'92848&'-ÿ9 9 65)=81ÿ89@ *(/48 9ÿ? 5=7ÿ 1/52' 3 ,ÿÿÿ FAÿ7'2809-ÿ4<'ÿ)5*7'9ÿ @ÿ7'( 924*/4890ÿ0 7ÿ1/52'ÿ82ÿ'B/14890-ÿ*'1 098>890ÿ 4</4ÿCG4H< 2'ÿ?< ÿ7'187'ÿ4 ÿ=8480/4'ÿ89ÿ/ÿ65)=81ÿ@ *5(ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ(524ÿ7 ÿ2 ÿ89ÿ/ÿ(/99'*ÿ 1 92824'94ÿ?84<ÿ4<'ÿ*80<4ÿ @ÿ4<'ÿ65)=81ÿ4 ÿ@ == ?ÿ/97ÿ( 984 *ÿ4<'ÿ6* 1''78902ÿ/97ÿ4<'ÿ *'25=4ÿ @ÿG4<'Hÿ782654' 3I ÿÿJ9ÿ4<82ÿ*'0/*7-ÿ 5*ÿ1 5*42ÿ/66*'18/4'ÿ4</4ÿ65)=81ÿ/11'22ÿ4 ÿ ÿ ÿ:ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ ÿK 7 ÿ ÿ 3 9LMN 8MO ÿP29 -ÿ +IÿQRÿ+ I! S-ÿ/4ÿT ÿUV'= ÿ < ÿW/* ÿ :-ÿ +IX ÿ "ÿ 4 ÿ < ÿ$ ÿS + ÿ ,ÿ PY ÿÿ I ÿO8 ÿZ1[77 1ÿO 7 91 ÿ ÿ ÿO6\6ÿ]7 ÿP29 -ÿ +IÿQRÿS!+ "-ÿ/4ÿT:ÿUV'= ÿ < ÿ ^14 ÿ+-ÿ +IX ÿÿ 4/)=A-ÿ4<'ÿ6*'&8 52ÿ*5='-ÿ$5='ÿSU0X-ÿ?/2ÿ*'&82'7ÿC89ÿ6/*4ÿ)'1/52'ÿ4 ÿ (51<ÿ89@ *(/48 9ÿ?/2ÿ)'890ÿ7''('7ÿ1 9@87'948/=-ÿ891=57890ÿ89@ *(/48 9ÿ?<81<ÿ_787ÿ9 4ÿ 012314412ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿÿ 12 47ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !" #$%ÿ &'()'*ÿ+,-ÿ ÿ ./0'ÿ,ÿ ÿ ÿ 12'ÿ3 4*15ÿ/67ÿ12'8*ÿ)4586'55ÿ85ÿ9:467/('61/;ÿ1 ÿ/ÿ7'( 3*/183ÿ51/1'ÿ/67ÿ6'3'55/*<ÿ86ÿ 12'ÿ; 60ÿ*46ÿ5 ÿ12/1ÿ12'ÿ=4);83ÿ3/6ÿ>470'ÿ12'ÿ=* 7431ÿ :ÿ12'ÿ3 4*15ÿ86ÿ/ÿ08&'6ÿ3/5' ?@+ÿÿ 67ÿ12'ÿ=4);83ÿ3/66 1ÿ9>470'ÿ12'ÿ=* 7431ÿ :ÿ12'ÿ3 4*15ÿ86ÿ/ÿ08&'6ÿ3/5'?ÿ8:ÿ12'ÿ 86: *(/18 6ÿ)'860ÿA8122';7ÿ85ÿ6'3'55/*<ÿ: *ÿ467'*51/67860ÿ912'ÿ6/14*'ÿ :ÿ12'ÿ 785=41'?ÿ *ÿ12'ÿ3 4*1B5ÿ)/5'5ÿ: *ÿ/ÿ7'3858 6 @ ÿÿ C2'ÿ)4*7'6ÿ: *ÿ &'*3 (860ÿ12'ÿ=*'54(=18 6ÿ :ÿ=4);83ÿ/33'55ÿ/;A/<5ÿ:/;;5ÿ 6ÿ 12'ÿ=/*1<ÿ5''D860ÿ1 ÿ9 )1/86ÿ *ÿ 1 241 2ÿ 6:87'618/;ÿC*'/1('61 ?@@ÿÿ 67ÿ12/1ÿ=/*1<ÿ (451ÿ52 Aÿ( *'ÿ12/6ÿ('*'ÿ9= 1'618/;ÿ: *ÿ3 ;;/1'*/;ÿ'3 6 (83ÿ3 65'E4'63'5 ?@ÿÿ ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ :/;;ÿA81286ÿ/6<ÿ*'3 068F'7ÿ'G3'=18 6ÿ1 ÿ12'ÿ=4);83B5ÿ*8021ÿ :ÿ/33'55ÿ/67ÿA/5ÿ6 1ÿ1*4;<ÿ 5'65818&'ÿ *ÿ3 6:87'618/;ÿ86ÿ6/14*' B?ÿÿHI ÿ/1ÿJ@ÿK861'*6/;ÿ381/18 6ÿ (811'7L ÿ @+ÿ M7N 1ÿO 7 I724 18ÿP1934ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿQRÿOS ÿ -ÿ +@ÿTUÿ@V ,!-ÿ/1ÿJ ÿKW'; ÿ 2 ÿ #4;<ÿ+X-ÿ +@LÿK: 16 1'ÿ/67ÿ861'*6/;ÿE4 1/18 65ÿ (811'7L ÿÿÿ @ ÿ Y8ÿZ1[77 1ÿY 7 91 ÿ -ÿ +@ÿTUÿX!+ "-ÿ/1ÿJ+ÿK )5'*&860ÿ12/1ÿ9\1]2'ÿ=4);83ÿ861'*'51ÿ 86ÿ12'ÿ>47838/;ÿ=* 3'55ÿ3/66 1ÿ)'ÿ&86783/1'7ÿ8:ÿ12'ÿ6/14*'ÿ :ÿ12'ÿ;8180/18 6ÿ*'(/865ÿ(/5D'7ÿ 86ÿ/ÿ:467/('61/;ÿA/<?L ÿ @@ÿ 1 ÿ 2 ÿ$ ÿX +K)LK@LÿK'(=2/585ÿ/77'7L ÿ @ÿ Y8ÿZ1[77 1-ÿ +@ÿTUÿX!+ "-ÿ/1ÿJX ÿ 012314412ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿÿ 12 47ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !" #$%ÿ &'()'*ÿ+,-ÿ ÿ ./0'ÿ+ ÿ ÿ ÿ 12345'/6-ÿ57'ÿ7/*(ÿ(845ÿ)'ÿ9:/*5;<8=/*;>'6 ?@ABÿÿ23ÿ 57'*ÿC *64-ÿ1D5E7'ÿ< 3<=84 *Fÿ /44'*5; 3ÿ57/5ÿ/ÿ< (:/3FÿG/<'4ÿ/3ÿ8348)45/35;/5'6ÿ*;4Hÿ Gÿ9'< 3 (;<ÿ6;4/6&/35/0'?@ÿ ;4ÿ3 5ÿ'3 807 A!ÿÿ *ÿ;4ÿ: 5'35;/=ÿ'()/**/44('35ÿ *ÿ57'ÿG/<5ÿ57/5ÿ57'ÿ;3G *(/5; 3ÿ7/4ÿ 3 5ÿ:*'&; 84=Fÿ)''3ÿ6;4<= 4'6 AIÿ ::=F;30ÿ57;4ÿ)/=/3<;30ÿG*/('C *Hÿ7'*'-ÿJ'5K'=ÿ7/4ÿG/;='6ÿ5 ÿ:* &'ÿ/ÿ :/*5;<8=/*;>'6ÿ7/*(ÿ48GG;<;'35ÿ5 ÿ 85C';07ÿ57'ÿ:8)=;<?4ÿ;35'*'45ÿ;3ÿ57'ÿ*'6/<5'6ÿ ;3G *(/5; 3 ÿÿL;*45-ÿ57'ÿ7/*(ÿJ'5K'=ÿ/44'*54ÿC;==ÿ <<8*ÿ;Gÿ57'ÿ*'6/<5'6ÿ;3G *(/5; 3ÿ;4ÿ (/6'ÿ:8)=;<ÿ;4ÿ3 5ÿ48GG;<;'35=Fÿ:/*5;<8=/*;>'6 ÿÿ%'< 36-ÿC;57 85ÿ57'ÿ<8**'35=Fÿ *'6/<5'6ÿ: *5; 34ÿ Gÿ57'ÿ (:=/;35-ÿ57'ÿ:8)=;<?4ÿ/);=;5Fÿ5 ÿ836'*45/36ÿ57'ÿ :* <''6;304ÿ;4ÿ4'*; 84=Fÿ6;(;3;47'6 ÿÿL;3/==F-ÿJ'5K'=?4ÿ/*08('35ÿ57/5ÿ 1 M419Nÿ;4ÿ 6;4: 4;5;&'ÿ;4ÿ83< 3&;3<;30 ÿ ÿAÿBÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ ÿO2ÿ 7ÿ 8 P 1ÿQ 78 27ÿ ÿO29 -ÿ +"ÿRSÿ+" I-ÿ/5ÿT ÿUV'= ÿ 7 ÿ 80 ÿA -ÿ +"Wÿ UX8 5;30ÿM7Y 1-ÿ +AÿRSÿAI ,!-ÿ/5ÿT W ÿ A!ÿ Z[6ÿ\8]^ ÿO29 ÿ ÿ\1 -ÿ +IÿRSÿA+I B-ÿ/5ÿTAÿUV'= ÿ 7 ÿ%':5 ÿ "-ÿ +IWÿUX8 5;30ÿ Z8ÿ_1`77 1-ÿ +AÿRSÿB!+ "-ÿ/5ÿTAW ÿ AIÿM7Y 1-ÿ +AÿRSÿAI ,!-ÿ/5ÿT ÿÿa'</84'ÿJ'5K'=ÿ)'/*4ÿ57'ÿ)8*6'3ÿ5 ÿ:* &'ÿ0 6ÿ </84'-ÿ/36ÿ57'ÿG/<5ÿ57/5ÿ;3G *(/5; 3ÿ;4ÿ<8**'35=Fÿ836;4<= 4'6ÿ;4ÿ3 5ÿ48GG;<;'35-ÿJ'5K'=?4ÿ /*08('354ÿ57/5ÿ:/45ÿG;36;304ÿ Gÿ0 6ÿ</84'ÿ 3ÿ83< 35'45'6ÿ( 5; 34ÿ(845ÿ='/6ÿ5 ÿ57'ÿ4/('ÿ < 3<=84; 3ÿ7'*'ÿG/==ÿ47 *5 ÿÿJ 5 ÿbÿ B ÿ 012314412ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿÿ 12 47ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !" #$%ÿ &'()'*ÿ+,-ÿ ÿ ./0'ÿ++ÿ ÿ ÿ 12ÿ4567589:ÿ<=65>5:6ÿ?=ÿ@A=B?C5=6?D8?6Eÿ FG'ÿG/*(ÿH'IF'Jÿ/JJ'0'KÿLMJJÿ)'ÿMNOJMPI'QÿRS NÿMIÿMNÿIG'ÿ/)K'NP'ÿ Oÿ P NOMQ'NIM/JMITÿS* I'PIM NKÿMKÿI ÿ)* /QÿI ÿ(''IÿIG'ÿ*'URM*'('NIKÿ Oÿ$RJ'ÿV + ÿÿ Kÿ 'WSJ/MN'Qÿ/) &'-ÿI ÿKG Lÿ/NÿMNI'*'KIÿMNÿP NOMQ'NIM/JMITÿIG/Iÿ RIL'M0GKÿIG'ÿSR)JMPXKÿ *M0GIÿ Oÿ/PP'KK-ÿH'IF'Jÿ(RKIÿQ ÿ( *'ÿIG/Nÿ(/Y'ÿZ[0\'N'*MPÿKI/I'('NIKÿ OÿG/*( ]^"ÿÿ FG'ÿKG LMN0ÿ(RKIÿ)'ÿS/*IMPRJ/*M_'Q`ÿMNÿ IG'*ÿL *QK-ÿH'IF'JÿZ(RKIÿS MNIÿI ÿKS'PMOMPÿ MNO *(/IM NÿJMY'ÿaI*/Q'ÿK'P*'IKÿ *ÿP (S'IMIM&'JTÿK'NKMIM&'ÿS*MPMN0ÿMNO *(/IM NX]ÿIG/Iÿ MKÿN IÿMNÿIG'ÿSR)JMPÿ(MWÿ/NQ-ÿMOÿQMKPJ K'Q-ÿLMJJÿP/RK'ÿPJ'/*JTÿMQ'NIMOM'QÿG/*( ^,ÿ H'IF'JÿPJ/M(KÿI ÿ(''IÿIGMKÿ)R*Q'Nÿ)Tÿ/JJ'0MN0ÿZG/*(ÿ)'T NQÿMIKÿ*'SRI/IM N-ÿ MNPJRQMN0ÿ)RIÿN IÿJM(MI'QÿI ÿQM*'PIÿG/*(ÿI ÿMIKÿ)RKMN'KKÿ*'J/IM NKGMSKÿLMIGÿPR**'NIÿ/NQÿ S I'NIM/JÿPRKI ('*K ] ÿÿbRIÿH'IF'JXKÿ (SJ/MNIÿ/NQÿH IM Nÿ*'KIÿ NÿRNKR)KI/NIM/I'Qÿ ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ ^"ÿ c2ÿ 7ÿdef gÿ 1 f 2ÿ -ÿ +!ÿhiÿj^ ^ ^-ÿ/Iÿk ÿlm'J ÿ G ÿm'P ÿ+V-ÿ +!nÿlo*Q'*n ÿ ^,ÿ cp ÿlUR IMN0ÿq 272f7 rÿ ÿq14s-ÿ"j ÿ QÿV!"-ÿ! "t ,ÿlm'J ÿ G ÿ nn ÿ ÿ H I ÿuÿ+j ÿ 012314412ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿÿ 12 47ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !" #$%ÿ &'()'*ÿ+,-ÿ ÿ ./0'ÿ+ ÿ ÿ ÿ 12/3(4ÿ 5ÿ0'6'*31ÿ7/*( +ÿÿ8 *ÿ'9/(:2'-ÿ;'<='2>4ÿ (:2/36<ÿ/22'0'4?ÿ@A B61'ÿ<7/<ÿ 4''CÿA 5ÿ<7'ÿC'5/(/< *Dÿ4</<'('6<Bÿ7/4ÿ)''6ÿ:2/6<'C-ÿ<7'ÿ123'6<ÿE322ÿF6C'*</G'ÿ/ÿ 1*3<31/2ÿ2 Gÿ/<ÿ/ÿ:* &3C'*ÿE3<7ÿE7317ÿ3<ÿ7/Cÿ)''6ÿ:'*5'1<2Dÿ7/::DHÿ/6Cÿ@(/Dÿ <'*(36/<'ÿ<7'ÿ1 6<*/1<ÿ)/4'Cÿ 6ÿ/ÿ:*'<'9<H Iÿ@<7'*'ÿ34ÿ/ÿ*'/2ÿ*34Gÿ<7/<ÿ;'<='2ÿE322ÿ)'ÿ /4G'Cÿ< ÿ)3Cÿ 6ÿ5'E'*ÿ/6Cÿ5'E'*ÿ1 6<*/1<4ÿ0 360ÿ5 *E/*CHJIÿ/6Cÿ@A B61'ÿ1 653C'61'ÿ A36Bÿ/ÿ:* &3C'*>4ÿ536/613/2ÿ4</)323<Dÿ34ÿ1/22'Cÿ36< ÿKF'4<3 6-ÿ1F4< ('*4ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ1/6ÿ43(:2Dÿ 17 4'ÿ<7'ÿ6 6 1 65* 6</<3 6/2ÿ :<3 6ÿ 5ÿ4'2'1<360ÿ/ÿC355'*'6<ÿ&'6C * H ÿÿÿ =7'ÿ'9/(:2'4ÿ 5ÿ: <'6<3/2ÿ7/*(ÿ;'<='2ÿ 55'*4ÿ36ÿ4F:: *<ÿ 5ÿ<7'ÿ; <3 6ÿ/*'ÿ '&'6ÿ2'44ÿ1 61*'<' ÿÿ;'<='2ÿ/44'*<4ÿ<7/<ÿ@A3B5ÿ<734ÿ F*<ÿE'*'ÿ< ÿC341 6<36F'ÿ<7'ÿ 1 653C'6<3/2ÿ<*'/<('6<ÿ 5ÿ<7'ÿ:2'/C3604ÿ<7/<ÿ1 6</36ÿL*/63<'>4ÿC'5/(/< *Dÿ4</<'('6<4-ÿ 3<ÿE F2Cÿ'55'1<3&'2Dÿ<7E/*<ÿ;'<='2>4ÿ'55 *<4ÿ< ÿ:*'&'6<ÿ5F*<7'*ÿ3**':/*/)2'ÿ7/*( HMÿÿÿ ÿÿ+ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ ÿN<ÿ34ÿ3(: *</6<ÿ< ÿ'(:7/43O'ÿ7'*'ÿ<7/<ÿ<7'ÿ'9<'6<ÿ< ÿE7317ÿ;'<='2ÿ34ÿ*'KF3*'Cÿ< ÿ:2'/Cÿ 7/*(ÿ< ÿ(''<ÿ3<4ÿ(363(/2ÿ6 <31'ÿ:2'/C360ÿ)F*C'6ÿF6C'*ÿ F*<ÿ 5ÿ 7/61'*Dÿ$F2'ÿ"ÿC355'*4ÿ 5* (ÿ<7'ÿ( *'ÿ*30 * F4ÿ)F*C'6ÿ< ÿC'( 64<*/<'ÿ7/*(ÿF6C'*ÿ$F2'ÿM + ÿÿÿ ÿ (:2 ÿPÿJ+ ÿ Jÿ (:2 ÿPÿJ ÿ ÿ (:2 ÿPÿJJ ÿ Mÿ ; < ÿPÿ+M ÿ 012314412ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿÿ 12 47ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !" #$%ÿ &'()'*ÿ+,-ÿ ÿ ./0'ÿ+1ÿ ÿ ÿ 23'4'ÿ5 6'768/9ÿ3/*(4ÿ:/89ÿ6 ÿ(''6ÿ63'ÿ46*870'76ÿ5/*68;<9/*8=/68 7ÿ46/7>/*> ÿÿ?7ÿ :/;6-ÿ86ÿ84ÿ>8::8;<96ÿ6 ÿ8(/087'ÿ/ÿ>':/(/68 7ÿ;/4'-ÿ/6ÿ9'/46ÿ87ÿ/ÿ; (('*;8/9ÿ4'66870-ÿ @3'*'ÿ63'4'ÿ4/('ÿ; 7;'*74ÿ@ <9>ÿ7 6ÿ18A1B ÿ)'ÿ5*'4'76 ÿÿC'62'9ÿ6*8'4ÿ6 ÿ/& 8>ÿ6384ÿ *'/986Dÿ)Dÿ;9/8(870ÿ864ÿ3/*(ÿ84ÿ<78E<'ÿ)';/<4'ÿ>84;9 4<*'ÿF@ <9>ÿ'::';68&'9Dÿ7<998:Dÿ C'62'9G4ÿ':: *64ÿ6 ÿ5* &'ÿ86ÿ@/4ÿ/7>ÿ84ÿ)'870ÿ3/*('> H!ÿÿ 6ÿ4 ÿÿ?:ÿI*/786'ÿ3/>ÿ (/>'ÿ63'4'ÿ46/6'('764ÿ87ÿ/ÿ5<)98;ÿ4'66870-ÿC'62'9ÿ@ <9>ÿ46899ÿ)'ÿ/)9'ÿ6 ÿ4<'ÿ: *ÿ >':/(/68 7ÿJ<46ÿ63'ÿ4/(' KÿÿL389'ÿ63'ÿ7/6<*'ÿ :ÿ63'ÿ3/*(ÿ(/Dÿ>8::'*ÿ>'5'7>870ÿ 7ÿ 8:ÿ/ÿ>':/(/6 *Dÿ46/6'('76ÿ84ÿ(/>'ÿ87ÿ5*8&/6'ÿ *ÿ5<)98;-ÿ/ÿ>':/(/68 7ÿ *ÿ98)'9ÿ4<86ÿ @ <9>ÿ46899ÿ)'ÿ&8/)9'ÿ87ÿ'863'*ÿ; 76'M6 "ÿÿÿ %6'55870ÿ)/;Nÿ:* (ÿC'62'9G4ÿ/*0<('764-ÿ86ÿ84ÿ'&8>'76ÿ:* (ÿ/ÿ; (5/*84 7ÿ6 ÿ 63'ÿ'M/(59'4ÿ87ÿ$<9'ÿO +ÿ63/6ÿ5 6'768/99Dÿ>':/(/6 *Dÿ46/6'('764-ÿ 7 ÿ 7-ÿ/*'ÿ7 6ÿ63'ÿ N87>ÿ :ÿ87: *(/68 7ÿ63'ÿ>*/:6'*4ÿ :ÿ$<9'ÿO +ÿ876'7>'>ÿ6 ÿ5* 6';6 ÿÿ23'ÿ:8&'ÿ'M/(59'4ÿ 87ÿ$<9'ÿO +ÿ87;9<>'PÿF6*/>'ÿ4';*'64Qÿ4'74868&'ÿ5* 5*8'6/*Dÿ87: *(/68 7Qÿ4'74868&'ÿ ÿÿ!ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ ÿ$RÿSÿ! ÿ Kÿ T77 ÿ7 U -ÿT 7297ÿ ÿV 2W-ÿ1,!ÿ >ÿ,!K-ÿ,K XK1ÿYZ'9 ÿ+,K"[ÿY:87>870ÿ/ÿE< 6'ÿ87ÿ/ÿ5<)98;9Dÿ /&/89/)9'ÿ(/0/=87'ÿ/*68;9'ÿ@/4ÿ98)'9 <4[ ÿ "ÿ \] ÿ 012314412ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿÿ 12 47ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !" #$%ÿ &'()'*ÿ+,-ÿ ÿ ./0'ÿ+ÿ ÿ ÿ 123/342/5-ÿ)6723'77-ÿ *ÿ8'*7 33'5ÿ231 *(/92 3:ÿ7'37292&'ÿ8'*7 3/5ÿ231 *(/92 3ÿ764;ÿ/7ÿ ('<24/5ÿ*'4 *<7:ÿ/3<ÿ8'*7 3/55=ÿ2<'3921=230ÿ231 *(/92 3ÿ764;ÿ/7ÿ7 42/5ÿ7'46*29=ÿ 36()'*7-ÿ123/342/5ÿ/44 639ÿ36()'*7-ÿ/3<ÿ9;'ÿ3/('7ÿ 1ÿ(23 *ÿ4;25<*'3 >,ÿÿ?/4;ÿ 1ÿ 9;'7'ÿ'36('*/9'<ÿ4/9'0 *2'7ÿ27ÿ<274*'9'ÿ/3<ÿ*'15'497ÿ231 *(/92 3ÿ9;/9ÿ27ÿ3 9-ÿ *ÿ/9ÿ5'/79ÿ 7; 65<ÿ3 9ÿ)'-ÿ 1ÿ239'*'79ÿ9 ÿ9;'ÿ0'3'*/5ÿ86)524ÿ23ÿ9;'ÿ@6'79ÿ9 ÿ63<'*79/3<ÿ9;'ÿ<27869'ÿ )'1 *'ÿ9;'ÿ4 6*9ÿ *ÿ9;'ÿ)/7'7ÿ1 *ÿ9;'ÿ4 6*9A7ÿ<'4272 37 B ÿÿC;25'ÿDÿ< ÿ3 9ÿ<27869'ÿ9;'*'ÿ 27ÿ7 ('ÿ*27Eÿ 1ÿ'4 3 (24ÿ;/*(ÿ9 ÿF'9G'5ÿ21ÿ9;'ÿ*'</49'<ÿ231 *(/92 3ÿ27ÿ(/<'ÿ86)524-ÿ /55 H230ÿ764;ÿ231 *(/92 3ÿ9 ÿ*'(/23ÿ*'</49'<ÿI('*'5=ÿ)'4/67'ÿ297ÿ<2745 76*'ÿ9 8Jÿ 4/67'ÿ9;'ÿ8/*92'7ÿ'4 3 (24ÿ;/*(>ÿH 65<ÿ96*3ÿ9;'ÿ8*'76(892 3ÿ 1ÿ86)524ÿ/44'77ÿ 3ÿ 297ÿ;'/<ÿ/3<ÿ1*679*/9'ÿ9;'ÿ86*8 7'ÿ 1ÿ$65'ÿB + B+ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿÿ,ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ ÿ 9 ÿ ; ÿ$ ÿB +L)ML M ÿ B ÿ N77ÿO8ÿP1Q77 1-ÿ +RÿCSÿB!+ "-ÿ/9ÿT+ÿLIG;'=ÿ3 9'ÿ9;/9ÿ9;27ÿ 6*9ÿ9*/<292 3/55=ÿ;/7ÿ /55 H'<ÿ*'</492 3ÿ 1ÿ<274*'9'ÿ7'37292&'ÿ231 *(/92 3-ÿ764;ÿ/7ÿ/ÿ8*24'ÿ9'*(ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿG;/9ÿ27ÿ )'4/67'-ÿ 3ÿ)/5/34'-ÿ9;'ÿ<'9*2('39ÿ9 ÿ9;'ÿ8/*92'7ÿ 1ÿ<2745 76*'ÿ 69H'20;7ÿ9;'ÿ86)524ÿ239'*'79ÿ 23ÿ764;ÿ/ÿ<274*'9'ÿ82'4'ÿ 1ÿ231 *(/92 3 >M ÿ B+ÿ UJ ÿ/9ÿTBÿL'(8;/727ÿ/<<'<M ÿ 012314412ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿÿ 12 47ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !" #$%ÿ &'()'*ÿ+,-ÿ ÿ ./0'ÿ+1ÿ ÿ ÿ 23ÿ567ÿ9:;<=>?@ÿABC7D7@Cÿ=BÿEBF7D@CGBF=BHÿC67ÿ2G@7@ÿIJÿC67ÿK=@L:C7ÿÿ MN'ÿOP)QRSÿ(/RTU/RTVÿ/ÿVU* T0ÿRTU'*'VUÿRTÿ/SS'VVÿU ÿUN'ÿS TU'TUÿ WÿUN'ÿ/QQ'0'Xÿ X'W/(/U *YÿVU/U'('TUV ÿÿZWÿUN'ÿRTW *(/UR TÿSP**'TUQYÿ*'X/SU'Xÿ*'(/RTVÿV -ÿUN'ÿOP)QRSÿ [RQQÿN/&'ÿT ÿ('/TVÿU ÿPTX'*VU/TXÿUN'ÿXRVOPU'ÿ\'UM'QÿN/Vÿ/V]'XÿUN'ÿ P*UÿU ÿ /X^PXRS/U' ÿÿMNRVÿS TWQRSUVÿ[RUNÿUN'ÿOP)QRS_Vÿ*R0NUÿU ÿ`( TRU *ÿUN'ÿO* S''XRT0Vÿ/TXÿ *'VPQUaVbc1 d/ÿ*R0NU-ÿ/0/RT-ÿUN/Uÿ`N/Vÿ)''TÿSN/*/SU'*Re'Xÿ/VÿWPTX/('TU/QÿU ÿ/ÿ X'( S*/URSÿVU/U' c1fÿÿZTÿ UN'*ÿ[ *XV-ÿ[N'Tÿ`UN'ÿVPOO V'XQY S TWRX'TUR/QÿRTW *(/UR Tÿ *'O*'V'TUVÿUN'ÿT/UP*'ÿ WÿUN'ÿXRVOPU'ÿRUV'QWdUN'ÿRTU'*'VUÿ WÿUN'ÿOP)QRSÿRTÿ/SS'VVRT0ÿUNRVÿ RTW *(/UR Tÿ PU['R0NVÿUN'ÿ'S T (RSÿN/*(ÿU ÿUN'ÿO/*UR'VÿUN/UÿXRVSQ VP*'ÿ(/Yÿ S/PV' c1ÿÿMN/UÿRVÿUN'ÿS/V'ÿN'*' ÿ gNRQ'ÿ\'UM'Qÿ/TXÿ.* W'VV *ÿh Q ]NÿX')/U'ÿUN'ÿQ'0RUR(/SYÿ Wÿ.* W'VV *ÿ h Q ]N_VÿOQ/TT'XÿPV'ÿW *ÿUNRVÿRTW *(/UR T-11ÿT UNRT0ÿRTÿ P*ÿQ/[ÿ )QR0/U'Vÿi j7 ÿ ÿ1ÿ ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ ÿkl ÿ/Uÿmn ÿ 1fÿo 7 ÿ +fÿgpÿ+ f! 1-ÿ/Uÿm+ÿqrP URT0ÿ01447 ÿ jÿ 24s8ÿk88 ÿt79 ÿ 4 u -ÿnf ÿv Xÿ +f -ÿ+f "ÿqnUNÿ R* ÿ+,"ww ÿ 1ÿ x8ÿy1z77 1-ÿ +fÿgpÿ1!+ "-ÿ/Uÿm1 ÿ 11ÿ \ U ÿ{{ÿ+"| f}ÿ~OO_Tÿ{{ÿ+1|+n ÿ 012314412ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿÿ 12 47ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !" #$%ÿ &'()'*ÿ+,-ÿ ÿ ./0'ÿ+!ÿ ÿ ÿ 1 8 23ÿ3 ÿ4* &'ÿ567ÿ6'ÿ8''98ÿ/::'88ÿ3 ÿ;<= *(/3; <ÿ=;>'?ÿ;<ÿ/ÿ@'>/5/*'ÿ: A*3-ÿ(A:6ÿ >'88ÿ36/3ÿ6;8ÿ4A*4 8'ÿ;8ÿ8 ('6 5ÿB4* 4'* CÿD<83'/?-ÿ074678ÿ;8ÿ )>;0/3'?ÿ3 ÿ4* &'ÿ36/3ÿ 0 ?ÿ:/A8'ÿ'E;838ÿ3 ÿ?'<7ÿ.* ='88 *ÿF > 96ÿ/::'88ÿ3 ÿ36'ÿ;<= *(/3; <ÿ6'ÿ8''98ÿ/8ÿ/ÿ ('()'*ÿ =ÿ36'ÿ4A)>;: G!ÿÿH6/3ÿ;<= *(/3; <I36'ÿ0*/&/('<ÿ =ÿ36'ÿ:/8'I:/<< 3ÿ)'ÿ ?;8:'*<'?ÿ=* (ÿ36'ÿ*'?/:3'?ÿ (4>/;<3-ÿ56;:6-ÿ/3ÿ)'83-ÿ< 3;=;'8ÿ36'ÿ4A)>;:ÿ36/3ÿ J*/<;3'ÿ(/?'ÿ8 ('ÿA<9< 5<ÿ?'=/(/3 *7ÿ83/3'('<38ÿ36/3ÿK'3H'>ÿ< 5ÿ/88'*38ÿ/*'ÿ ?'=/(/3 *7ÿ= *ÿ8 ('ÿA<9< 5<ÿ*'/8 <L8M GNÿÿH6;8ÿ;8ÿ6/*?>7ÿ/?'OA/3'ÿ3 ÿ'</)>'ÿ36'ÿ 4A)>;:ÿB3 ÿ= >> 5ÿ/<?ÿ( <;3 *ÿ36'ÿ4* :''?;<08ÿ/<?ÿ36'ÿ*'8A>3ÿ =ÿP36'Qÿ?;84A3' CG"ÿÿÿÿ ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ G!ÿ 3 ÿ 6 ÿ$ ÿG +L)MLRMÿLBH6'ÿ4/*37ÿ *ÿ4'*8 <ÿ8''9;<0ÿ3 ÿ )3/;<ÿ *ÿ(/;<3/;<ÿ <=;?'<3;/>ÿ H*'/3('<3ÿ/>5/78ÿ)'/*8ÿ36'ÿ)A*?'<ÿ =ÿ'83/)>;86;<0ÿ0 ?ÿ:/A8'ÿ= *ÿ <=;?'<3;/>ÿ H*'/3('<3 CM ÿ GNÿS * ÿ'E/(4>'-ÿ36'ÿ;<3'*'83'?ÿ*'/?'*ÿ =ÿ./*/0*/46ÿ+Nÿ =ÿ36'ÿ (4>/;<3ÿ5 A>?ÿ*'/?Tÿ BJ*/<;3'ÿ6/8ÿ)'0A<ÿ3'>>;<0ÿK'3H'>U8ÿ:A**'<3ÿ/<?ÿ4 3'<3;/>ÿ:>;'<38I=/>8'>7ÿP$V@ HV@Qÿÿ H6'ÿ4A*4 8'ÿ =ÿ36'8'ÿ>;'8ÿ;8ÿ3 ÿ: <&;<:'ÿK'3H'>U8ÿ:>;'<38ÿ/<?ÿ4 3'<3;/>ÿ:>;'<38ÿ36/3ÿK'3H'>ÿ ;8ÿP$V@ HV@QCÿÿ (4> ÿWÿ+N ÿ G"ÿ X8ÿY1Z77 1ÿX 7 91 ÿ ÿ +Rÿ[\ÿG!+ "-ÿ/3ÿ]N ÿÿ^77ÿ18 ÿ_281 ÿ` 7a b347 ÿc72 2ÿ d74 ÿ^e ÿ ÿ f14-ÿ +Nÿ[\ÿG"+ G-ÿ/3ÿ] ÿL@'> ÿ 6 ÿ & ÿ+G-ÿ +NMÿL6 >?;<0ÿ36/3-ÿ />36 A06ÿ36'ÿ: (4>/;<3ÿ*'&'/>'?ÿ36/3ÿ36'ÿ:/8'ÿB;<& >&'P?Qÿ: ((A<;:/3; <8ÿ)'35''<ÿ ;3;0* A4U8ÿ(/</0'('<3ÿ/<?ÿ;38ÿg /*?ÿ =ÿ@;*':3 *8ÿ: <:'*<;<0ÿ;38ÿ: (4>;/<:'ÿ5;36ÿ>/5ÿ /<?ÿ5;36ÿ*'0A>/3 *7ÿ: <8'<3ÿ *?'*8-Cÿ*'?/:3; <8ÿ*'0/*?;<0ÿ36'ÿ84':;=;:ÿ: ((A<;:/3; <8ÿ 5'*'ÿ< 3ÿ4* 4'*ÿ8;<:'ÿBP3Q6'ÿ4A)>;:ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ6/8ÿ/ÿ83* <0ÿ;<3'*'83ÿ;<ÿ36'ÿ5 *9;<08ÿ =ÿ/ÿ@'>/5/*'ÿ '<3;37ÿ/<?ÿ;38ÿ: (4>;/<:'ÿ5;36ÿ8A)83/<3;&'ÿ>/5CM ÿÿ 012314412ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿÿ 12 47ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !" #$%ÿ &'()'*ÿ+,-ÿ ÿ ./0'ÿ+1ÿ ÿ ÿ 2ÿ 345ÿ6 748ÿ92ÿ)'ÿ9(: ;;9)4'ÿ< *ÿ/ÿ('()'*ÿ <ÿ2='ÿ:7)49>ÿ2 ÿ738'*;2/38ÿ 6=/2ÿ9;ÿ0 930ÿ 3ÿ93ÿ2=9;ÿ>/;'ÿ)/;'8ÿ 3ÿ2='ÿ:4'/8930;-ÿ?92ÿ9;ÿ89<<9>742ÿ2 ÿ'3&9;9 3ÿ/ÿ @789>9/4ÿ :939 3ÿ93ÿ2=9;ÿ(/22'*ÿ2=/2ÿ> 748ÿ(/932/93ÿ2='ÿ> 3<98'329/4925ÿ <ÿ/44ÿ2='ÿ 8';903/2'8ÿ(/2'*9/4ÿ/38ÿ5'2ÿ)'ÿ> (:*'='3;9)4'ÿ2 ÿ2='ÿ*'/8930ÿ:7)49> AB,ÿÿC3ÿ92;ÿ (:4/932-ÿD'2E'4ÿ/;F;ÿ2=9;ÿ 7*2ÿ2 ÿ8'2'*(93'ÿ6='2='*ÿG*/392'ÿ> ((922'8ÿ 8'</(/29 3-ÿ2 *29 7;ÿ932'*<'*'3>'ÿ692=ÿ:* ;:'>29&'ÿ'> 3 (9>ÿ/8&/32/0'-ÿ2 *29 7;ÿ 932'*<'*'3>'ÿ692=ÿ> 32*/>27/4ÿ*'4/29 3;-ÿ2*/8'ÿ49)'4ÿ/38ÿ8'>':29&'ÿ2*/8'ÿ:*/>29>'; ! ÿÿ H='3ÿ2=9;ÿ 7*2ÿ9;ÿ>/44'8ÿ7: 3ÿ2 ÿ8'2'*(93'ÿ2='ÿ('*92;ÿ <ÿ2=';'ÿ>4/9(;ÿ93ÿ2*9/4ÿ *ÿ ( 29 3ÿ:*/>29>'-ÿ2='ÿ 7*2ÿ6944ÿ3 2ÿ)'ÿ/)4'ÿ2 ÿ*'38'*ÿ/38ÿ8'49&'*ÿ/ÿ> (:*'='3;9)4'ÿ 8'>9;9 3ÿ692= 72ÿ*'<'*'3>'ÿ2 ÿ2='ÿ>7**'3245ÿ*'8/>2'8ÿ93< *(/29 3 ÿÿÿ ÿ ÿ ÿBÿ,ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ ÿJ8ÿK1L77 1-ÿ +MÿHNÿB!+ "-ÿ/2ÿO+ ÿ ! ÿ (:4 ÿPPÿM"Q1+ ÿ 012314412ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿÿ 12 47ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !" #$%ÿ &'()'*ÿ+,-ÿ ÿ ./0'ÿ+"ÿ ÿ ÿ 12ÿ4567589:ÿ<58=>?@5ÿA?ÿBCDEFCGHÿ=:ÿ4=:J8>@5Kÿ LMN/OOP-ÿQ'RS'OÿTO/M(UÿRV/RÿRVMUÿT W*RXUÿY'TMUM NÿMNÿ 1 Z419[ÿMUÿYMU\ UMRM&' !+ÿÿ ]NY''Y-ÿ/TT *YMN0ÿR ÿQ'RS'O-ÿ 1 Z419[ÿMUÿRV'ÿ*'/U NÿMRÿ^MO'YÿMRUÿ\O'/YMN0UÿWNY'*ÿU'/Oÿ MNÿRV'ÿ^M*URÿ\O/T' ! ÿÿ_NY'*ÿQ'RS'OXUÿ*'/YMN0ÿ ^ÿ 1 Z419[-ÿQ'RS'Oÿ`T/NN R-ÿ NÿRV'ÿ N'ÿV/NY-ÿ/*0W'ÿRV/RÿRV'ÿY'^/(/R *Pÿ/NYÿR *RM WUÿUR/R'('NRUÿ)Pÿa*/NMR'ÿ/*'ÿT/WUMN0ÿ M**'\/*/)O'ÿV/*(-ÿbVMO'-ÿ/RÿRV'ÿU/('ÿRM('-ÿ*'\'/RÿRV U'ÿY'^/(/R *Pÿ/NYÿR *RM WUÿ UR/R'('NRUÿMNÿRV'ÿ\W)OMTÿ*'T *Y c!dÿÿ Uÿ'e\O/MN'Yÿ)'O b-ÿRV/Rÿ*'/YMN0ÿ ^ÿ 1 Z419[ÿMNÿ RV'ÿT NR'eRÿ ^ÿRVMUÿQ RM N-ÿMUÿN'MRV'*ÿ/TTW*/R'ÿN *ÿ\'*UW/UM&' ÿ ]Nÿ 1 Z419[-ÿUV *ROPÿ/^R'*ÿRV'ÿ\/*RM'Uÿ'NR'*'YÿMNR ÿ/Nÿ/**/N0'('NRÿR ÿ bNÿ/NYÿ (/N/0'ÿRV*''ÿ*'NR/Oÿ\* \'*RM'U-ÿRV'ÿ*'O/RM NUVM\ÿ^'OOÿ/\/*R !ÿÿf RVÿRV'ÿ\O/MNRM^^Uÿ/NYÿ Y'^'NY/NRUÿ/TTWU'YÿRV'ÿ RV'*ÿ ^ÿ(MU*'\*'U'NRMN0ÿRV'ÿ'eR'NRÿ ^ÿRV'M*ÿ\*'&M WUÿ ÿ!ÿ+ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ ÿ +"ÿghÿd,, i ÿ ! ÿ Q R ÿjÿ ÿ !dÿ $fÿjÿ! ÿ !ÿ 1 Z419[ÿk1 3 887ÿlÿ -ÿ +"ÿghÿd,, i-ÿ/Rÿm ÿ 012314412ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿÿ 12 47ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !" #$%ÿ &'()'*ÿ+,-ÿ ÿ ./0'ÿ+,ÿ ÿ ÿ '12'*3'45'ÿ34ÿ67'ÿ3489:6*; !<ÿÿ =6'*ÿ67'ÿ2>/3463==:ÿ*'5'3&'8ÿ/ÿ>'66'*ÿ67';ÿ*'/8ÿ/:ÿ/ÿ67*'/6ÿ 6 ÿ:2*'/8ÿ67'ÿ/>>'0'8ÿ(3:*'2*':'46/63 4:-ÿ67';ÿ=3>'8ÿ:936 !!ÿÿ?7'ÿ2>/3463==:ÿ67'4ÿ( &'8ÿ = *ÿ/ÿ6'(2 */*;ÿ*':6*/34340ÿ *8'*-ÿ@/:AB340Cÿ673:ÿ 9*6ÿ6 ÿ6'(2 */*3>;ÿ'4D 34ÿ67'ÿ E'='48/46:ÿ=* (ÿ(/A340ÿ/>>'0'8>;ÿ8'=/(/6 *;ÿ:6/6'('46:ÿ/) 96ÿ67'ÿ.>/3463==:ÿ6 ÿ67'ÿ %F -ÿ34&':6 *:ÿ34ÿ %.-ÿ *ÿ/4;ÿ 67'*ÿ673*8ÿ2/*63': G!Hÿÿ@I4ÿ 67'*ÿJ *8:-ÿ67'ÿ.>/3463==:ÿ B: 9076Cÿ/ÿ2*3 *ÿ*':6*/346Gÿ 4ÿ:2''57-ÿJ7357ÿ3:ÿ2* 73)36'8ÿ);ÿ67'ÿE'>/J/*'ÿ 4:636963 4 !"ÿ K73>'ÿ36ÿ3:ÿ6*9'ÿ67/6ÿ 1 L419Mÿ7'>8ÿ67/6ÿ67'ÿ2>/3463==:ÿ7/8ÿ@=/3>'8ÿ6 ÿ':6/)>3:7ÿ 67/6ÿ3**'2/*/)>'ÿ7/*(ÿJ3>>ÿ>3A'>;ÿ*':9>6-Gÿ*'>;340ÿ34ÿ2/*6ÿ 4ÿ67'ÿ=/56ÿ67/6ÿ67'ÿ 34= *(/63 4ÿJ/:ÿ/>*'/8;ÿ29)>35ÿ67* 907ÿ67'ÿ2>'/8340:-ÿ67'ÿ5 9*6ÿ*'/57'8ÿ673:ÿ 5 45>9:3 4ÿJ7'4ÿ/4:J'*340ÿ/4ÿ'463*'>;ÿ83=='*'46ÿN9':63 4ÿ67/4ÿ67'ÿ 4'ÿIÿ/4:J'*ÿ ÿ!ÿ<ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ ÿOP ÿÿ !!ÿ OP ÿ/6ÿQ RS ÿ !Hÿ OP ÿ/6ÿQS ÿ !"ÿ OP ÿ/6ÿQSR ÿ 012314412ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿÿ 12 47ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !" #$%ÿ &'()'*ÿ+,-ÿ ÿ ./0'ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !, 1'*' ÿÿ21'ÿ3 4*5ÿ67ÿ 1 84199ÿ:/;ÿ)'670ÿ/;<'=ÿ>5 ÿ5'(? */*6@Aÿ'7B 67ÿC454*'ÿ;?''31ÿ )/;'=ÿ; @'@Aÿ 7ÿ/ÿC67=670ÿ51/5ÿ51'ÿ (?@/675ÿ?@'/=;ÿ/ÿ9 8 1D87ÿ981 ÿC *ÿ='C/(/56 7ÿ *ÿ5*/='ÿ@6)'@ EF ÿÿ21'ÿ3 4*5ÿ/7/@AG'=ÿ51'ÿ='C/(/56 7ÿ3@/6(;ÿ; @'@Aÿ67ÿ51'ÿ3 75'H5ÿ Cÿ ='36=670ÿ:1'51'*ÿ/ÿ2$Iÿ:/;ÿB4;56C6'= F+ÿÿÿ J'*'-ÿKÿ(4;5ÿ/7;:'*ÿ/ÿ;670@'ÿL4';56 7Mÿ:1'51'*ÿN'52'@ÿ1/;ÿ='( 7;5*/5'=ÿ/ÿ ?/*5634@/*6G'=ÿ1/*(ÿ51/5ÿ 45:'601;ÿ51'ÿ?4)@63ÿ675'*';5ÿ67ÿ/33';;ÿ5 ÿ3 4*5ÿ?* 3''=670;ÿ /7=ÿ*'3 *=; ÿÿKÿ/(ÿ7 5ÿ3 7;6='*670ÿ:1'51'*ÿ/ÿ5'(? */*Aÿ67B47356 7ÿ;1 4@=ÿ6;;4'-ÿ)45ÿ */51'*ÿ:1'51'*ÿ*'=/35'=ÿ67C *(/56 7ÿ;1 4@=ÿ)'ÿ(/='ÿ?4)@63 ÿÿ 7=ÿ)'3/4;'ÿ51'ÿ /@@'0'=@Aÿ='C/(/5 *Aÿ;5/5'('75;ÿ1/&'ÿ/@*'/=Aÿ)''7ÿ(/='ÿ/7=ÿ= 34('75'=-ÿKÿC/3'ÿ7 ÿ *6;<ÿ Cÿ67/=&'*5'75@Aÿ>C *)6==670ÿO/ÿ?/*5APÿC* (ÿ'70/0670ÿ67ÿ3 7;565456 7/@@Aÿ ?* 5'35'=ÿ;?''31 EF ÿÿÿ ÿ!ÿ,ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ ÿQR ÿ/5ÿST ÿ F ÿ QR ÿ/5ÿSÿU'(?1/;6;ÿ67ÿ *6067/@V ÿ F+ÿ QR ÿ/5ÿSTÿU675'*7/@ÿ365/56 7ÿ (655'=V ÿ F ÿQ R ÿ/5ÿSW ÿÿ21'ÿC/35ÿ51/5ÿ51'ÿ;5/5'('75;ÿ1/&'ÿ/@*'/=Aÿ)''7ÿ(/='ÿ@6<'@Aÿ'H?@/67;ÿ:1Aÿ N'52'@ÿ1/;ÿ7 5ÿ; 4015ÿ'('*0'73Aÿ67B47356&'ÿ*'@6'C ÿÿÿ 012314412ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿÿ 12 47ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !" #$%ÿ &'()'*ÿ+,-ÿ ÿ ./0'ÿ +ÿ ÿ ÿ 12*34'*-ÿ'&'5ÿ605 *650ÿ34'7'ÿ76056869/53ÿ:688'*'59'7ÿ65ÿ;* 9':2*/<ÿ; 732*'ÿ/5:ÿ *'=2'73':ÿ*'<6'8-ÿ>'3?'<@7ÿ 1 A419Bÿ/*02('53ÿ8/6<7ÿ8 *ÿ/5 34'*ÿ'=2/<<Cÿ7/<6'53ÿ *'/7 5 ÿÿD5:'*ÿ>'3?'<@7ÿ*'/:650ÿ 8ÿ 1 A419B-ÿ34'ÿ8/932/<ÿ0*/&/('5ÿ 8ÿ/ÿ:'8/(/36 5ÿ 9 (;</653ÿ9 2<:ÿ27 7 ÿ)'ÿ:679< 7':ÿ3 ÿ34'ÿ;2)<69ÿ65ÿ/ÿ9 2*3ÿ: 92('53ÿ68ÿ34/3ÿ 658 *(/36 5ÿE/7ÿ5 3ÿ;*'&6 27<Cÿ:679< 7':-ÿ*'0/*:<'77ÿ 8ÿE4'34'*ÿ/99'77ÿ3 ÿ34'ÿ ;/*3692</*ÿ73/3'('537ÿE 2<:ÿ9/27'ÿ;/*3692</*6F':ÿ4/*(-ÿ)'9/27'ÿ:679< 72*'ÿE 2<:ÿ ; 3'536/<<Cÿ8 *'9< 7'ÿ/ÿ74 E650ÿ 8ÿ6**';/*/)<'ÿ4/*( GHÿ?4/3ÿ*'/:650ÿE 2<:ÿ'&679'*/3'ÿ 34'ÿ;*'72(;36 5ÿ 8ÿ;2)<69ÿ/99'77-ÿ605 *'ÿ 2*ÿ$2<'ÿI +ÿJ2*67;*2:'59'ÿ*'=26*650ÿ/ÿ 74 E650ÿ 8ÿ0 :ÿ9/27'ÿ3 ÿ*')23ÿ34'ÿ;*'72(;36 5-ÿ/5:ÿ9 58<693ÿE634ÿ34'ÿ0'5'*/<ÿ*2<'ÿ 34/3ÿ34'ÿ('*'ÿ8/93ÿ658 *(/36 5ÿ67ÿK;*'&6 27<Cÿ25:679< 7':Lÿ67ÿ5 3ÿ'5 204ÿ3 ÿJ27368Cÿ 9 586:'536/<ÿ3*'/3('53 Gÿÿ 1 A419Bÿ4/7ÿ5 ÿ)'/*650ÿ4'*' ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿGÿHÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ ÿ$NÿOÿI ÿ Gÿ A7P 1-ÿ +HÿQRÿHG ,!-ÿ/3ÿS ÿÿÿ 012314412ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿÿ 12 47ÿ67879 2 914 2 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !" #$%ÿ &'()'*ÿ+,-ÿ ÿ ./0'ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ 123ÿÿ567589:167ÿ ;'</=>'ÿ?'@A'BÿC/>ÿD/EB'Fÿ@ ÿ</**GÿE@>ÿ)=*F'Hÿ DÿI* &EH0ÿ0 Fÿ</=>'ÿ=HF'*ÿ $=B'ÿJ +-ÿ?'@A'BK>ÿ? @E HÿD *ÿ H@EH='Fÿ HDEF'H@E/BÿA*'/@('H@ÿ(=>@ÿ)'ÿLM NML ÿÿ AC'ÿIB'/FEH0>ÿ/@ÿE>>='ÿOEBBÿ)'ÿ=H>'/B'F ÿ 1Pÿ1:ÿ:6ÿ6QRSQSR3ÿ T'*Gÿ@*=BGÿG =*>-ÿ UVUÿXYVZ[\ÿ]^ÿ_`ab\cVÿdddÿ

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.