Pinkerton v. State ex rel. Wyoming Workers' Safety and Compensation Div.

Pinkerton v. State ex rel. Wyoming Workers' Safety and Compensation Div.
1997 WY 73
939 P.2d 250
Case Number: 96-294
Decided: 06/10/1997
Supreme Court of Wyoming

Lorraine PINKERTON

 Appellant(Petitioner)

v.

STATE of Wyoming ex rel., WYOMING WORKERS' SAFETY AND COMPENSATION DIVISION,

 Appellee(Respondent).

Appeal from the District Court, Niobrara County

 The Honorable Barton R. Voight, Judge

Representing Appellant: 

Donald L. Painter, Casper.

 Representing Appellee: 

William U. Hill, Attorney General; John W. Renneisen, Deputy Attorney General; Gerald W. Laska, Sr. Assistant Attorney General; Bernard P. Haggerty, Assistant Attorney General.

Before TAYLOR, C.J., and THOMAS, MACY, GOLDEN and LEHMAN, JJ.

GOLDEN, Justice.

 [¶1]      Appellant Lorraine Pinkerton appeals the denial of her claim for worker's compensation benefits. She challenges the constitutionality of WYO. STAT. § 27-14-102(a)(xi)(J), which excludes workers' compensation benefits for mental injury which is not accompanied by physical injury, on the grounds that it violates equal protection.

[¶2]      Our recent decision in Frantz v. Campbell County Memorial Hosp., 932 P.2d 750 (Wyo. 1997), addressed this precise issue and is dispositive. The statute is constitutional and the order denying benefits is affirmed.

ISSUES

[¶3]      Pinkerton states the issue to be:

1. Whether W.S. 1977 § 27-14-102(a)(xi)(J) is unconstitutional as a denial of equal protection and due process for arbitrarily providing for the compensability of mental injury accompanied by physical trauma and the non-compensability of mental injury unaccompanied by physical trauma.

[¶4]      The Division of Workers' Compensation (Division) restates it as:

A. Whether the denial of benefits for the Appellant's mental injury violated the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.

FACTS

[¶5]      Pinkerton worked at the Wyoming Women's Correctional Center as a correctional officer. On March 9, 1996, while working the graveyard shift, Pinkerton discovered the body of an inmate who had committed suicide by hanging. Although she does not remember doing so, Pinkerton untied the knot from around the deceased's neck and helped to lay her down. This dissociative incident was followed by flashbacks, an overwhelming fear of the dark, extreme anxiety, and fatigue from disrupted sleep because of nightmares which rendered Pinkerton unable to return to work for several days after the incident. When she did return to work, additional symptoms surfaced leaving her unable to make rounds and check the safety of those inmates under a suicide watch for fear of what she might find. Pinkerton had seen the Center's psychologist after the incident and was prescribed an anti-depressant by her family physician, but her symptoms did not diminish. On April 7, Pinkerton resigned her position. In June, she began seeing a psychotherapist at Eastern Wyoming Mental Health Center. Pinkerton was diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder caused by discovering the dead inmate and began counseling sessions. Because of the loss of her job, she was unable to afford the recommended dosage of her anti-depressant. She has somewhat improved with counseling.

[¶6]      Pinkerton filed a worker's compensation claim for her mental injury, which was denied by the Division. She challenged the constitutionality of the statute which precludes recovery for mental injury unaccompanied by physical injury and received a contested case hearing. At the hearing, she and her counsel both stated that she did not suffer a physical injury because of this incident. Without ruling on the statute's constitutionality, the hearing examiner denied her claim. She petitioned the district court for review and it certified the constitutional question to this Court in accordance with WYO. R.APP. P. 12.09.

DISCUSSION

Standard of Review

[¶7]      Rule 12.09 of the Wyoming Rules of Appellant Procedure provides for judicial review of agency action according to WYO. STAT. § 16-3-114(c) (1990), which states:

            The reviewing court shall:

* * * * * *

(ii) Hold unlawful and set aside agency action, findings and conclusions found to be:

* * * * * *

(B) Contrary to constitutional right, power, privilege or immunity; . . . .

WYO. STAT. § 16-3-114(c)(ii)(B) (1990).

Equal Protection

[¶8]      WYO. STAT. § 27-14-102(a)(xi)(J) (Cum. Supp. 1996) provides:

(xi) "Injury" means any harmful change in the human organism . . . arising out of and in the course of employment. . . . "Injury" does not include:

(J) Any mental injury unless it is caused by a compensable physical injury, it occurs subsequent to or simultaneously with, the physical injury and it is established by clear and convincing evidence, which shall include a diagnosis by a licensed psychiatrist or licensed clinical psychologist meeting criteria established in the most recent edition of the diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders published by the American Psychiatric Association. In no event shall benefits for a compensable mental injury be paid for more than six (6) months after an injured employee's physical injury has healed to the point that it is not reasonably expected to substantially improve.

[¶9]      Pinkerton contends that the statute creates an unconstitutional classification when it distinguishes between one class of workers who have suffered a compensable injury because of physical injury and another class of workers who have suffered noncompensable mental injury. Since this appeal was filed, we decided this precise issue in Frantz v. Campbell County Memorial Hospital, 932 P.2d 750 (Wyo. 1997). We held that denying coverage for mental injury did not violate equal protection guarantees because the classifications bear a rational relationship to a legitimate state objective, namely, the economic concerns and burdens associated with mental injury. Frantz, 932 P.2d at 753-54. Our decision in Frantz is dispositive of the issue presented by Pinkerton. The order denying benefits is affirmed.