Pennsylvania v. Daniels (majority)
Annotate this CaseAppellees Henry Daniels and Kevin Pelzer participated in a plan to kidnap and hold for ransom sixteen-year-old Alexander Porter. Appellees kidnapped the victim, bound and gagged him, and placed him in the trunk of his car. Ultimately, they determined to kill the victim. In all, the victim was held in the trunk for twenty-four hours. According to appellees' police statements and Daniels's trial testimony, appellees were unable to determine whether the youth was dead when they went to dispose of his body. Pelzer shot Porter four times in the back of the neck to remove all doubt. The jury found both appellees guilty of first-degree murder and other offenses. These cross-appeals were a continuation of their first collateral challenges to their convictions under the Post-Conviction Relief Act ("PCRA"). The Pennsylvania Supreme Court vacated the PCRA court's March 25, 2003 order, which had granted appellees a new trial. The Court reviewed three claims of trial counsel ineffectiveness, denied relief on all three claims, and remanded the case to the PCRA court for the preparation of an opinion addressing the remainder of appellees' claims. On remand, the PCRA judge retired, a new judge ordered a new penalty proceeding for each appellee, while denying guilt phase relief. The Commonwealth appealed that order, while appellees, in separate cross-appeals, sought review of additional issues upon which the PCRA court denied relief. Upon careful consideration of the record below, the Supreme Court affirmed the order of the PCRA court as it related to Kevin Pelzer, but reversed the order as it related to Henry Daniels. Thus, Pelzer was denied guilt phase relief, but the award of a new penalty phase hearing to him was affirmed, and Daniels's PCRA petition was dismissed in its entirety.
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.