Calvary Episcopal Church, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, et al. v. The Right Reverand R.W. Duncan, Bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of Pittsburgh, et al. (Order)

Annotate this Case
Download PDF
IN THE COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA Calvary Episcopal Church, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, a Pennsylvania Non-profit Corporation; Saint Stephen's Protestant Episcopal Church of Wilkinsburg, Pennsylvania, a Pennsylvania Non-profit Corporation : : : : : : : The Reverend Dr. Harold T. Lewis, : Rector, Calvary Episcopal Church, : Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania; and Philip : Richard Roberts, Senior Warden, : Calvary Episcopal Church, Pittsburgh, : Pennsylvania, and Herman S. Harvey : : v. : : The Right Reverend Robert William : Duncan, Bishop of The Episcopal : Diocese of Pittsburgh; The Right : Reverend Henry Scriven, Assistant : Bishop of The Episcopal Diocese : of Pittsburgh : : Babatunde Fapohunda, Robert : Manson, James Moore, John Morgan, : Lynn Patterson, Donald Pepler, : Thomas Rampy, Bruce G. Seiling, John : Stevenson, Richard Thomas, and : Douglas Wicker, all of whom are : members of the Board of Trustees of : The Episcopal Diocese of Pittsburgh : : The Rev. Catherine Brall, Kathleen : Marks, The Rev. J. Douglas McGlynn, : The Rev. Scott T. Quinn, and William : Roemer, all of whom are members of : the Standing Committee of the : Episcopal Diocese of Pittsburgh, and : The Episcopal Diocese of Pittsburgh, : No. 293 C.D. 2010 an unincorporated association and The Episcopal Church, an unincorporated association, by The Right Reverend John C. Buchanan, as Trustee Ad Litem : : : : : Appeal of: The Episcopal Diocese of : Pittsburgh, The Right Reverend Robert : William Duncan, The Right Reverend : Henry Scriven, Babatunde Fapohunda, : Robert Manson, Kathleen Marks, The : Rev. J. Douglas McGlynn, James : Moore, John Morgan, Lynn Patterson, : Donald Pepler, Thomas Rampy, : William Roemer, Bruce G. Seiling, : John Stevenson, Richard Thomas and : Douglas Wicker : ORDER NOW, March 29, 2011, having considered appellants application for reargument before the Court en banc and appellees answer, the application is denied. BY THE COURT: BONNIE BRIGANCE LEADBETTER, President Judge

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.