FEARNSIDE v. LINDHARD

FEARNSIDE v. LINDHARD
1931 OK 12
300 P. 378
149 Okla. 161
Case Number: 20185
Decided: 01/27/1931
Supreme Court of Oklahoma

FEARNSIDE, County Treas.,
v.
LINDHARD.

Syllabus

¶0 Municipal Corporations -- Taxation -- Case Followed.
Under stipulation of parties, the decision of this court in the case of J. R. Jones, County Treasurer of Okmulgee County, v. Chas. Blaine, No. 20026, 149 Okla. 153, 300 P. 369, is determinative of the issues in this case, and the rules of law therein announced, in so far as they are applicable herein, are announced as the law of this case.

Error from District Court, Muskogee County; Enloe V. Vernor, Judge.

Action by W. L. Lindhard against H. C. Fearnside, County Treasurer of Muskogee County. From the judgment, defendant appeals. Affirmed in part and reversed in part.

Broaddus & Ambrister and S. H. Lattimore, for plaintiff in error.
Stone, Moon & Stewart, for defendant in error.

ANDREWS, J.

¶1 W. L. Lindhard, the defendant in error, who will be hereinafter referred to as plaintiff, instituted this proceeding in the district court of Muskogee county against the plaintiff in error, who will be hereinafter referred to as defendant, to recover money paid under protest under certain tax levies for the fiscal year commencing July 1, 1927. The case was tried to the court without a jury, and the court rendered judgment in favor of the plaintiff on the fourth cause of action. The defendant brought the cause to this court on appeal.

¶2 There is herein presented the validity of a cemetery levy made under the provisions of chapter 8, S. L. 1927, a library levy made under the provisions of chapter 7, S. L. 1927, and a city park levy. The trial court sustained the contention of the plaintiff as to the cemetery levy and library levy and denied the contention of the plaintiff as to the city park levy.

¶3 The parties herein have stipulated that the issues in this cause shall be submitted to this court for its consideration on the briefs filed in this court in the case of J. R. Jones, County Treasurer of Okmulgee County, v. Chas. Blaine, No. 20026, 149 Okla. 153, 300 P. 369.

¶4 Under the decision of this court in that case, this day decided, the cemetery levy was void. The judgment of the trial court as to that levy is affirmed. Under that decision the library levy is valid. The judgment of the trial court as to that levy is reversed. The question of the levy for the city park was not presented in that case, and, not having been briefed, the judgment of the trial court as to that levy is affirmed.