CRAVEN v. SMITH

CRAVEN v. SMITH
1920 OK 35
188 P. 96
77 Okla. 260
Case Number: 9907
Decided: 01/20/1920
Supreme Court of Oklahoma

CRAVEN
v.
SMITH.

Syllabus

¶0 Quieting Title--Validity of Tax Deed.
Affirmed upon the authority of Prowant v. Smith, No. 9905, 77 Okla. 257.

Error from District Court, Pawnee County; Conn Linn, Judge.

Action to quiet title by Minnie B. Craven against Isaac Smith. Judgment for defendant, and plaintiff brings error. Affirmed.

Orton & Moore, for plaintiff in error.
McCollum & McCollum, for defendant in error.

KANE, J.

¶1 This cause is ruled by the opinion this day handed down in Eva S. Prowant v. Isaac Smith. While this action was commenced and prosecuted by a different plaintiff against the same defendant, and involved the title to different lots, the lots were included in the same tax deed, and the questions presented for review are precisely the same in both cases.

¶2 In these circumstances the judgment of the trial court in this case must be affirmed upon the authority of Prowant v Smith, supra.