Gill v State

Gill v State
1919 OK CR 92
179 P. 618
15 Okl.Cr. 596
Decided: 04/08/1919
Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals

1. APPEAL AND ERROR Appeal by Certified Transcript of Record Errors Considered.

2. SAME Remarks of Trial Judge on Overruling Motion for New Trial.

3. APPEAL AND ERROR Failure to Appear or File Brief Affirmance.

Appeal from District Court, Harper County; W.C. Crow, Judge.

E.F. Gill was convicted of the crime of adultery, and sentenced to pay a fine of $250 and costs, and he appeals. Affirmed.

Page 597

PER CURIAM. This is an appeal by transcript of the record from a judgment of conviction rendered in the district court of Harper county against the defendant, E.F. Gill, sentencing him to pay a fine of $250 and the costs of the action for the crime of adultery.

The court has examined the record, and finds no prejudicial error sufficient to authorize a reversal of this judgment. There is an attempt to incorporate as part of the transcript a long dissertation delivered by the district judge at the time sentence was pronounced against defendant, and it is claimed in the petition in error that an examination of this discourse evidences in the mind of the district judge a doubt as to the guilt of the defendant. Such a discourse forms no part of the record. Lumpkin v. State, 5 Okla. Cr. 488, 115 P. 478.

An appeal by transcript includes only the following papers:

(1) The indictment or information, and a copy of the minutes of the plea or demurrer.

(2) A copy of the minutes of the trial.

(3) The charges given or refused, and the indorsements, if any, thereon.

(4) A copy of the judgment. Section 5960, Revised Laws 1910.

It is apparent, therefore, that the attempt to incorporate this discourse by the trial judge into the record in this case must fail, and, for the reason that it forms no part of the record, this court is not at liberty to consider any alleged error based upon it.

Finding no prejudicial error in the record properly constituting the transcript which the clerk is authorized

Page 598