THOMPSON v HARVEY

Annotate this Case

Download PDF

.0 I8 ' , ' <?t El 3 ,, k"la,Lntiffs and ,~~jrpa?I.Lants " . , , , -,'vj:j - . .7 . , \v I I,,~l:~TAMH ~ ~ ~ l ~ \c?rt: ~ ~1 Y ~ Deferzriant~< and Ra.spuxrtSents Counsel o f liecord : .Iardiire? irntl KcCzarthy, Wiai,teiit~l. , Montanii L ,John 11, .Jard"Lne a r g u e d , i d i ~ i t e h al , Pioritanii l Glenn F, Kei~nsry srgue,i?, f i e l e n a , Mantama S a t a l l , Cunx.in:Lns aird ilat:ch, lie1 crra , Mor~taixa Robert T, G~"~mrnl.ns arpxrecl, i-iiiienal Montana tinrri..rora, i,t?c?crdor:f aim! PosC:on, H e l e n a , Mor'rtarru .James T. Hnrrisor.x , .9r, rirj;rred, iicl,e?rr:i, Morrtsr?a Sirbinittei.~ : February 26, i W & Mn-, t:Jiisl.i.ce lv'c?sl(:!)r , - .,- C : a n a~,>:.,~csiJ..J?x:cxn a .j!,~dgrl?er~.!:, <:>I: is: ,> .,$, ,,. & ,:. * i : . I S I I ., ,,,$I.,, 1, , : ~ ~. I ' . .. "" .Lli(:: C:l,,s;eri 'IlTrj.e? t:!,lL:l <:tc: i ~ , L: M(> I. . .,/a L i,(>n {<?: .:I [lt?~??~ T t:,?)ne?,r\,:k : :: I (!? t. C. : :;nuri-!:?i, ..... " arc+ tA;i:, x:j,,q~l kJ i ?& t; ;3,1: c: L? 1S ):( . ,, eXC: tnc! n\ri.ier.u ci!:.i,e (0f . .< .on(,:!,irrs or c,:ii~r~i..rac:t;~urch,ss;:r.; j + , i x i . Bro;ldwatt:?a: i,)j,tc:ki (,:,::xnpd:t~y i :r\)iiz .; C.?(>I~~IJ~,~ -,j % i- p () i . . . r:egl;t; . -- pr#,:>-.. T:)(:i (.;l.' '"- tire s u i ~ c r r d i . r ~ d t:. l> i r oC wa;.cr from 2,kic? incr coj,~<,~<~.c^i.,o.c f , ii:'$ r : ?rile N:i,s::o1,ir:l-- N.ii:urr a I Rc!~so:.~rc:c:~~ Mi e i ( u i. : , r .-B),:.va:ih~;i ti.r. :',i .~. a,,, r ~,.\,~fs ,- Tl,y -15 ,. t,. c;ril~l~m \4hC., ! - -" A \ISt26 ti: 1 . :.,ni,~ii: crt i :Ire i i i1,~lt.i i 0 . .i,c>l:i.lliorrec \$a:: p;lrcikai;ec? f r c m iricti r.ig,hc (,:rw;irxi y ;: 1 1 D($t?p <,:j: c+<;:l.: 1 >d Ca k \I,:r ?>, .,i ?.> . '-. t1 ' 811 ,!i : s,l<;,ei_ ; <>, :i;;rt.,ik::s . CJ~, L~ ),it;: o f wiit,ex: (3 < a $5 e?:t: :n i3.i~ (.>\,;n~.!rsby ~~::.rciliis;eo i ,a pri;r;cirr:: e pt:. .C:$?l ! i . , \i1z:r W2.t:r ,:Jc>h:i N t.!;.]:ii 1. F! e?5i::;xu rc: c? 26 a 4 tj ~-)r> x - it,".y .! i, c i , [ g , ~t:.~,l : , t. .LC,:! : f ~ VJ.\i,i. ? . ,. X<>~:[it?i~: I J < i ~I.C:%~? ~ i ~ :c ''~ HI.! kx?~: Chc.>dtqi 11 a TI' LC. I i 5 i"r!(::l) 7 ' arid I,'" E < b j + : n t,<3 ~:~rt>t..c:s : L.e]:s ~ l<c:>be~: ~ ;,XI , ~ I{i:>l>y<: ,Ifk>klr~ ~ t : ?- ~ ~ ~ F'], yr:l;i St,.a,t. (2 1 , t:,ar~;i ~ ori.<j:!,na.l i.l-rie ~ 13e$,trk> lj.<:.~\.>pc: I,aot,~ .i, N c;,j,"cj.I.,s ric?, i.pbc:. . ~, ,:~.c~]~~c~.i,c:?it,:,,,,. .. . . arc> Ge:: 1.i:l F ,, u.1 :<:!l pet. i.t.i.c>l~,c!~:!:5 L'xc,l ;.I< (icT\rl:~.,. . . . ...sJ,~~.t,., 21;iurLce i i ~ ~ n s a c k ~ c!'hart il-I (:li:rkc:, ?r, :i , J;L~,I!OY-L;.IIX.I(;"~~,(-; ,, , t,.l~.,~,l.k $91. dci~:rk:c? i * r c ) u g l ~ iut~:.ie; iirg t,.ire cc,:t,..e~:'s o f r e e p Crctc?l.: :>.ntr ueaus , : e i:.itli: o f :h .,.. L +. .. r.v " ?,,<,?, ,," -..> . , a pi?t3.,rinrr f o r at! cirdclr. . . . wa; s ac:l:iirr? t..ht: ( : . k . . . : CC>I.X~: Ais,rj<', c d i , \ ~ ~ : ; r s i . : : x - ~ Deep <,,:r:et>K. E'~:ot>,cJ~~~;~ater <:>I>, ~.r>, C!:m~ir>t.y~ <::x>.:,~<,gc? i.u pc~il~t c>,f kt cde?%i\rc.red i l e Oc,>i?~i.c>rrof i-ihc? Coilrt., t C;stJ.es e>;<c,?l,.(z ,i,s+:2 csc, (.> f + .s.(,: . i.,kt<?1, i i ! S t,,, fc>j: i.t:, (31 3 ,I.<] :<ears* i l l c e l ~ l ~ ~ :it:>1-z :!j,ri:t 31 r . d,.r,ve~rs~ori crcri?!l?l.y ,,ei.;i~ ( , l~ , ~ t ~ , tri s r ..o iijilz:; T":e 1 usc!cl ir. t h e "-- a r c ! 2 oc:iCeiS d,ok;n:il:r:i:rrt drL , , . i'ror-, t h e rjoi.nt, at,.:*znrcr: t.i;r ' . I ~ : . ; ~ o u r j : - l : ~ r : o ~ ~ c i \ ~ r ~ ~ ~ , ~ ? r : Ca!,;:I, ilii-p (.:l,r.c&l; . t s [:.ire c?(:!el~: . i7 c . P i 1 ~ ~ c ? r 5 . L i ; > , i , : r pro1:~ose to rrrovc! Ir.he poi,r;ir o f ~ ~ i i r . i b i : ; i , c ~ : ~ :s for .,.,;lc :i,nc:il r i . g i l i up;;i:-:eam -'-. /,'a . c!s " PJ.L,! a:.i crc: :'( i c , 'P;>.> -a. ., t. - I i : !.i?c?rj ~ ' V: of :IL~:P& t:j.[;~ht. r?:i I, I.)(,? 1 ' 3 ) i,c!l-es of.' Cree(?!: , : i p ; ~ r o ~ ~ i m n t '-.'? : I . ~ ~ ~ ,: .I~ ~:?;e:*d ]<~\l:i i_.e%ov,i,,. ,-t-j ,l.a,l:;J n;c;ve wo~,l:M idacre t i l e pc:).i,irt 0 C "i r: I< : (gate: :~.pp~:;r.i 1: , , L!:> t..\l<: k,lk. l;<e .. . cxl l<:)T>Cl?:i :r J . divccrsi(r,l~;>e 3 ;ni.:.c.s aL)ove ::m , w.i ih w a t e r i:r:i~n t h r : csana.L wh.i,c:l , 1.s pCace(d i.11 i,:i;e at Liie !;,jo.i.;~i t h e carral c*:c,s.;es ?:,he st.rc:,"iiv, in -ti:<: cnlr;~.!,.was c::c,jn:p:,c?t:e~3 s:i,,nc:e ~si;i,? ir.1 : t : c . n c!iar~r.si:.L sreir! Il'11.l~ Sy::tI-'n~, 19151, 'T';.,i.s ,.,ncj-, f : s cr.r: o n l y ;:ir:acti.c!al, n~rr.irir::(:$ tilt! , or r,f r .t I i. ,. l i$1 . ," the?, cr)rtrtr t:o makc. i;ie . I . .: : . . i , L.1. rc:p:.*cc::d I , : ciirr-rl. w i 11. mean f?;(.)~m t.h; ~ar,;l. mealis t.i:a:: ,r,'. ,i(::s , ,,, ..' i,:)c:k! .,,I. (:,>Wl\e~], ~JY .,. rc,2,,, .L . :p!t: . , L't; :LC>TL(?l: :or t i , p c:i.~!ilr~,l.li.fig , s L, : ; , i j.r! ~gt:>.~~:l,d ] l ~;;:,,r~,qjc:jse>~.J t > <::k)a~i:;~(::. , . . 27; :~ncli~r p.l.:rcr.i! (;~:~I?PJ~s c.rc2 i n i i ? r . i . o r ?,i :.l , , t,,Ll<:r ~ 1;'i.l.: . c;iiinc>t il-ls".?,. r~si:lt, trlc:? ,,:>I1 dv;si,lal,,l<:; Lo i,!,ic.~a~. ,, .~ ,. .. ,- ,~, i:~'4i*.i.<lual.s u wlrose i:i,ght:; 4 ".' I Y i c j i l t : ,.G 1, I t : wi.l.1 i l s o m a : el: 80 ac.r-<?fso f Land wi:i.i .itr ;33si. . nil, . : pi.)Lii' &,>.,nve L:iri: t ~ I;: : , tIj.c? : : x . i , ~ l C iif (,.l.ivet.:;io~i 0 ' k> I.? .it j ,+ i 11 e r ,: * : . : c> ; r i . w;,'~.! tho:.re !h;?ii.(:!* exi'llan~~c IY)~ wi.ta.r divcit:c:(.i ,.\ I : j T t , y;iI:c>,- 1s, who .e 1,and, YL $5 1.cxc~i (:>ii t: .c.l.l C? : " ; :I CI k:>rz\? ,(,: , r i c r:rarr:;iie.ro f .~ "" i Ly 1, s 2(_. j..7*:-- . -. s~pcr,;,r,i.i.c:l,~~y- ~ w c . d irncle?... sei.t.!.c>n 89--8'.Cl6, Y<s(:,:A5s ;5,il vjdc:s bet:un . 3 . t t ~ oi.1: ~iu-r'rrr.?r: pc;>i.nt,,> 1 <i.iv*et:: i.c>rj > ri,d ( : : ; : , LLS;<C Sec::.(,):,)(lr l i l the (.~L:]~:ctc~rs d 1~re2 p . : o l enti,-l:,i.et,i tc- {.he !.~i;c o f !.?atc;i mil\ir:r rn \c, t.hk? p I.?l<>E? c>f (.:i iVt?! 1 S <:>TI .)1, t,. i:,t ht:? rS ::i.r , . . , : ! . 1), >,t:crk?::I .,! ~.. t:,he?:t::lc]: ... .\,",., .)m a nit, may e > < i : e x ~ c L l, k ~ : <i:,i,c;h ~ I, i !j,nle, pi,pts, i ayl:%di~c:i::., by wrl;.::i~, :ljc i;ivr.,r s L r i ; r o: .. , . ?, r . i , t {.> , , '. , ,. ,l.i ; a . i:.o a17 pLuci: ol,hr.r i^:?an \-here t l ? e I milt 11 ).:,Sf.. w ~ mtrd,e, <>.nil m,ehy use: i l l e xi:$,ti:s lhcrr <:)t;Ilc;r .a,k. ~ s . . ~ r.>urliosc:~; tli;~!-; h a t f o r wi.:ic.ii i t wa,s or~.a;.):rrar.l.y t t!,?>." (2 . ,< k1 , (, 1 c, j ?.\ . :l;>.(>l: > p rj <,i ~ . c , t"<.!d. i,:o an *nc,:c;,.s,::d usi:. !' of .igjter k,e"ailse? o f t h e incrc;i!.sc: j.n d c r r : i q ~ , ? riny i>er:;o:, pcrrsorls, x i - s c x -.t n .c l, or1 o r cnl:porei l.ion , c~v,i~j, "i.:a<,~j (:ox: i" pc, S~IS; < jLt:!r~ I! : s : 1 a r ~ (c;3 s1.1c -f:> [>+.ik> :t (? c>.f s .i,rr ( > . L . L v n . . . ia ~ ; % *,<isor?\ n1'1y strcaci, t h e i.~atc?rs:! ,v- c ", d C:I . u I a : : 3c' i i.~ll.iri.i. h d , by ' io! .:;i)l;)r~pl:.iit i i c ~ i ~ itlillt .I l: i s ; ,: - . . r s : .., .". . . ! ~ 1 t :C;:I.~,:::I~ : > n ~ o ~ ~ r ~ t , V A ~ a c , c x f<:>r: l;,,tj,n i,t:r i : i : , . ga t,, j . (of t hc>i.i: iar,~::is cccint1c.t b: (c.lbta:i,r,e;l fkorrr t h r ~~?at:,u:ral t! . 1 . .w . j,,., of i,hc .;tra;rm, rdhc s h a l , I . cor!sirucf a r~:?,s.;:r~.:r)i-:, ox: s h a l i pu.rc!~a:je 0 : a 1 s : .from A r~'.:-rv'.'I .,, r ownet1 by L h t ? .;l;;itc: wal:ei,: c:onse.rvair.i.orr Sriard o f ~ I I c ? / t ., __._8,.: ?~t:<i,[,<e :,IC>~)~:?IJIEL,> t , , . k ~ f ~ ~ . ' ~ l i ~ S t : c;f (j: ? ~ i ~ ~ [ . k t p u::.. ~ S l > , t ~ l l ! . .~ v , : . r e 1 ill:(\r@sL ill ~i~:<:lbre~ec\rl.>l.r~ 01. lwCit:.cer st:.orc?d t:Ckac?rein, wi:ic.!ki i s so i.~rc,2l:ed ilia-I: l.:~<>iii!~ii. c ; f n,ivir:t,l or oihe,r ob!:itsc-1c.s Lire: water i.rnpi>i.li;r3i.C1. + i . L,~c.lrc:.in c a u - n c ~ tb ! c:ond;ri:tec? e to Lllo 1.drrci.s v;!,h;.i.:h t.;hey ,,,,-,,,a, .,t:,.,31rc. .i,o i r : r i ~ ~ : i t : c . , n a y , px:vvif.j<::d i:ile siorocl W d L t 3 I . ,.$ <: ..> c , l n ire dl,schargi.ch irrt:t, t.hc: st:,r;edrn i.11 SL.L<:?! )il,;:it)::(jl. a - t l ~ a ti.t c.:ar! h : used b o n c f i o i ~ i l , l . I::y/ j:jl::i.oi. ap&rrt>p15.-. e ~ ., da(:(r),rid x ~ / ~ : Tt.!.te :liitl:j;:aI f ' l ~ ; v i o f i.i)c: (I:ITC:.IX~ 'cL t ::, . L ~iie I : : oi a i s I,.-: .l..iet~ o f ?in e::~pi,-:~,l. ;rlno;,i;it o f s t c > r e d wa t?u , p:o.;r.i.c:i~~d, i?i.wt?ver. , t h a t s n c i l t>xc?i~;ir~(;~e Lx: nki3,<lc: i ~ d j t i~,c>iu ii j: ~ r y ,l;.c I i (:i i.<:t : c,:? r> . t:, > , ; : lpr : I 1Jjp.r 0p:t: i ic : : : . ' . i> < ! 'I t ; I <:.o\.lrL cl:'e<:$d,7.n laj,:l.i,;;y to deii2~:rninc: ;.I,e trxte3t and t.~iu::nti.c~r'l C (.J.L (,/ Justice

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.