Richard D. Roberts v. Michal Shahan, Division of Motor Vehicles

Annotate this Case

Download PDF

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

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.