William Drylie, Jr. v. Michael Shahan, Director of Division of Motor Vehicles, Department of Transportation

Annotate this Case

Download PDF

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

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.