Credit Acceptance Corp. v. James F. Cole, Jr. and Kimberly S. Cohey

Annotate this Case

Download PDF

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

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.