John W. Gillespie v. Chelsea on the Square Apartments

Annotate this Case

Download PDF

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

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.