Kenneth D. Rutledge, et al. v. S & L Contractors, Inc. and Brent Rogers v. Alton Beach, Country Custom Siding, Inc. & Stelljes Excavating and Paving

Annotate this Case

Download PDF

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

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.