James M. Kozel, LLC, a Delaware Limited Liability Company v. Mulligan's Pizza, Inc., a Delaware Corporation, and Joseph Girgis

Annotate this Case

Download PDF

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

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.