Miriam Anderson v. Pennsylvania Manufacturers Association Insurance Company

Annotate this Case

Download PDF

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

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.