Haas Publishing v. Apartment Communities d/b/a Harbor House, et al.

Annotate this Case

Download PDF

!" " " #"$ %&'%(')*+ ,- " , " .-/ ,$ /- 0 +1 +%%2 3 , ,$ 3 #- 0 +& +%%2 , / " / +%% # : 09 4 0 56. 0 0# 7 8 0! . );2)* " #53# 56. 0 #53# 8 03# " " )()* " 0 9 0 " " #< )&22 / 4# );(;; 0 " " +)1 5 .- 57 4 =7 0 @.5 3 # 7 0 , 4 7 3 5 #0 35 #.0 , 3 5 # , A 4 5 /# # .0 # ,3 0-#0 #.5 5 # 7 " =7 0 0 #0 0 5 -0#.47 5. 0> 0/ # 0 C +%%& , 0 , 5? -0 45 7 5 #! 3 0#/ # '5. B.,4/ " 4 #//. 4 4 , - #: , #0 ,! 0 5 4 5 0! 3 5" # 7 3#/ 0> 0/ 5 0/ #//. 5? # #0 -#. #//. 0 3 # - 7 5 ,- 037 & +%%& 5 / A0 5 # , , # , , 5 , , / , , 0 # 5: 0 4! # 0 3. 05" , ! 0- 7 0 5" 3 , " 0 , #0 0 " 5 7 0 # # 7 0 A * +%%&" 7 0 # 4 4 <3.5 - # : 75 , 4 #.0 A )& +%%& 4 3" #7 , 0 , /# # 7 0 4 : 5 7 , # # 7 A +& +%%&" 7 537 ,. 7 0 4 3#. 5 4/ 04. , 7 ,! 0 A 75/ 0: 0 !# ! , 7 7 0 47 ,#.0 #-5 0! , 7 7 : 5 : 7#. ,7 # , 5/ 55 7 #0 0 , 7 5 D , 7 A 4# 5 05 0 7 # 0 5 # '5. B.,4/ /# # 7 0 4 # 0 537 ,. , #0 5 #0 7 5 3#. 5 # '5. B.,4/ 7 : 5 7 0 -# 7 :0 A * +%%& ! 3 0 .0 #.0 7 / 55 , 0 # 75 3 , 0" .0 # #//. 0 3. 05 :0 # # # @. A +) +%%& , 0#/ , # /# # , /5 :7 0 ," 5 /#! , # 5 #0 5 # , # 7 # .0 7 0 # 5 # 0 5# ! 7 3 0/ #0 5 # , # 7 0A # 55 5 7 / # '5. B.,4/ 7 7 0 4 7 0#3 , 45 #0 , 4# , 5 30 # .0 # 7 , A 0 3. 05" 5 # , 7 /# # #! 3 0 7 # '5. " 7 / 0 # 7 5 3#.0 #0 0, 0 , A 4 7 /# # =);2; " 7 0 #0 , 530 # :7 , 530 # 7 5 75 0 # ! 3 #! 3 # '5. B.,4/ -. # A -0 45 #0 0 ! : 7 450 " "+," 1+2 1+; " . 0" *;; #.0 E5 0 ! : 5 / , # :7 7 0 7 , A 4 7 /# # " ,# 5 # -0 4 7 , , 0, 5 5 # #:5$ + 0/ 4 :7 7 0 450 E5 -.5 , 5 #.0 7 5 -.5 , 5 > 7 55 3 # B., 3 , 530 # 5 7 < 5 3 # B.,4/ -A 3# 53 3 , 0 5# 5 # #5 , # 3 0 3 #.5 0- 0 0A 3 # , :7 0 #.0 7 5 # <3 , , 7 -#. ,5 # 0 5# ! : # 7 3 03./5 3 5 , 7 5 # 5# 4 #0 , 0 3#4 D , 0. 5 # : # 0 3 3 5# 5 # 0#,.3 B.5 3 5 4 , 530 # 7 5 # -.5 ,F #0 7 6. 5 # 5 # :7 7 0 7 0 ! : 4 #.0 40 5 : 7 7 #.0 - #: -. 0 7 0 :7 7 0 - ! 5 7 7 B., 3 / , ! : # 7 0 ! 0. 5 # : , . # ,. 3# 5 , 0 # # 7 3 5 # 7 3 5 3#. , 7 ! 0 5# - A 0 37 , 7 3# 3 .5 # # :7 37 3#/ 5 / , "? )%; "+, 2(& = " . 0" );1C " 7 @.5 3 # 7 .0 # 5E 3#. 5 0 5 # , # ! 3 # 0/ #.0 3# 3 ., , 3 # 753 #//. , 0 7 <3.5 - / 0 5# @.0, 7 4 3 04./ 7 0 5E , / , #0 :7 37 3#. , - 3# 5 , 0 , <3.5 - - 55 # 5 #0, 0 # @. A )+ +%%& 7 AD " 0 # 3 # 4 3" #.0 /.5 , , 4 # 0 3. 05 , , # 0 5 7 7 7 3# 5 , 0 4 35 # 7 " +%%& # 7 /# # # 0#3 , 4 +2C**2 = 7 , 7 " . 0" @" 7 ,$ > <3.5 4 3 5 4 3 :7 37 / 47 7 ! 7 3 # 0 5# - A 0., 05# . , 0 7 3 03./5 3 5" 0 55 55 , 4 4 3 0 # 3 55 0 A <3.5 4 3 " " " / 0 57#: 4 # 4 4 3 #0 3 0 55 55 : 7#. ! , 0 5# / A - , / , 5. 3 " #0 #! 0 G 4 4 3 E / A - 5# 40#55 5 # /#. # 57 0 , 0 3 F # # , ! 3 B.,4/ . # 5.37 <3.5 :#. , 3 5 # 4 ! / 4 # 7 :#0,5 <3.5 4 3 "? 7 5 .0 # 55. # # 3 0#3 , 45 7 0 #0 0 3 # 5. #0 , :#09 # , / - 3 .5 7 7 , # 5 30 .0 # 3#. 5 4 / 0A : 7#. /#0 , 4# " # 7 ! <3.5 - # / 0 A 04. 57#:5 * , 0 3 5 30 0A 5 4 3" 7 7 5 4# 5 # 7 7 , - 5 5 #0 , # .0 #. , 0 9 0 3 # 5 # 0 ! / / 55 , 05 : 0 0 5# - 4 ! , 7 , 5,5 4. 57 - 0 , - 3 .5 7 0 5 7 3#0 #0 5 # H5 " " , 07 ,/ 7 #.0 3# 3 ., , 7 , 0/ 5 5 7 # '5. B.,4/ 0 5 : 5 # 7 , 7 5 # 0 #0 #0 A : 5 0# 0 0 / ,A 5 /# A # # 7 5 7 # 7 0#3 , 45 " "@" #. , ! " = 3 #- 0 )( +%%& " 4 , 7 : 5 0 5# - : 0 3 5 ,, # 7 0 #0 0 7 #.0 , - 3 .5 7 5 . 3 # , :7 37 7 , - 4. #33.00 4 :# : 95 - #0 7 0 ,, # #.0 " 0 5, A 0 B., 3 " 7 /#! 3 3 , 0 -. 7 3#0 #0 # E5 0#3 , 45 0 /#0 5 / 0 # 7#5 #0 0 0 " # 5# 3# 3 ., " 7 3#0 #0 #0 A 3#. , 7 ! #" +%%C'%)'+2C / 5 /# # 3 :7 37 7 5 #.0 :7 0 , 7 0 -A #! 03#/ 7 5 .0 A # # 75 3 0 , #0 0 5.0 7 6. 5 # - 3#/ 5 : 0 7 5 3 # 5 0#/ 3 # 3 5" # '5. B.,4/ H5 3#. 5 A 3 # 5 9 7.5 7 5 #.0 7 , , 7 0 3#0, 5 !# , # 0 , -A 7 @.5 3 # 7 , # " - 3 .5 5" 3 03./5 # '5. B.,4/ 450 0 / 0# 0 A ,,0 55 ," 753 5 ! 3 # , 4 / 05# :#. , 7 ! 05" 0 9 5E 3#. 5 5.0 7 : 5 : 0 # 537 ,. , / 05 # , 3, 4 7 /# # ,, # , 3 0# 3 0 " 5 57#. , 7 ! 7 0 5 # 9 47 # 7 5 / , " 7 04./ 7 @.5 3 5 :7 #.0 , , # 7 3 A 4 7 5 , 05. 5 ! #.0 , 0, . , 0 @.5 3 # 7 5E 04./ C 7 3 75 # 3 3# 5 , 0 , #.0 #$ 0#- /5 0#5 5E %&" # 7 ! <3.5 - 35 7 # , 7 #0 7 5 , 4 3" #.0 7 5 3# 3 .5 # : 5 7 . 5" 7 0 #0 , # -.5 # , 530 #0 4# 4 0 5# 5 , 7 B.,4/ 0#,.3 # 5E - #: 5 7 0 -A # # A5 5 - 5 , . # # " #I 3 7 . @.,4/ " 7 5 +& 7 A# 3 #- 0 JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ < @" / 5 7 @.,4 5' 3 %2 1

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.