Cathy L. Vogl v. Laurie Davis

Annotate this Case

Download PDF

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

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.