Roderick D. Davis v. Department of Corrections, Warden Thomas Carroll, Officer Frank Kromka and Lt. Robert May

Annotate this Case

Download PDF

! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ) *+ ,,$- ) . // )) *+ / +0 *+ , * 1 0 0 * + + * )) ,, 2 + 3 * , * *+ $- ) . // )) "#$%&$%'( 420 ++ 5 5 %%8% 03 * ) *+ ,, *; + ?6@(% ) 1 6 &""' %6 &""' +4 + /4+3 ++ / +0 *+ ) + + 8&" * )0 *;+ * ++ * 3 , %66(( ) *+ ,,$- ) . 02 02 // )) *+ <= ) *+ ,,>! 1 , ,* ) , * *+ $- ) . , :4 + // )) <= ,) . 7 * 39 * ) , :4 + ,, -4 ) *; 1 + + (+1 ) %68"% , * *+ ) // ) . +1 +1 , +1 , * *+ >! 1 4+ 4 + /4 4 *+ + %" ,) 0 + *+ 0 // ) % * +1 +1 ) *+ ,,A ) 0 + * +1 + * /4 4 *+ + . +1 / C4 ; *+ 1 004* +3 1 +1 ; 0 ) +1 & ) ; *+ / 004* +3 + * * 1 , * *+ 1 + +) 0/) *+ 04 + 2 * 400 3 C4 ;0 *+ *2 ) , +1 +1 + + + 0 ) , +1 + ) 0 * 4 ) / * / ?'""% 74 + *; 0 3 * 4 ) 4 ,0 + ,) 1 /) * , +1 ; * 3 , 23 +1 ,) +3 /4 4 *+ ) , + + )) //) + * , +1 + ) *+ ,, , 0 :4 + + * ; * + +1 + * + 0 , * *+ ,/ 0 + * =0 + * + 0 > . * 0 + * * * +1 0 + * + 04 + 2 + + %68@ %86#"% < ) 4/ ! )+1 4;1 +1 ) *+ ,,A ) + *. + *, * * * +1 ) *+ ,, . *;,4))3 + * , 0 1 0 * / +1 74 + *; / + ) 0 * ) , +1 . ) *+ ,,A / / +3 * +1 + + + * 004* +3 + %" 2 + 23 +1 ;* ) ; *+ ; *4 * + * , +1 , , 74 ) , +3 + * ; * + +1 0 * +1 0/) 3 +1 + +1 + * ) *+ ,,A 4+ * *+ * ) + * + * + , 4* ))A 0 + * 0 0 ) *+ ,,A /4 4 *+ + +1 ) // ) +1 + . ) ; * 3 * ) , +3> /4 4 *+ + +1 004* +3 / + + +1 4+ ) . / +1 ) 0 0 74 + * , 74 ) , , 74 ) , 1 +3> 4 ) ) *+ ,,A + * + * 74 + *; / ,, 4+ ) 0 4/ * .1 1 + + * 1 0 , * *+ 0 * . +1 + + * ; * +10 *1 ) , +1 + +1 % =* , * *+ ) *+ ,,A , ) ) 2) + +1 0 4* 0 + * , , )4 , * *+ 1 ; * + +1 0 * +1 +1 + , = ,, 74 + +1 + +1 4) %&<2!<B! , +1 , * *+ A 0 + * ; * + +1 0 * +1 , * *+ , + + * ) / / +3 & ) 4+ 0 + *, +1 /) * + * + // +1 4;1 + +4 ))3 *; 0 * 3 0 ; , + 0 +1 + 1 )) ; . , 23 +1 , * *+ & ) *1 + * +1 ) ; )0 + ) . 4)+ , +1 + +1 + . *;,4))3 + )) ; 1 ) *+ ,,A ) *+ ,, )) ; * * .,) , )4 + , + *; 2) / *, 010 * * ,1 / , * *+ 1 ) 0 , 4 + 0 , 23 +1 * ) / / +3 1 0 + *, + + / * ) / / +3 * , * *+ *; 0 * 3 400 3 C4 ;0 *+ + ) 0 4/ * .1 1 ) , 0 * 2 ; *+ 4) %&<2!<B! , +1 +1 0 + * +1 % +1 /4 4 *+ * 4// + , , * *+ 1 + +1 0 ; )) ; +1 , )) . *;5 ) *+ ,,A ) 0 2 23 +1 ) 0 2 23 +1 + * , ;* 004* +3D & 1 + +1 ) *+ ,,A /4 4 *+ + %" # 1 + +1 +1 / & 8&" < )) * , +4 ) 2 0 ++ ) %66#! * 2) *, &""& 4 + +1 ) *+ ,,A 0 + *, * + *3 0 + ) 0 400 3 C4 ;0 *+ +1 3 04 + ) , + * +1 + +1 3 ,) . 4/ , ) * +1 * ; *4 * C4 ;0 *+ + ) 0 ?'""%D * , * *+ + / +1 + +1 + + ! * . *; +1 * +1 ) ;1+ 0 + , #&"(&@(8 + E% < ) +1 0 # )! " 4 + 04 + 2) + +1 * *$0 *+ +) + B'& . +1 , + *; / +3 # * =F G1 . +1 4+ + ) 2 + * % # , +1 &' & + * * +1 / *+ *4 * * +1 ) *+ ,,A ;* 004* +3 , 2 4 +1 ,, +1 04 + 2 ) / * + ,, ) *+ ,,A + ) + * ) 0 >! * + , +1 9 * + + 1 *3 / ) 0 0 0 + 4+ * *+ ) ) 2 ) +3 /4 4 *+ + +1 + + 1 3 <= + + + ) 0 / 4 1 + + *4 * + * ; + *; +1 + + +1 , + + + 1 * 4 * +. + / +0 *+ , + * + 1 + , 4* * *)3 ; * + + * +1 / +3 + +1 ))>! 3>! ) '66 , * *+ * "! 2 + + + + * ; * + +1 * ) *; )) <= 1 02)3 * ,, +1 +1 ! * 1 0 ) ; * 3 )) ) 0 * # , * 1 * + + # 2) + + ) 2 ) +3 , 1 4 004* +3 0 )! 1 ,) 1 + 23 +1 0/) *+ +3 +14 , * *+ / / +1 ) *+ ,,A / !" <= ) ) ; / + * *; + + * )) ; ) %68@! %8@%("' + E& = *3 . ,, + + 0 3* +2 %8@%("' + E& < &""# ?B@%% , / ; 0> + + * +1 ;* 004* +3 +1 4;1 * * %8 +1 + +1 & %%(@ %%(B < &""# + %%(B * %%((D $ . , '66 4 + ; * + 0/) 3 0 3. 1 ;* 004* +3 / * *+ > $ & , + * $ ,, * 74 ) , + %" 0 004* +3 , 0 ?'""% 1 , )) . 5 H /+ +1 . / 23 +1 ' * + +4+ * ) . , +1 *+ + + + , +1 + + +1 0 0 3 H/ )3 74 2 *+ / + 74 *; 23 4 + , 0/ + *+ C4 + * * ) 0 4 , + * 1 )) * * C4 ;0 *+ 0 ; / * )+ + +1 0 * 3 *+ +) 0 *+ 1 )) 2 . ; * + +1 + + *3 /42) ,, 0/) 3 * )4 *; +1 0 02 , *3 2 00 * * + * + + ; * 3 , +1 + + .1 +1 ) + // *+ * .1 +1 * . / 4 )3 *; 4 1 * *3 ) 4+ / *; + ) . * 74 +3 2 , *3 0 * + + + 24* ) .1 +1 , )) . *; ) 0 *+ / *+5 <%! 1 + 0 * 0/) * , 4+ , * * ** + * . +1 +1 / , 0 * , * ,, ) 4+3 74 *; + 0* + * , / ) 3 +1 *+ / + + * *, 0 *+ , + +4+ 4) ;4) + * +1 ; *+ *; . +11 ) *; , /42) )3 + ;4) + *+ +) 0 *+ / ) ; *3 +1 ,, ) 4+3 * ) *; +1 H , + * * +1 / + , +1 /42) ,, 0/) 3 0 02 *3 * .1 0 +1 /42) ,, 0/) 3 0 02 1 )) 1 4/ 3 4+1 +3D <&! 1 + 0 * 0/) * ,. * *; , +1 * * +1 2 ) , +1 + +1 /42) *+ + . 4) 2 + 2 +1 23D * <#! 1 + 0 * 0/) * ,. * . +1 4+ ; . *+ * * ;) ; * D / +1 + +1 004* +3 , C4 ; +1 ++ * 3 9 * ) * /4+3 ++ * 3 9 * ) * 0 02 , +1 9 * ) 02)3 1 )) + )) ) ) 0 4 , + * , 4* 4/ * * + 0 * *; 4+ , +1 / , 0 * , * ,, ) 4+3 2 2 )4+ D / ,4 +1 +1 + * *3 ) + * / *; ; * + +1 + + /42) ,, 0/) 3 0 02 , +1 + + +1 /) *+ ,, 1 )) 1 +1 24 * , / *; +1 2 * ,% 0 , +1 ) 0 *+ , 004* +3 + , +1 * +1 + * # %" ?'""% 4)+ , +1 74 ) , 23 +1 ) *1 + / 004* +3 / ) *+ ,, 04 + / * < ! 1 + +1 + * +1 )) ; / / +3! ,, + + 4 * + * 4 + < * +1 4+ , * + + 0 +1 + ) 0 + * , +1 , )) . *;5 * * ,1 / ** + * . +1 +1 / , 0 * * ) , * ) 4+3D <2! 1 + +1 )) ; + + 4 * 4 +. * +/ , 0 < ! 1 + +1 )) ; + + 4 * 4 +. / , 0 * ;) ; * @ *; . +1 ; , +1D . *+ * # ( &""# %66B 6''6(8 + E# < %8@%("' + E& < + +1 ) *3 , +1 , * *+ 004* +3 / 4* 2) + / 1 4 , 1 / +1 + +1 + +1 ;4) + * 0 * , +1 * 4 //)3 + , * *+ A 0 + * , + * ; *+ 004* +3 0 4+ ,0 + ; *+ , * *+ ; *+ )) +1 + + 1 )) . +1 . +1 ) ;1+ 0 + , / * 2) + +1 *+ ) ++ + + *; 2) / ,/ * ) 1 *+ * * +1 * + //) / / )3 23 / , 1 / / +3 * * *; +1 + 23 +1 0 + + 4 ) , +1 + * + ,, + ) *+ ,,A /4 4 *+ + +1 74 ) , + ) 0 + 04 + 2 * . +1 / + + +1 *+ / H + *; 74 + *; +1 / 0 ; 004* +3 / , +4 ) 2 , * ) *+ ,,A ) *+ ,,A +1 ) 0 ) 0 * , +1 * + +4+ * +1 + *, + +4 * , +1 / / +3 )) , * +1 + +1 ) *+ ,, * 4)+ , +1 * )4 )) 1 . +1 + )) * *+ 2 0 * *; 4 ) , *+4 ))3 3 * ,, ) *+ ,,A / / +3 * +1 + 1 + .1 1 * 1 ) *+4 ))3 ), + ) *+ ,, 1 4) * *+ +1 74 ) , 3 * +1 + + + *. 400 3 C4 ;0 *+ * 0 / +1 *+ +) ) ; * + +1 0 +4 * * +4 * * 0 ) 2) + +1 0 4* 1 + + 3 +1 + +1 3 3 . *;,4))3 / +0 *+ , ) *+ ,,A / / +3 * .1 +1 + 1 4) 4 ) , 0 1 0 . +1 4+ 1 + )) ; *4 * ) 0 +1 + 3 .1 * +1 3 , ) 14 +1 , +1 *, % ' & + 3+ / * 0 * + ) 0 * * ) / / +3 , 1 .1 * +1 3 , ) 2 * $ 0 + + + + * ; * + +1 0 * +1 + 0 +1 + 1 ! # )) 23 +1 +1 ) *+ ,, )) ; 4/ 0 )! *+ *+ * , + +1 74 ) , ) * + 4,, B 74 + *; +1 * / *+ + , * *+ 74 ) ,3 + * +1 . )) , 0 +1 * 74 ) , 004* +3 / + + * * 4 + 2 )) ; ,, ) 2) + 1 0 23 +1 4+ , ) 4+ / 4 )3 . +1 + )) * ! *+ * +1 + +1 0 + *, +1 3. *, + */ ) 3 * &""& #666" < 3 * ) 4/ 1 ) *+ ,, ) 0 +1 + +1 3 ;4) + * * / 4 . +1 ) , + + )) , * *+ 0 ;4) + * * / 400 3 C4 ;0 *+ , )4 + / 0 * * * 4 * 4 1 74 + *; +1 4,, 1 + * *+ , +4 ) 2 1 + * , +1 + / +0 *+ , ) , +1 + 0 * + */ ) 3 / , ) ,1 / ; *4 * 4 * ) , ) *+ ,,A / / +3 * + */ ) 3 * ) *+ ,,A 4// + +1 ( +1 0 # + , +1 23 / 0 / +0 *+ %688 +4 * * + * , /4 4 *+ + / +0 *+ , ; 3 ) *+ ,, ) , * *+ 0 * .1 1 +1 + * . *;,4))3 *+ + 0 /) * + ) 2) , *+ + +1 / + + +1 0 ) 0, / ! # * *; +1 3A ) *+ ,,A +1 3 * + / / )3 , )) . / / +3 * +1 + 1 / / +3 . 0 + , 4/ ) * + 4,, , * *+ * 1 ,1 $ *+ 2 * ;4) + * ))A )) 04 + 2 *+ *+ * +1 + +1 + 0 , %%B&&6% < ! , * *+ 4// + +1 + *; , '$ "! + + . *+ * * ;) ; * 400 3 C4 ;0 *+ * , +4 ) 2 + )) ; + * . +1 ; + * ; *+ &"! * ; * + +1 0 ) *+ ,,A , +1 ) *+ ,,A !" %!$ $ * ))3 * +1 * + *; + ) 0 ** + * . +1 +1 / , 0 * + * ))3 +1 * + 4)+ , +1 , * *; +1 * + + ) 0 3A 0 + * , ) 0 ; * + +1 0 , * 1 4)+ , +1 * +1 4 +A 2 / + + +1 4 +A , * *; , , + .1 1 2 * * 4 +,* $ , * )4 , * *+ A 0 + * , , * *+ A 0 + * , ) *+ ,,A ) 0 + * ;* 004* +3 + * * *)3 2 ) 0 + + 1 + 4 / +3 + +1 , * *+ ,, ,, ,, 0 400 3 C4 ;0 *+ 2 + +1 0 + + 4 ,0 + 4* + + + 0 * + 1 4) * +1 74 ) , 1 + 0 + *, 4,, *; )) ) 0 , * *+ ,, + *+ , +4 ) 2 + + * 0 +1 4/ * .1 1 8 / + * , 23 400 3 C4 ;0 *+ + ) 0 ; * + 1 0 23 +1 / +3 + +1 400 3 C4 ;0 *+ , * //)3 +1 *; 1 0 ) 2) 004* +3 / 004* +3 4* 0 3A + * *; +1 ))A 0 + * , +14 * 2 + + ) 0 * 1 0 0 0 004* +3 , * *+ ; *+ ; * 3 )) +14 * 1 74 ) , * + + 4+ * *+ + + ) , + + )) +1 2 / +0 *+ , +3 + * +1 /4 4 *+ + +1 +1 * +1 74 ) , ) *+ ,,A / / +3 * .1 +1 1 + / * +1 +1 + ) 0 ) 0 + * 0 + *, ; *4 * / * ) *+ ,,A * 0/) 3 ) ; *+ * + ; * + + * +1 * ) *; , )) . . +1 400 3 C4 ;0 *+ + ; * + +1 0 * +1 , *+ 400 3 C4 ;0 *+5 1 + +1 - , ) . +1 4/ * +1 ) *+ ,,A + * * 4+ * *+ ) *+ ,,A , )4 ) , + * 2 ; *+ 2 + + / * 3A + * ; *4 * +1 4 ,0 + ) , + + )) ) *+ ,,A / / +3 * / +0 *+ , 0 * , * *+ + */ ) 3 * 0 ;4) + * * *; +1 / * 3A 1 * / + * , 4 * + ( IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII : 6 9

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.