Kathy Melvin v. Playtex Apparel, Inc.

Annotate this Case

Download PDF

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

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.