Donegal Companies as subrogee of Donald W. & Shirley H. Wilson v. Horizon Home Services Inc. f/k/a Geiger Services, Inc.

Annotate this Case

Download PDF

! $" # " % ) ** + " - $ " " " . ! / 0( # $" % &'&& + ' " &' ( !" $% & '" % + , # # 1 " 2 3 " * 3 " "" " " 4" + " , 4 5 " ( 3 " 6 $" + "7 * % . % " 9: * 2 $ " " > $ + " " " **7 " 2 " * 6 " " = + "$ " " * " "4 4 * "8 " " " $ " $ $ $ ";< " *% " " $ / 3 " " ** " "4 * $ " 7 + 48 # 8 3 9: > " " " " ** ;< * *?,? " **7 5 " $ 3 ) " 4 ," 2 "4 * 4 2 ,* $ "4 " # " 3 " 6 , 2" " " $ + " >> * " + + * " >> * " "* * " " + * ? " > "" $ $ 6 " " , "4 * 3 $ 2 " " " " **7 % * * @ " " 4 " $ " AA& B' + " " $ " 3 : " " " " 3 " " 4 " $ " # $ ; 6 " 7 * " " "4 "* " 2 2 " 6 6 " + " " C $ " * 3 *% * " " ( )$ "" # $ % % " " 6 4 3 " " % " / " 3 6 4 , " 5 3 3 2 C 2 3 8 3 8 6 , * " " $" 4 "" " " 22 4 " " B " " 2 $ " " $ 8 " ** " 3 90< C " / 2 " " 3 "47 " "E / 2 " 6 $ " 9'< " $ E / 2"A6 " " 24 # ! " + # ! " > E / 2"B6 " " E / 2"(6 7 E / 2"06 " 9A< " $ 6 "4 $ 8 24 " " *" * " " " > E 4 " 6 3 5 " *" " 6 " 6 $ " " @ " " " " 4 * $ 6 " " / " " " 6 ,6 " " C "" 4 *" 24 # 6 / 2"06 * 6 "" *" " " * "6 3 3 8 * " *" " * D # " 6 " 2 % " 4 7 " **7 % " 6 ," "" # " " # " " " 4 " " " # " 2 , "4 6 " ;< 6 6 "" 5 9:% " / , / $* "" " 4 "6 9 < * "6 * 4 " " *" 4 "" 9A< $ " " , 6" " % * " / 2" 6 2 , 3 6 4 *" " " / 2" 6 * *) " " 3 * " 6 , " 3 " 3 " $" " 3 22 4 " " " " *" * 4 "" 3 * 6 " % " " 3 " " * * 6 $ * " 4 ? *" $ $ " * *3 " " 3 " " "% " $ 8 " "" " * 3 " 2 " " / " 4# " " 3 $ 6 " 6 " * ? @ "6 " $ $ " " "4 " " *" $ $ E " " " " 4 6 " 6 /" 3 / 3 " 4 $ %" 6 2 2 ,* " $ $ 4 6 2 "" $ * " " " " " 4* " " " *" 4 " 2 " 6 7 / " 6 % " 2 6 * % " . 8 ; 6 "3 $ $ * "4 $ * " 6 $ 3 6 4 "4 " " ; $ $ " * C 4" " $ 3 6 4" 6 " " , " " " " "" "" " 4 6F " " " " " " $ " " * " ; " " / ** " % " % " 4 $ " * " " : :6 6 * " 3 F / 4 : 3 6 4 6 " " . " * " " " " " " 6 , B * " 6 $ 6 $ A / " " " 4 # * 5 6 " " " 3 7 " " 24 :" $ " $ " "4 3 3 $ 2 > ; 7 " "4 6 " " " % " " 6 " 6 " " " " / 3 " " 6 2 ,* " 8 "" 9:# # 6 $" % "2 " " 4" " ;< " 9 0< 4 6 " "6 6 " 6 " " " " " " $ " " G+ " " 6 " 4 "" &BB # 6 " "E " 6 " " " 3 6 4 * $" 2C " 6 , $ 24 $ 3 6 4 # " "4 2 ,F : $$ $ " ; "4 $ 3 " " "' &# *" 3 6 46 "2 $ " " E " "6 "4 4 3 6 4 / *6 "" $ * "4F 3 4 * * $" " " $ $ 4# H 6 " " 2 $ " 6 3 " " " 4 2 $ 6" " 4 3 4" " 22 4 " " " 3 6 4 4 3 6 $ ," 2 " " * " ** " " 6 4 . F / # # "6 2 , " $ " / *" " " " 24 "? " " " 2 "6 " 6 " 4 " " " * " &A " " " 9:! " ;< * "" " 6 "4 " " "3 6 , "" 3 6 4 "4 > " " * 6 6 04 4 6 5 / " " " $ ! 6" ** " "6 " " 4 8 # " / " " * " 2 "6 ," * # 7 > / " " " "" , " "4 ! " 6 $ "" $ " 4 "6 9 < * " " 3 6 4 $ " "" " " 2 = " 6* / " $ $$ $ " "2 , " " " 3 6 4 " "" 2 6 3 6 , "" 3 6 4 * " " " 6 " 0 'A " " 6 24 / "4 " " , "4 " " " "6 F / " " " 6 % " 2 24 3 $ " " 3 7 3 6 4 4 8 " 6 , * " " C " # 3 6 4 6 , "" + 6* "4 9A < 4 " " 5 " " / # $ * " 6" " 6 " " ! "4 " " 6 " *6 " * " " " " $ " " " " " , 2 * " " 2C " 6 , 24 $ H 2 " 3 6 4 2 * 6 " 3 " " 4 $ " $ 4 " * " 6 , 2 $ E 3 * " " 2 2 " 8 / " 4 @ 8 4 ! " " " % * 6" " 3 6 4* ; $ " " , 6 8 * " 5 4 & 2C " / 2 "7 A< 8 3 6 4 * 4 * : 3 " " " $ / 3 " 2C " 6 ,E " " **7 $ 4* 9&< 4 2 3 6 46 3 " * > " " . 6 ";< " "" 4 3 6 4 8 , 4 3 C " ! " 2 " * 6 " " " 4 6 " 9:% $ 8 " 9 @ & B( ' $ # % 4 2 * $" 6 4" "" " *" H + @ " # ! " 2 6 " 24 " 2C " C 2 " " " * 5 " " $ / " 4 " " 3 3 $ B 6 * 9: 6 " " 6 $ 6 , * ;< " " * 8 $ 3 >" * " 4 * 2 / 3 " " "" * " / " 2C " 6 , $ $ $ , ; 6 $ " $ " " 6" 4 24 " " * "4 8 24 " " C 26 $ " 4" $ 6 C 2 " ; 3 " 2C " " 4" "" / $ 8 6 ,6 6* " , " 4 "4 6 $ * C 2 " * "" : " # # 3 6 42 C 6 " 6 , 46 4 8 " " " " 3 " 6 " C F / 3 " $ " , " : . 6 * "3 "4 2 ,* " 24 3 2 6 , 2 C 2 " "2 * * " 4 / 3 " " " 4 AB 6" " 22 $ 6 " " 2C " " " "4 % 3 / $ " 8 5 " $ " 22 6 " % " "6 6 :6 " 2 4 "4 " 6 2C " 2 * $ " " % 8 2 3 " " / "* " " 6 " "6 " " 6" 5 4 ; $ " 2 "6 $ $ " * C 2 " * " " :3 4 * " " $ ( * "4 " "* , 6" " $5 # ; 8 2 * " " 3 " $ AB 4 $ * " "4 8 " " * " " " 6 , # " 4 3 * 2C " 6 , 6 $ " " :" $ C 2; $ 6 6 8 6 6 $ " . 8 4 "" *" $ $ " " 43 4" , 6 " " " $ ;< 2 4 * " 9:5 " "" $ $ " " " " 6 3 4 * 3 : " " 6 ; , * " 6 4 " * " 3 * " 6 " " # 3 6 4 ( :> " 2 $ $ * " 6 6 6 " ** 3 " *" 4 (A 9B" " B'' / " 7 " C 46 6 24 3 & A " " "2 " 2 I $ " A 9 &A0< 2 "6 " ** " ** 7 # - " " +3 H &92< " - " " " 3 % $ $ * " 9A< 6 " " " B ' "2 * " *9 <6 " " "2 * ) 6 * " "4 * "4 4 & 2 " " " ** 4 6 9 <" 2 6" "4 9 <6 "4 6 % ! 9 $ $ JK 9 &' < : ; F( 5 " $ $ " && < + * "4 % "4 ; 6 $ $ " " &' < ; : 2 "7 3 % " & 95 " * " "" * I " ** " " ** : 3 " * " " " " " $* " + " ' +F &'A< $ >" " " " " " " " " " " 2 3 " **7 " " 6 , 4" "" 6 " " + " , $ * " " " " 4" " 2C " 6 , * "4 6 # * 7 " 3 $ 0 " >> * " >" " " "" , * 2" " " + " " " 3 6 + * " + "* 24 2 " $ 6 # 7 3 6 4 2 $ * * " " 4 " " 6 "" 6 , 6 " 2 $ " "4 5 * # 2 * 24 " 3 $" 24 2 $ " F " ** 24 " " # * " " " ** 2 3 6 " " 24 3 6 4 "" " $ ; "" 3 6 "6 "4 9 4 + 40 * "4 " " "* " * 4 / " " " 6" " ** * " " + " < $ " " 6 "" " + * 3 % 2 / " $ 4 " " " # 4 24 " / " 4( < % " 4 " $ ' 3 " *+ "" 7 $ " ** * ) L> BB 9 3 6 4 6 3 $ 6 3 6 4 , " / " $ *" + F 0 " $ " # 1 &&F 6 3 24 % "6 " 22 " " *+ < 9# * $$ $ 4" " "" " < 4 " 6 ! + 2 "4 " : / 3 " " $ * " 6 $ 4 24 ! " <E & 4 + "% * "4 &&&F # " ** 6 "6 $ 0 9 " " 3 6 46 $ $ ) L> 4 " " 3 6 4 9# 42 4 " " + + " " $ * " "* 2C " , * $ $ "" " " 6 , 4 * $ " " " "* " " " "4 / . 8 " "4 " * 6 " " " " 3 C 2 * * " " ** " * * *" 3 % " " " ** / " * "4 22 4 $ $ 6 " # + *" " " >" " "4 " 2 * " " . *" 6 + "" "C $ "2 8 2 " " * 3 " " " 4 * $ & - # $ *" * "

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.