Justia Daily Opinion Summaries

White Collar Crime
October 6, 2023

Table of Contents

USA v. Shah

Constitutional Law, Criminal Law, White Collar Crime

US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit

Browse upcoming and on-demand Justia Webinars

White Collar Crime Opinions

USA v. Shah

Court: US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit

Docket: 21-10292

Opinion Date: October 2, 2023

Judge: Priscilla Richman

Areas of Law: Constitutional Law, Criminal Law, White Collar Crime

Seven codefendants appeal their various convictions stemming from a multi-million-dollar healthcare conspiracy involving surgery-referral kickbacks at Forest Park Medical Center in Dallas, Texas. They challenge convictions under the Anti-Kickback Statute (“AKS”), the Travel Act, and for money laundering. The defendants in this case are, with three exceptions, the surgeons whom Forest Park paid to direct surgeries to the hospital—Won, Rimlawi, Shah, and Henry. One exception is Forrest— she is a nurse. Another is Jacob—he ran Adelaide Business Solutions (Adelaide), a pass-through entity. The other is Burt—he was part of the hospital’s staff. Defendants raise many of the same issues on appeal, often adopting each other’s arguments.
 
The Fifth Circuit affirmed. The court wrote that the state law at issue here is the Texas Commercial Bribery Statute (TCBS). Here, it does not matter if the physician was acquitted because there could still be sufficient evidence in the record that defendants “offer[ed]” a benefit in violation of the TCBS regardless of whether any physician accepted it.  Further, the court explained that even assuming no rational jury could have found a single conspiracy, the surgeons fail to show that this error “prejudiced their substantial rights.” Henry and Forrest do not raise this point at all. Won and Shah address it only briefly and fail to provide any record citations to support the proposition that “clear, specific, and compelling prejudice” resulted in an unfair trial.

Read Opinion

Are you a lawyer? Annotate this case.

Browse upcoming and on-demand Justia Webinars

About Justia Daily Opinion Summaries

Justia Daily Opinion Summaries is a free newsletter service with over 65 newsletters covering every federal appellate court and the highest court in each U.S. state.

Justia also provides weekly practice area newsletters in 60+ different practice areas. All daily and weekly Justia Newsletters are free. You may request newsletters or modify your preferences by visiting daily.justia.com.

You may freely redistribute this email in whole.

About Justia

Justia’s mission is to make law and legal resources free for all.

New on Justia Onward

Want instant updates? Get Notified

News & Notes From Google Local Services Ads: October 2023

Justia Amplify Team

onward post

Another month has come and gone, and we have updates about Google LSAs fresh from the Google Partner newsletter! Check out this post to stay in the know about what matters most for lawyers in the latest edition of this exclusive newsletter from Google.

Read More

Justia

Contact Us| Privacy Policy

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn LinkedIn Justia

Unsubscribe from this newsletter

Justia | 1380 Pear Ave #2B, Mountain View, CA 94043


Unsubscribe from all Justia Newsletters