Doe v. Burke Wise Morrissey & Kaveny, LLC

Court: Supreme Court of Illinois

Citation: 2023 IL 129097

Opinion Date: November 30, 2023

Judge: Neville

Areas of Law: Civil Procedure, Communications Law, Health Law, Medical Malpractice

The attorneys represented Doe in a medical malpractice action against a hospital and other medical staff. During that litigation, the evidence established that, after Doe was admitted to the emergency room of the hospital, he attempted suicide by stabbing himself multiple times. The hospital sought a qualified protective order under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA, 42 U.S.C. 1320d) to gain access to Doe’s protected health information and requested a subpoena pursuant to HIPAA. At trial, Doe testified in detail about his suicide attempt, his injuries therefrom, and his diagnosis., Doe was awarded $4.2 million. Subsequently, the attorneys issued a press release related to the medical malpractice trial describing Doe’s suicide attempt, the resulting injuries, and his diagnoses and commented on the medical malpractice case and Doe’s history for an article published in the Chicago Daily Law Bulletin.

Doe alleged that the attorneys violated the Mental Health and Developmental Disabilities Confidentiality Act (740 ILCS 110/1). The Illinois Supreme Court reinstated the dismissal of his case. Doe waived his claims of confidentiality under the Act by voluntarily and publicly disclosing his private health information in a public trial; the qualified protective order under HIPAA did not preclude such waiver. The evidence and testimony divulged during Doe’s medical malpractice trial were not records or communications made in the course of mental health services; therefore, the Act does not apply.

Explore the Crossroads of Legal and Business Ethics in the AI Era

Justia Team

In an era dominated by continuously changing technology, artificial intelligence has made a splash as the latest wave of change. With this change, professionals in various industries face new ethical considerations. Join Justia Webinars for an upcoming program exploring the intersection of legal and business ethics in an evolving AI landscape.

Read More