2006 Ohio Revised Code - 1303.39. (UCC 3-310) Effect of instrument on obligation for which taken.

§ 1303.39. (UCC 3-310) Effect of instrument on obligation for which taken.
 

(A)  Unless otherwise agreed, if a certified check, cashier's check, or teller's check is taken for an obligation, the obligation is discharged to the same extent discharge would result if an amount of money equal to the amount of the instrument were taken in payment of the obligation. The discharge of the obligation does not affect any liability that the obligor may have as an indorser of the instrument taken in payment of the obligation. 

(B)  Unless otherwise agreed and except as provided in division (A) of this section, if a note or an uncertified check is taken for an obligation, the obligation is suspended to the same extent the obligation would be discharged if an amount of money equal to the amount of the instrument were taken, and all of the following rules apply: 

(1) In the case of an uncertified check, suspension of the obligation continues until dishonor of the check or until it is paid or certified. Payment or certification of the check results in discharge of the obligation to the extent of the amount of the check. 

(2) In the case of a note, suspension of the obligation continues until dishonor of the note or until it is paid. Payment of the note results in discharge of the obligation to the extent of the payment. 

(3) Except as provided in division (B)(4) of this section, if the check or note is dishonored and the obligee of the obligation for which the instrument was taken is the person entitled to enforce the instrument, the obligee may enforce either the instrument or the obligation. In the case of an instrument of a third person that is negotiated to the obligee by the obligor, discharge of the obligor on the instrument also discharges the obligation. 

(4) If the person entitled to enforce the instrument taken for an obligation is a person other than the obligee, the obligee may not enforce the obligation to the extent the obligation is suspended. If the obligee is the person entitled to enforce the instrument but no longer has possession of it because it was lost, stolen, or destroyed, the obligation may not be enforced to the extent of the amount payable on the instrument, and to that extent the obligee's rights against the obligor are limited to enforcement of the instrument. 

(C)  If an instrument other than one described in division (A) or (B) of this section is taken for an obligation, division (A) of this section shall apply if the instrument is one on which a bank is liable as maker or acceptor, and division (B) of this section shall apply in all other instances. 
 

HISTORY: 145 v S 147. Eff 8-19-94.
 

Not analogous to former RC § 1303.39 (129 v S 5), repealed 145 v S 147, § 2, eff 8-19-94.

 

Official Comment

1. Section 3-310 is a modification of former section 3-802. As a practical matter, application of former section 3-802 was limited to cases in which a check or a note was given for an obligation. Subsections (a) and (b) of section 3-310 are therefore stated in terms of checks and notes in the interests of clarity.  Subsection (c) covers the rare cases in which some other instrument is given to pay an obligation. 

2. Subsection (a) deals with the case in which a certified check, cashier's check or teller's check is given in payment of an obligation.  In that case the obligation is discharged unless there is an agreement to the contrary.  Subsection (a) drops the exception in former section 3-802 for cases in which there is a right of recourse on the instrument against the obligor.  Under former section 3-802(1)(a) the obligation was not discharged if there was a right of recourse on the instrument against the obligor.  Subsection (a) changes this result.  The underlying obligation is discharged, but any right of recourse on the instrument is preserved. 

3. Subsection (b) concerns cases in which an uncertified check or a note is taken for an obligation.  The typical case is that in which a buyer pays for goods or services by giving the seller the buyer's personal check, or in which the buyer signs a note for the purchase price.  Subsection (b) also applies to the uncommon cases in which a check or note of a third person is given in payment of the obligation.  Subsection (b) preserves the rule under former section 3-802(1)(b) that the buyer's obligation to pay the price is suspended, but subsection (b) spells out the effect more precisely.  If the check or note is dishonored, the seller may sue on either the dishonored instrument or the contract of sale if the seller has possession of the instrument and is the person entitled to enforce it.  If the right to enforce the instrument is held by somebody other than the seller, the seller can't enforce the right to payment of the price under the sales contract because that right is represented by the instrument which is enforceable by somebody else.  Thus, if the seller sold the note or the check to a holder and has not reacquired it after dishonor, the only right that survives is the right to enforce the instrument. 

The last sentence of subsection (b)(3) applies to cases in which an instrument of another person is indorsed over to the obligee in payment of the obligation.  For example, Buyer delivers an uncertified personal check of X payable to the order of Buyer to Seller in payment of the price of goods. Buyer indorses the check over to Seller.  Buyer is liable on the check as indorser.  If Seller neglects to present the check for payment or to deposit it for collection within 30 days of the indorsement, Buyer's liability as indorser is discharged.  Section 3-415(e).  Under the last sentence of section 3-310(b)(3) Buyer is also discharged on the obligation to pay for the goods. 

4. There was uncertainty concerning the applicability of former section 3-802 to the case in which the check given for the obligation was stolen from the payee, the payee's signature was forged, and the forger obtained payment.  The last sentence of subsection (b)(4) addresses this issue.  If the payor bank pays a holder, the drawer is discharged on the underlying obligation because the check was paid.  Subsection (b)(1).  If the payor bank pays a person not entitled to enforce the instrument, as in the hypothetical case, the suspension of the underlying obligation continues because the check has not been paid.  Section 3-602(a).  The payee's cause of action is against the depositary bank or payor bank in conversion under section 3-420 or against the drawer under section 3-309.  In the latter case, the drawer's obligation under section 3-414(b) is triggered by dishonor which occurs because the check is unpaid.  Presentment for payment to the drawee is excused under section 3-504(a)(i) and, under section 3-502(e), dishonor occurs without presentment if the check is not paid. The payee cannot merely ignore the instrument and sue the drawer on the underlying contract. This would impose on the drawer the risk that the check when stolen was indorsed in blank or to bearer. 

A similar analysis applies with respect to lost instruments that have not been paid.  If a creditor takes a check of the debtor in payment of an obligation, the obligation is suspended under the introductory paragraph of subsection (b). If the creditor then loses the check, what are the creditor's rights?  The creditor can request the debtor to issue a new check and in many cases, the debtor will issue a replacement check after stopping payment on the lost check.  In that case both the debtor and creditor are protected.  But the debtor is not obliged to issue a new check.  If the debtor refuses to issue a replacement check, the last sentence of subsection (b)(4) applies.  The creditor may not enforce the obligation of debtor for which the check was taken.  The creditor may assert only rights on the check.  The creditor can proceed under section 3-309 to enforce the obligation of the debtor, as drawer, to pay the check. 

5. Subsection (c) deals with rare cases in which other instruments are taken for obligations.  If a bank is the obligor on the instrument, subsection (a) applies and the obligation is discharged. In any other case subsection (b) applies.