2009 California Civil Code - Section 3196-3205 :: Article 5. Release Of Stop Notice

CIVIL CODE
SECTION 3196-3205

3196.  If the original contractor or subcontractor disputes the
correctness or validity or enforceability of any stop notice, the
public entity may, in its discretion, permit the original contractor
to file with the public entity a bond executed by a corporate surety,
in an amount equal to 125 percent of the claim stated in the stop
notice conditioned for the payment of any sum which the stop notice
claimant may recover on the claim together with his costs of suit in
the action, if he recovers therein. Upon the filing of such bond with
the public entity, the public entity shall not withhold any money or
bonds (where bonds are to be issued in payment for the work of
improvement) from the original contractor on account of the stop
notice. The surety or sureties upon such bond shall be jointly and
severally liable to the stop notice claimant with the surety or
sureties upon any payment bond furnished pursuant to Chapter 7
(commencing with Section 3247).

3197.  If the original contractor asserts (1) that the claim upon
which the stop notice is based is not included within the types or
classifications of claims referred to in this article, or (2) that
the claimant is not one of the persons named in Section 3181, or (3)
that the amount of the claim as specified in the stop notice is
excessive, or (4) that there is no basis in law for the claim as
referred to and set out in the stop notice, he may have the question
determined in a summary proceedings in accordance with the provisions
of Sections 3198 to 3205, inclusive.

3198.  The original contractor shall serve upon the public entity an
affidavit and a copy thereof alleging the legal grounds upon which
he bases his claim and the facts in support thereof, and demanding
the release of all or such portion of such money or bonds as is
alleged to be withheld improperly or in an excessive amount. Such
affidavit shall also state the address of the original contractor
within this state for the purpose of permitting service by mail upon
him of any notice or legal document.

3199.  The public entity shall serve upon the claimant, either
personally or by registered or certified mail, addressed to the last
known address of the claimant, a copy of the affidavit and the demand
for release together with a written notice stating that the public
entity will release such money or bonds, or such portion of either as
has been demanded, unless the claimant files with the public entity
a counteraffidavit on or before a time designated in the notice,
which shall not be less than 10, nor more than 20 days, after service
upon the claimant of the copy of such affidavit. Proof of service
shall be made by an affidavit.

3200.  If the claimant desires to contest the original contractor's
affidavit and demand for release, he shall, within the time allowed,
serve upon the public entity a counteraffidavit alleging the details
of his claim and shall also set forth in detail the specific basis
upon which he contests or rebuts the allegations of the original
contractor's affidavit, together with proof of service of a copy of
such counteraffidavit upon the original contractor. If no such
counteraffidavit with proof of service is served upon the public
entity within the time allowed, then the public entity shall
forthwith release the money or bonds, or such portion thereof as has
been demanded by such affidavit, without further notice to the
claimant, and the public entity shall not be liable in any manner for
making such release. The public entity shall not be responsible for
the validity of the affidavit or counteraffidavit.

3201.  If such counteraffidavit, together with proof of service, is
so filed, either the original contractor or the claimant may file an
action in the appropriate superior court for a declaration of the
respective rights of the parties. After the filing of such action,
either the original contractor or the claimant shall be entitled to a
hearing by the court for the purpose of determining his rights under
the affidavit and demand for release and the counteraffidavit. Such
hearing must be granted by the court within 15 days from the date of
making of such motion, unless continued by the court for good cause.
The party making the motion for hearing must give not less than five
days' notice in writing of such hearing to the public entity and to
the other party.

3202.  At such hearing, the original contractor shall have the
burden of proof. The affidavit and counteraffidavit shall be filed
with the court by the public entity and they shall constitute the
pleadings, subject to the power of the court to permit an amendment
in the interest of justice. The affidavit of the original contractor
shall be deemed controverted by the counteraffidavit, and both shall
be received in evidence.

3203.  No findings shall be required in a summary proceeding under
this article. When the hearing is before the court sitting without a
jury and no evidence other than the affidavit and counteraffidavit is
offered, if the court is satisfied that sufficient facts are shown
thereby, it may make its determination thereon; otherwise, it shall
order the hearing continued for the production of other evidence,
oral or documentary, or the filing of other affidavits and
counteraffidavits. At the conclusion of the hearing, the court shall
make and enter its order determining whether the demand for release
shall be allowed or not, which order shall be determinative as to the
right of the claimant to have the money or bonds further withheld by
the public entity. The original contractor shall serve a copy of
such order on the public entity.

3204.  Nothing contained in this article shall be construed to
deprive any party of the right to a trial by jury in any case where
such right is given by the California Constitution, but a jury trial
may be waived in like manner as in the trial of an action.

3205.  No determination in the summary proceedings under this
article shall be res judicata with respect to any right of action by
the claimant against either principal or surety on any labor and
material bond or with respect to any right of action against any
party personally liable to the claimant.

Disclaimer: These codes may not be the most recent version. California may have more current or accurate information. We make no warranties or guarantees about the accuracy, completeness, or adequacy of the information contained on this site or the information linked to on the state site. Please check official sources.