In Re: Willie Upshaw--Appeal from 114th District Court of Smith County (majority)

Annotate this Case
HTTP/1.1 200 OK Cache-Control: private Content-Type: application/pdf Server: Microsoft-IIS/7.5 Content-Disposition: inline; filename=CCAOpinion.pdf X-Powered-By: ASP.NET Date: Fri, 01 Jun 2012 16:49:58 GMT Connection: close %PDF-1.5 %ãÏÓ 79 0 obj endobj 92 0 obj stream hÞbbd``b`êŒM BH°>‰¹ˆ{ ¢H0çXæ D°€ˆ}@Ù_&F:FbˆÿŒ? Y  endstream endobj startxref 0 %%EOF 102 0 obj stream hÞb```a``Še`f`¨fàd@N&  dž‡ Ò 8€,  +CÀ> Í Ä< ¥ŒŠ \ 6!öFˆßøPœoêU £mqY½üR7OÏ-3¦,~ª;ÕYTW‹êiËJU\­WíÅÅúŸ»3LŽI>îQ{U-›Å·n›e½e×õßìózY­~DÝuµ¬ Ôöÿ~óÛ-ªnÚMÝ>ˆ\Pú@!BS òå.Áò€Æ$Z0Dÿyô>zÄ>´ßMóGm^Ì+Óå,F"ÇD+5z9P·¢«~Ò¯Ù…§@¸ÿ/ÀAúé¿ endstream endobj 3 0 obj stream ÿ2Ô2Ë©"ÁRd8,ÎÒÁæ|ÌÌÀbüÓS0yÚ¨!³NÓD܇ڠ "ý3Á ˆGw~¬l´ì¬"}~'ÿôÎ ŒpýÚkØ8 ¯i¦š{ ¿Eֈ°Úb*°„F;Ú0Cá‡ì JÒ"'¬"+…Ù¨™`ma‡7dM$(R;p !,:'"¤œpÙ 2ù8`ôE8K`7rV2pønÁXanDnìÚD0}º&;b$ô6xa ao¦"aŒ'.D‡¤Øa, ©íVÎ6Ý šxëa‡Vè6!wû`¶(a{¥haÓt[¶äï%†Û¥¤˜ÞÙÅò1 UÒtÿz¤a ¥ ˜onµí°"§wé8nE 0¯zúvÕº`Õ¾ºK†Ý;Jï ùÅM¸nG(|n©.Å7KI;nº°Q C¥w„AÚHS.Ž"H˜íÝÈÁ+¶&AöØbÚHŽnè„ô‡š5ˆ^ÚtÐI須`ÚTÓDwEIbÐ"pr¬9:]·nÒ ÉàpFH¸©7·]$ÚqŠ %†)ºQH¸tј¥dœZÓI| Df€³s¤ÖÞ `·tEäíð 0ÛiÐmm؄|0Ź}R~A ½º,v‘¶íØ@`Á±MÒÒ±nAˆ6íê)6ÐAYDs 0á]&x ‘iÄ ¶µ¤X†[;£¶k0Ù*xNt™ Á56g² ˜jÚy¦' PDdžBÙ0a¦ÚtÕ"h ‘!ñRœ$˜pr­·tÒ ¤½$)&!°Å¶äAý-8AKL0ÛqMў•„é)Ç ^ÅAq/¶›·KÔ* W Ca«0á~)‹'‘‹á7 6›mÒjA|¥H˜ê¦(vÚot8ê‘~# `qm§oQÚpLØe…#°„víÒ#šL*I4![˜xm´›l𘺠%KD4"Älh.×j:HL'a¶•·uI$ [¶[k˜}'A‡m´'àˆõbŠ¹$¦xl"œ6ÎiBcoO"d »n!S]&šKL‘Gm´F)‡Mè¢ $ˆŶGÈì;m[}i¤‘n»mµ»é]$Œ ­"ám¶Òwu# h$= û´sÒKA¢#‘6Dˆ@›mØZzMÈg€ÈãPÇÝá7¼ãÒ^B Ž!ÁðØ°mˆVúÇIRulNÛ ÝÒi.?Û Ù ?éh†c[Ûmíè2ÇI"(ä+t¾ÁîÍÁ&ÙÇ]Iì!‡-mÅÛlSÞ©)±H„ïoÝõ1é$‡Û..>Ù y„]&8Jï*îÛ N͙ÒzG›8änmÁ±o :uÓ± !Ü0Èæ\ÚA%k'Ùc¡^"¾A1zÒ@ˆü{l"ÛxCÕ­-nUì>ý‹Gµ¤ÉCۍ½·¯†aú3‹©þý‘þæ=F'eŽµnþÛlÞ7¯bû3>D¯¿.ÒKW¶îÛ«}PH%m‹½«Íã˚A0ëضÙB:*"Ž"•°ÈhŠm­zD…Çï¶q/þ )u¶÷ÚÅé¨L=äc¥ëxjÈGöî"8êB¹aN߸kõ^†…+éì‰d_;«Ö²9Õ Ýݸ¬~ÁôŒë·ù¢Ûÿzä3'ݝþÐ4{ú˜´5)0»"G›5ï„ù:ö»è]˜?"~>ß½rèxäÄ©Å®ßm¤_o¶Î>/6?yǯzö\1°Ç^xñ[ ÈàïBÈAúd‡Tf R¬q¡wSŽŸ†³Pu ˆØcD5 ¸ý­¯ŽKDàe : ¯L§õð~"Àluooú›ö¹ÝG¤RŠOô÷t½zêgûÿN½i$˜7JÜ/Ùüf¤QtA¶µ¿¡ëµÒ¶)t oGö¿†GKÄl$ïüþ#¬0Þ o^àûï«l ( „GÞ>w"iû-þɘ7@'²>ò‡ô „=‘ã_ì IYûÅ ¯óŽÈᝆè$7žXÿJAx ÊOJÁ ûþbYT5=Õ0n¬Ž é[ðŸ»ìFÁºñY‹Äc×,x`ÛA ¥ ˆýÐÇL…kªÍá¡ÿéa%×Ú ÿí°lRÇû¿0ók'ZÈAÛ Ø8$¶ø_Ø"?ktÅf͈$ ˆõ_Ø"?¦„4¶4$˜+¤½uñãÁ¤hºK×ð°ÿá"8ö -·Kácÿ±­†¿Òá7~P`ˆú²  -ŠKÚý„éE+&84®4‹øæ×ã † X4¬Ž=sþ?¢þàCG©CŠCÑzÿ°in•_×V+CèÎüõ‘GL%~AwðAýõŠ`¿„ ?ìÐ͞©:½‘®©ìûŽ¥:熌T®³Ž«¤é¯ðŠ÷V(UÇý[ºJ­Ý"‡­Hï×ð_J‘G¥úOüÛò@[ëWA#OøÌ^ž8£ÏÞ)jÒÇ&;OVé}( _÷»£Uä é.ñ~ý¹ ýë~5b'Èl{aýuWäu÷d1?è^ë¡ iÖS‘Îä‡ÈDøãUnaÝl Kkáyj,ýºX0¨aVǬï¥xÔ_Û· ¸íõ¹1ÈÇt?ÿ8^ªëFß½ZH/½‘Å#„þlÈü;MÒJ"yÇƨ]mÎ?¥Ó~+¦×·Ç û#‡/Tãþ~ &šL4›h1Q×Ú°³a¶a±ao¶bÎÌٚ9[4g«Æ¶jl«Æ¶jl«Æ¶jl©¦ÞþéIý›^EÒ+c[WZ/ØÖnnË&¦l×õŸ$Ynéö;¶ª§Þjs ¼nìñlI\9UEîR6w¿ þåîù‘ãl˜mXlØÛp°áhɆ³ YÖd3uûÚ)ó )¦Gُ ïüò£º]é¿¢[Ï­¨çVäs+úñŠ~¼æ»ãñ·÷¯@œ¥ endstream endobj 7 0 obj stream 2012-05-30T15:22:37-05:00 2012-05-30T15:22:37-05:00 2012-05-30T15:22:37-05:00 Acrobat PDFMaker 10.0 for Word uuid:b39b5e2e-accb-48c7-8c3a-f87a01d4d091 uuid:888992de-e625-4b7e-baf5-98765cf5d502 3 application/pdf batwood Adobe PDF Library 10.0 D:20120529152812 State of Texas endstream endobj 8 0 obj stream hÞ27W0P°±ÑwÎ/Í+Q0Ò÷ÎL)Ž¶0 )€ÉXýÊTý€ÄôÔb;;€&l ý endstream endobj 9 0 obj stream hÞ|Í͊@àWé›"šÎHЕ ˆÁ‹+ {žd:8þ¤¥ y{[ÞŠ¢øj¸ Œ0ñˆ@%ˆ"˜ À¿e ª endstream endobj startxref 116 %%EOF

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.